Individually optimized commercial road transport: A decision support system for customizable routing problems

The Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) in its manifold variants is widely discussed in scientific literature. We investigate related optimization models and solution methods to determine the state of research for vehicle routing attributes and their combinations. Most of these approaches are idealized and focus on single problem-tailored routing applications. Addressing this research gap, we present a customizable VRP for optimized road transportation embedded into a Decision Support System (DSS). It integrates various model attributes and handles a multitude of real-world routing problems. In the context of urban logistics, practitioners of different industries and researchers are assisted in efficient route planning that allows for minimizing driving distances and reducing vehicle emissions. Based on the design science research methodology, we evaluate the DSS with computational benchmarks and real-world simulations. Results indicate that our developed DSS can compete with problem-tailored algorithms. With our solution-oriented DSS as final artifact, we contribute to an enhanced economic and environmental sustainability in urban logistic applications

Distance-constrained vehicle routing problem: exact and approximate solution (mathematical programming)

This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University.The asymmetric distance-constrained vehicle routing problem (ADVRP) looks at finding vehicle tours to connect all customers with a depot, such that the total distance is minimised; each customer is visited once by one vehicle; every tour starts and ends at a depot; and the travelled distance by each vehicle is less than or equal to the given maximum value. We present three basic results in this thesis. In the first one, we present a general flow-based formulation to ADVRP. It is suitable for symmetric and asymmetric instances. It has been compared with the adapted Bus School Routing formulation and appears to solve the ADVRP faster. Comparisons are performed on random test instances with up to 200 customers. We reach a conclusion that our general formulation outperforms the adapted one. Moreover, it finds the optimal solution for small test instances quickly. For large instances, there is a high probability that an optimal solution can be found or at least improve upon the value of the best feasible solution found so far, compared to the other formulation which stops because of the time condition. This formulation is more general than Kara formulation since it does not require the distance matrix to satisfy the triangle inequality. The second result improves and modifies an old branch-and-bound method suggested by Laporte et al. in 1987. It is based on reformulating a distance-constrained vehicle routing problem into a travelling salesman problem and uses the assignment problem as a lower bounding procedure. In addition, its algorithm uses the best-first strategy and new branching rules. Since this method was fast but memory consuming, it would stop before optimality is proven. Therefore, we introduce randomness in choosing the node of the search tree in case we have more than one choice (usually we choose the smallest objective function). If an optimal solution is not found, then restart is required due to memory issues, so we restart our procedure. In that way, we get a multistart branch and bound method. Computational experiments show that we are able to exactly solve large test instances with up to 1000 customers. As far as we know, those instances are much larger than instances considered for other VRP models and exact solution approaches from recent literature. So, despite its simplicity, this proposed algorithm is capable of solving the largest instances ever solved in literature. Moreover, this approach is general and may be used in solving other types of vehicle routing problems. In the third result, we use VNS as a heuristic to find the best feasible solution for groups of instances. We wanted to determine how far the difference is between the best feasible solution obtained by VNS and the value of optimal solution in order to use the output of VNS as an initial feasible solution (upper bound procedure) to improve our multistart method. Unfortunately, based on the search strategy (best first search), using a heuristic to find an initial feasible solution is not useful. The reason for this is because the branch and bound is able to find the first feasible solution quickly. In other words, in our method using a good initial feasible solution as an upper bound will not increase the speed of the search. However, this would be different for the depth first search. However, we found a big gap between VNS feasible solution and an optimal solution, so VNS can not be used alone unless for large test instances when other exact methods are not able to find any feasible solution because of memory or stopping conditions

Mathematical formulations and optimization algorithms for solving rich vehicle routing problems.

Objectives and methods of study: The main objective of this work is to analyze and solve three different rich selective Vehicle Routing Problems (VRPs). The first problem is a bi-objective variant of the well-known Traveling Purchaser Problem (TPP) in which the purchased products are delivered to customers. This variant aims to find a route for which the total cost (transportation plus purchasing costs) and the sum of the customers’s waiting time are simultaneously minimized. A mixed integer bi-objective programming formulation of the problem is presented and tested with CPLEX 12.6 within an ǫ-constraint framework which fails to find non-dominated solutions for instances containing more than 10 nodes. Therefore, a heuristic based on relinked local search and Variable Neighborhood Search (VNS) is proposed to approximate the Pareto front for large instances. The proposed heuristic was tested over a large set of artificial instances of the problem. Computational results over small-sized instances show that the heuristic is competitive with the ǫ-constraint method. Also, computational tests over large-sized instances were carried out in order to study how the characteristics of the instances impact the algorithm performance. The second problem consists of planning a selective delivery schedule of multiple products. The problem is modeled as a multi-product split delivery capacitated team orienteering problem with incomplete services, and soft time windows. The problem is modeled through a mixed integer linear programming formulation and approximated by means of a multi-start Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search (ALNS) metaheuristic. Computational results show that the multi-start metaheuristic reaches better results than its classical implementation in which a single solution is build and then improved. Finally, an Orienteering Problem (OP) with mandatory visits and conflicts, is formulated through five mixed integer linear programming models. The main difference among them lies in the way they handle the subtour elimination constraints. The models were tested over a large set of instances of the problem. Computational experiments reveal that the model which subtour elimination constraints are based on a single-commodity flow formulation allows CPLEX 12.6 to obtain the optimal solution for more instances than the other formulations within a given computation time limit. Contributions: The main contributions of this thesis are: • The introduction of the bi-objective TPP with deliveries since few bi-objective versions of the TPP have been studied in the literature. Furthermore, to the best of our knowledge, there is only one more work that takes into account deliveries in a TPP. • The design and implementation of a hybrid heuristic based on relinked local search and VNS to solve the bi-objective TPP with deliveries. Additionally, we provide guidelines for the application of the heuristic when different characteristics of the instances are observed. • The design and implementation of a multi-start adaptive large neighborhood search to solve a selective delivery schedule problem. • The experimental comparison among different formulations for an OP with mandatory nodes and conflicts

Orienteering Problem: A survey of recent variants, solution approaches and applications

National Research Foundation (NRF) Singapore under International Research Centres in Singapore Funding Initiativ

Innovative Hybrid Approaches for Vehicle Routing Problems

This thesis deals with the efficient resolution of Vehicle Routing Problems (VRPs). The first chapter faces the archetype of all VRPs: the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP). Despite having being introduced more than 60 years ago, it still remains an extremely challenging problem. In this chapter I design a Fast Iterated-Local-Search Localized Optimization algorithm for the CVRP, shortened to FILO. The simplicity of the CVRP definition allowed me to experiment with advanced local search acceleration and pruning techniques that have eventually became the core optimization engine of FILO. FILO experimentally shown to be extremely scalable and able to solve very large scale instances of the CVRP in a fraction of the computing time compared to existing state-of-the-art methods, still obtaining competitive solutions in terms of their quality. The second chapter deals with an extension of the CVRP called the Extended Single Truck and Trailer Vehicle Routing Problem, or simply XSTTRP. The XSTTRP models a broad class of VRPs in which a single vehicle, composed of a truck and a detachable trailer, has to serve a set of customers with accessibility constraints making some of them not reachable by using the entire vehicle. This problem moves towards VRPs including more realistic constraints and it models scenarios such as parcel deliveries in crowded city centers or rural areas, where maneuvering a large vehicle is forbidden or dangerous. The XSTTRP generalizes several well known VRPs such as the Multiple Depot VRP and the Location Routing Problem. For its solution I developed an hybrid metaheuristic which combines a fast heuristic optimization with a polishing phase based on the resolution of a limited set partitioning problem. Finally, the thesis includes a final chapter aimed at guiding the computational evaluation of new approaches to VRPs proposed by the machine learning community