Understanding the limits of LoRaWAN

The quick proliferation of LPWAN networks, being LoRaWAN one of the most adopted, raised the interest of the industry, network operators and facilitated the development of novel services based on large scale and simple network structures. LoRaWAN brings the desired ubiquitous connectivity to enable most of the outdoor IoT applications and its growth and quick adoption are real proofs of that. Yet the technology has some limitations that need to be understood in order to avoid over-use of the technology. In this article we aim to provide an impartial overview of what are the limitations of such technology, and in a comprehensive manner bring use case examples to show where the limits are

Survey on wireless technology trade-offs for the industrial internet of things

Aside from vast deployment cost reduction, Industrial Wireless Sensor and Actuator Networks (IWSAN) introduce a new level of industrial connectivity. Wireless connection of sensors and actuators in industrial environments not only enables wireless monitoring and actuation, it also enables coordination of production stages, connecting mobile robots and autonomous transport vehicles, as well as localization and tracking of assets. All these opportunities already inspired the development of many wireless technologies in an effort to fully enable Industry 4.0. However, different technologies significantly differ in performance and capabilities, none being capable of supporting all industrial use cases. When designing a network solution, one must be aware of the capabilities and the trade-offs that prospective technologies have. This paper evaluates the technologies potentially suitable for IWSAN solutions covering an entire industrial site with limited infrastructure cost and discusses their trade-offs in an effort to provide information for choosing the most suitable technology for the use case of interest. The comparative discussion presented in this paper aims to enable engineers to choose the most suitable wireless technology for their specific IWSAN deployment

2D Time-frequency interference modelling using stochastic geometry for performance evaluation in Low-Power Wide-Area Networks

In wireless networks, interferences between trans- missions are modelled either in time or frequency domain. In this article, we jointly analyze interferences in the time- frequency domain using a stochastic geometry model assuming the total time-frequency resources to be a two-dimensional plane and transmissions from Internet of Things (IoT) devices time- frequency patterns on this plane. To evaluate the interference, we quantify the overlap between the information packets: provided that the overlap is not too strong, the packets are not necessarily lost due to capture effect. This flexible model can be used for multiple medium access scenarios and is especially adapted to the random time-frequency access schemes used in Low-Power Wide-Area Networks (LPWANs). By characterizing the outage probability and throughput, our approach permits to evaluate the performance of two representative LPWA technologies Sigfox{\textsuperscript \textregistered} and LoRaWA{\textsuperscript \textregistered}

Distributed scheduling algorithms for LoRa-based wide area cyber-physical systems

Low Power Wide Area Networks (LPWAN) are a class of wireless communication protocols that work over long distances, consume low power and support low datarates. LPWANs have been designed for monitoring applications, with sparse communication from nodes to servers and sparser from servers to nodes. Inspite of their initial design, LPWANs have the potential to target applications with higher and stricter requirements like those of Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS). Due to their long-range capabilities, LPWANs can specifically target CPS applications distributed over a wide-area, which is referred to as Wide-Area CPS (WA-CPS). Augmenting WA-CPSs with wireless communication would allow for more flexible, low-cost and easily maintainable deployment. However, wireless communications come with problems like reduced reliability and unpredictable latencies, making them harder to use for CPSs. With this intention, this thesis explores the use of LPWANs, specifically LoRa, to meet the communication and control requirements of WA-CPSs. The thesis focuses on using LoRa due to its high resilience to noise, several communication parameters to choose from and a freely modifiable communication stack and servers making it ideal for research and deployment. However, LoRaWAN suffers from low reliability due to its ALOHA channel access method. The thesis posits that "Distributed algorithms would increase the protocol's reliability allowing it to meet the requirements of WA-CPSs". Three different application scenarios are explored in this thesis that leverage unexplored aspects of LoRa to meet their requirements. The application scenarios are delay-tolerant vehicular networks, multi-stakeholder WA-CPS deployments and water distribution networks. The systems use novel algorithms to facilitate communication between the nodes and gateways to ensure a highly reliable system. The results outperform state-of-art techniques to prove that LoRa is currently under-utilised and can be used for CPS applications.Open Acces

A platform for aggregate computing over LoRaWAN network

Recent technological developments led to increased computational and networking capabilities of everyday objects. This situation resulted in an increase in number of devices embedded in cyber-physical systems. In order to simplify the design and management of pervasive and heterogeneous systems like these, there is need for new high-level paradigms able to capture concerns like heterogeneity and location of the devices. Aggregate computing is one of these: it proposes to describe the global behaviour of a system by managing global spatio-temporal data structures, and abstracting details of its physical network, as topology and communication technology. A related problem with the design of complex pervasive systems is verifying their behaviour in a real scenario, because it is generally expensive, complicated, and not always possible in practice. A partial solution to the problem is testing this kind of systems using simulations. Even though simulations execute a system model, it should be noted that such model is only a system abstraction; however they can still provide reliable insights on the system behaviour and performance. In the Internet-of-Things context, an emergent enabling communication technology for situated devices is LoRaWAN. LoRaWAN is a network protocol that allows long range communications and low energy consumption, at the cost of limited data rate. There are currently no platforms for aggregated languages that support their execution over LoRaWAN networks. Moreover nowadays there are no simulators supporting real simulation of aggregate system over LoRaWAN networks: however there are simulators supporting aggregate applications or LoRaWAN networks. The contribution of this thesis is to provide a platform that supports the LoRaWAN abstractions as backend of an aggregate computing system, and join it to the existing DingNet simulator achieving a platform allowing aggregate applications simulations over realistic LoRaWAN networks

Towards LoRa mesh networks for the IoT

There are several LPWAN radio technologies providing wireless communication to the billions of connected devices that form the so-called IoT. Among them, LoRa has emerged in recent years as a popular solution for low power embedded devices to transmit data at long distances on a reduced energy budget. Most often, LoRa is used as the physical layer of LoRaWAN, an open standard that defines a MAC layer and specifies the star-of-stars topology, operation, roles and mechanisms for an integrated, full-stack IoT architecture. Nowadays, millions of devices use LoRaWAN networks in all sorts of agriculture, smart cities and buildings, industry, logistics and utilities scenarios. Despite its success in all sorts of IoT domains and environments, there are still use cases that would benefit from more flexible network topologies than LoRaWAN's star-of-stars. For instance, in scenarios where the deployment and operation of the backbone network infrastructure is technically or economically challenging, a more flexible model may improve certain performance metrics. As a first major contribution, this thesis investigates the effects of adding multi-hop capability to LoRaWAN, by means of the realistic use case of a communication system based on this architecture that provides a coordinated response in the aftermath of natural disasters like an earthquake. The capacity of end nodes to forward packets and perform multi-hop transmissions is explored, as a strategy to overcome gateway infrastructure failures, and analyzed for challenges, benefits and drawbacks in a massive system with thousands of devices. LoRa is also used as a stand-alone radio technology, independently from the LoRaWAN architecture. Its CSS modulation offers many advantages in LPWANs for IoT deployments. In particular, its different SFs available determine a trade-off between transmission time (i.e., data rate) and sensitivity (i.e., distance reach), and also generate quasi-orthogonal signals that can be demodulated concurrently by different receivers. The second major contribution of this thesis is the design of a minimalistic distance-vector routing protocol for embedded IoT devices featuring a LoRa transceiver, and the proposal of a path cost calculation metric that takes advantage of the multi-SF capability to reduce end-to-end transmission time. The protocol is evaluated through simulation and compared with other well-known routing strategies, analyzing and discussing its suitability for heterogeneous IoT LoRa mesh networks.Hi ha diverses tecnologies de ràdio LPWAN que proporcionen comunicació sense fils als milers de milions de dispositius connectats que conformen l'anomenada IoT. D'entre elles, LoRa ha emergit en els darrers anys com una solució popular per a què dispositius encastats amb pocs recursos transmetin dades a llargues distàncies amb un cost energètic reduït. Tot sovint, LoRa s'empra com la capa física de LoRaWAN, un estàndard obert que defineix una capa MAC i que especifica la topologia en estrella d'estrelles, l'operació, els rols i els mecanismes per implementar una arquitectura de la IoT integrada. A dia d'avui, milions de dispositius fan servir xarxes LoRaWAN en escenaris d'agricultura, edificis i ciutats intel·ligents, indústria, logística i subministraments. Malgrat el seu èxit en tot tipus d'entorns i àmbits de la IoT, encara romanen casos d'ús que es beneficiarien de topologies de xarxa més flexibles que l'estrella d'estrelles de LoRaWAN. Per exemple, en escenaris on el desplegament i l'operació de la infraestructura troncal de xarxa és tècnicament o econòmica inviable, una topologia més flexible podria millorar certs aspectes del rendiment. Com a primera contribució principal, en aquesta tesi s'investiguen els efectes d'afegir capacitat de transmissió multi-salt a LoRaWAN, mitjançant el cas d'ús realista d'un sistema de comunicació, basat en aquesta arquitectura, per proporcionar una resposta coordinada en els moments posteriors a desastres naturals, tals com un terratrèmol. En concret, s'explora l'estratègia d'afegir la capacitat de reenviar paquets als nodes finals per tal d'eludir les fallades en la infraestructura, i se n'analitzen els reptes, beneficis i inconvenients per a un sistema massiu amb milers de dispositius LoRa s'empra també com a tecnologia de ràdio de forma autònoma, independentment de l'arquitectura LoRaWAN. La seva modulació CSS li confereix molts avantatges en xarxes LPWAN per a desplegaments de la IoT. En particular, els diferents SFs disponibles hi determinen un compromís entre la durada de les transmissions (i.e., la taxa de dades) i la sensibilitat en la recepció (i.e., l'abast en distància), alhora que generen senyals quasi-ortogonals que poden ser desmodulades de forma concurrent per receptors diferents. La segona contribució principal d'aquesta tesi és el disseny d'un protocol d'encaminament dinàmic vector-distància per a dispositius de la IoT encastats amb un transceptor LoRa, i la proposta d'una mètrica per calcular el cost d'un camí que aprofita la capacitat multi-SF per minimitzar el temps de transmissió d'extrem a extrem. El protocol és avaluat mitjançant simulacions i comparat amb altres estratègies d'encaminament conegudes, analitzant la seva conveniència per a xarxes LoRa mallades per a la IoT.Existen varias tecnologías de radio LPWAN que proporcionan comunicación inalámbrica a los miles de millones de dispositivos conectados que forman el llamado IoT. De entre ellas, LoRa ha emergido en los últimos años como una solución popular para que dispositivos embebidos con pocos recursos transmitan datos a largas distancias con un coste energético reducido. Habitualmente, LoRa se usa como la capa física de LoRaWAN, un estándar abierto que define una capa MAC y que especi_ca la topología en estrella de estrellas, la operación, los roles y los mecanismos para implantar una arquitectura del IoT integrada. A día de hoy, millones de dispositivos utilizan redes LoRaWAN en escenarios de agricultura, edificios y ciudades inteligentes, industria, logística y suministros. A pesar de su éxito en todo tipo de entornos y ámbitos del IoT, existen casos de uso que se beneficiaran de topologías de red más flexibles que la estrella de estrellas de LoRaWAN. Por ejemplo, en escenarios en los que el despliegue y la operación de la infraestructura troncal de red es técnica o económicamente inviable, una topología más flexible podrá mejorar ciertos aspectos del rendimiento. Como primera contribución principal, en esta tesis se investigan los efectos de añadir capacidad de transmisión multi-salto a LoRaWAN, mediante el caso de uso realista de un sistema de comunicación basado en dicha arquitectura, para proporcionar una respuesta coordinada en los momentos posteriores a desastres naturales, tales como un terremoto. En concreto, se explora la estrategia de añadir la capacidad de reenviar paquetes a los nodos finales para sortear las fallas en la infraestructura, y se analizan los retos, beneficios e inconvenientes para un sistema masivo con miles de dispositivos. LoRa se usa también como tecnología de radio de forma autónoma, independientemente de la arquitectura LoRaWAN. Su modulación CSS le confiere muchas ventajas en redes LPWAN para despliegues de IoT. En particular, los distintos SFs disponibles determinan un compromiso entre la duración de las transmisiones (i.e., la tasa de datos) y la sensibilidad en la recepción (i.e., el alcance en distancia), a la vez que generan señales cuasi-ortogonales que pueden ser desmoduladas de forma concurrente por receptores distintos. En segundo lugar, esta tesis contiene el diseño de un protocolo de enrutamiento dinámico vector-distancia para dispositivos Internet of Things (IoT) embebidos con un transceptor LoRa, y propone una métrica para calcular el coste de un camino que aprovecha la capacidad multi-SF para minimizar el tiempo de transmisión de extremo a extremo. El protocolo es evaluado y comparado con otras estrategias de enrutamiento conocidas, analizando su conveniencia para redes LoRa malladas para el IoT.Postprint (published version