Null convention logic circuits for asynchronous computer architecture

For most of its history, computer architecture has been able to benefit from a rapid scaling in semiconductor technology, resulting in continuous improvements to CPU design. During that period, synchronous logic has dominated because of its inherent ease of design and abundant tools. However, with the scaling of semiconductor processes into deep sub-micron and then to nano-scale dimensions, computer architecture is hitting a number of roadblocks such as high power and increased process variability. Asynchronous techniques can potentially offer many advantages compared to conventional synchronous design, including average case vs. worse case performance, robustness in the face of process and operating point variability and the ready availability of high performance, fine grained pipeline architectures. Of the many alternative approaches to asynchronous design, Null Convention Logic (NCL) has the advantage that its quasi delay-insensitive behavior makes it relatively easy to set up complex circuits without the need for exhaustive timing analysis. This thesis examines the characteristics of an NCL based asynchronous RISC-V CPU and analyses the problems with applying NCL to CPU design. While a number of university and industry groups have previously developed small 8-bit microprocessor architectures using NCL techniques, it is still unclear whether these offer any real advantages over conventional synchronous design. A key objective of this work has been to analyse the impact of larger word widths and more complex architectures on NCL CPU implementations. The research commenced by re-evaluating existing techniques for implementing NCL on programmable devices such as FPGAs. The little work that has been undertaken previously on FPGA implementations of asynchronous logic has been inconclusive and seems to indicate that asynchronous systems cannot be easily implemented in these devices. However, most of this work related to an alternative technique called bundled data, which is not well suited to FPGA implementation because of the difficulty in controlling and matching delays in a 'bundle' of signals. On the other hand, this thesis clearly shows that such applications are not only possible with NCL, but there are some distinct advantages in being able to prototype complex asynchronous systems in a field-programmable technology such as the FPGA. A large part of the value of NCL derives from its architectural level behavior, inherent pipelining, and optimization opportunities such as the merging of register and combina- tional logic functions. In this work, a number of NCL multiplier architectures have been analyzed to reveal the performance trade-offs between various non-pipelined, 1D and 2D organizations. Two-dimensional pipelining can easily be applied to regular architectures such as array multipliers in a way that is both high performance and area-efficient. It was found that the performance of 2D pipelining for small networks such as multipliers is around 260% faster than the equivalent non-pipelined design. However, the design uses 265% more transistors so the methodology is mainly of benefit where performance is strongly favored over area. A pipelined 32bit x 32bit signed Baugh-Wooley multiplier with Wallace-Tree Carry Save Adders (CSA), which is representative of a real design used for CPUs and DSPs, was used to further explore this concept as it is faster and has fewer pipeline stages compared to the normal array multiplier using Ripple-Carry adders (RCA). It was found that 1D pipelining with ripple-carry chains is an efficient implementation option but becomes less so for larger multipliers, due to the completion logic for which the delay time depends largely on the number of bits involved in the completion network. The average-case performance of ripple-carry adders was explored using random input vectors and it was observed that it offers little advantage on the smaller multiplier blocks, but this particular timing characteristic of asynchronous design styles be- comes increasingly more important as word size grows. Finally, this research has resulted in the development of the first 32-Bit asynchronous RISC-V CPU core. Called the Redback RISC, the architecture is a structure of pipeline rings composed of computational oscillations linked with flow completeness relationships. It has been written using NELL, a commercial description/synthesis tool that outputs standard Verilog. The Redback has been analysed and compared to two approximately equivalent industry standard 32-Bit synchronous RISC-V cores (PicoRV32 and Rocket) that are already fabricated and used in industry. While the NCL implementation is larger than both commercial cores it has similar performance and lower power compared to the PicoRV32. The implementation results were also compared against an existing NCL design tool flow (UNCLE), which showed how much the results of these implementation strategies differ. The Redback RISC has achieved similar level of throughput and 43% better power and 34% better energy compared to one of the synchronous cores with the same benchmark test and test condition such as input sup- ply voltage. However, it was shown that area is the biggest drawback for NCL CPU design. The core is roughly 2.5× larger than synchronous designs. On the other hand its area is still 2.9× smaller than previous designs using UNCLE tools. The area penalty is largely due to the unavoidable translation into a dual-rail topology when using the standard NCL cell library

DeSyRe: on-Demand System Reliability

The DeSyRe project builds on-demand adaptive and reliable Systems-on-Chips (SoCs). As fabrication technology scales down, chips are becoming less reliable, thereby incurring increased power and performance costs for fault tolerance. To make matters worse, power density is becoming a significant limiting factor in SoC design, in general. In the face of such changes in the technological landscape, current solutions for fault tolerance are expected to introduce excessive overheads in future systems. Moreover, attempting to design and manufacture a totally defect and fault-free system, would impact heavily, even prohibitively, the design, manufacturing, and testing costs, as well as the system performance and power consumption. In this context, DeSyRe delivers a new generation of systems that are reliable by design at well-balanced power, performance, and design costs. In our attempt to reduce the overheads of fault-tolerance, only a small fraction of the chip is built to be fault-free. This fault-free part is then employed to manage the remaining fault-prone resources of the SoC. The DeSyRe framework is applied to two medical systems with high safety requirements (measured using the IEC 61508 functional safety standard) and tight power and performance constraints

Space Station Freedom data management system growth and evolution report

The Information Sciences Division at the NASA Ames Research Center has completed a 6-month study of portions of the Space Station Freedom Data Management System (DMS). This study looked at the present capabilities and future growth potential of the DMS, and the results are documented in this report. Issues have been raised that were discussed with the appropriate Johnson Space Center (JSC) management and Work Package-2 contractor organizations. Areas requiring additional study have been identified and suggestions for long-term upgrades have been proposed. This activity has allowed the Ames personnel to develop a rapport with the JSC civil service and contractor teams that does permit an independent check and balance technique for the DMS

Design of asynchronous microprocessor for power proportionality

PhD ThesisMicroprocessors continue to get exponentially cheaper for end users following Moore’s law, while the costs involved in their design keep growing, also at an exponential rate. The reason is the ever increasing complexity of processors, which modern EDA tools struggle to keep up with. This makes further scaling for performance subject to a high risk in the reliability of the system. To keep this risk low, yet improve the performance, CPU designers try to optimise various parts of the processor. Instruction Set Architecture (ISA) is a significant part of the whole processor design flow, whose optimal design for a particular combination of available hardware resources and software requirements is crucial for building processors with high performance and efficient energy utilisation. This is a challenging task involving a lot of heuristics and high-level design decisions. Another issue impacting CPU reliability is continuous scaling for power consumption. For the last decades CPU designers have been mainly focused on improving performance, but “keeping energy and power consumption in mind”. The consequence of this was a development of energy-efficient systems, where energy was considered as a resource whose consumption should be optimised. As CMOS technology was progressing, with feature size decreasing and power delivered to circuit components becoming less stable, the energy resource turned from an optimisation criterion into a constraint, sometimes a critical one. At this point power proportionality becomes one of the most important aspects in system design. Developing methods and techniques which will address the problem of designing a power-proportional microprocessor, capable to adapt to varying operating conditions (such as low or even unstable voltage levels) and application requirements in the runtime, is one of today’s grand challenges. In this thesis this challenge is addressed by proposing a new design flow for the development of an ISA for microprocessors, which can be altered to suit a particular hardware platform or a specific operating mode. This flow uses an expressive and powerful formalism for the specification of processor instruction sets called the Conditional Partial Order Graph (CPOG). The CPOG model captures large sets of behavioural scenarios for a microarchitectural level in a computationally efficient form amenable to formal transformations for synthesis, verification and automated derivation of asynchronous hardware for the CPU microcontrol. The feasibility of the methodology, novel design flow and a number of optimisation techniques was proven in a full size asynchronous Intel 8051 microprocessor and its demonstrator silicon. The chip showed the ability to work in a wide range of operating voltage and environmental conditions. Depending on application requirements and power budget our ASIC supports several operating modes: one optimised for energy consumption and the other one for performance. This was achieved by extending a traditional datapath structure with an auxiliary control layer for adaptable and fault tolerant operation. These and other optimisations resulted in a reconfigurable and adaptable implementation, which was proven by measurements, analysis and evaluation of the chip.EPSR

On Multicast in Asynchronous Networks-on-Chip: Techniques, Architectures, and FPGA Implementation

In this era of exascale computing, conventional synchronous design techniques are facing unprecedented challenges. The consumer electronics market is replete with many-core systems in the range of 16 cores to thousands of cores on chip, integrating multi-billion transistors. However, with this ever increasing complexity, the traditional design approaches are facing key issues such as increasing chip power, process variability, aging, thermal problems, and scalability. An alternative paradigm that has gained significant interest in the last decade is asynchronous design. Asynchronous designs have several potential advantages: they are naturally energy proportional, burning power only when active, do not require complex clock distribution, are robust to different forms of variability, and provide ease of composability for heterogeneous platforms. Networks-on-chip (NoCs) is an interconnect paradigm that has been introduced to deal with the ever-increasing system complexity. NoCs provide a distributed, scalable, and efficient interconnect solution for today’s many-core systems. Moreover, NoCs are a natural match with asynchronous design techniques, as they separate communication infrastructure and timing from the computational elements. To this end, globally-asynchronous locally-synchronous (GALS) systems that interconnect multiple processing cores, operating at different clock speeds, using an asynchronous NoC, have gained significant interest. While asynchronous NoCs have several advantages, they also face a key challenge of supporting new types of traffic patterns. Once such pattern is multicast communication, where a source sends packets to arbitrary number of destinations. Multicast is not only common in parallel computing, such as for cache coherency, but also for emerging areas such as neuromorphic computing. This important capability has been largely missing from asynchronous NoCs. This thesis introduces several efficient multicast solutions for these interconnects. In particular, techniques, and network architectures are introduced to support high-performance and low-power multicast. Two leading network topologies are the focus: a variant mesh-of-trees (MoT) and a 2D mesh. In addition, for a more realistic implementation and analysis, as well as significantly advancing the field of asynchronous NoCs, this thesis also targets synthesis of these NoCs on commercial FPGAs. While there has been significant advances in FPGA technologies, there has been only limited research on implementing asynchronous NoCs on FPGAs. To this end, a systematic computeraided design (CAD) methodology has been introduced to efficiently and safely map asynchronous NoCs on FPGAs. Overall, this thesis makes the following three contributions. The first contribution is a multicast solution for a variant MoT network topology. This topology consists of simple low-radix switches, and has been used in high-performance computing platforms. A novel local speculation technique is introduced, where a subset of the network’s switches are speculative that always broadcast every packet. These switches are very simple and have high performance. Speculative switches are surrounded by non-speculative ones that route packets based on their destinations and also throttle any redundant copies created by the former. This hybrid network architecture achieved significant performance and power benefits over other multicast approaches. The second contribution is a multicast solution for a 2D-mesh topology, which is more complex with higher-radix switches and also is more commonly used. A novel continuous-time replication strategy is introduced to optimize the critical multi-way forking operation of a multicast transmission. In this technique, a multicast packet is first stored in an input port of a switch, from where it is sent through distinct output ports towards different destinations concurrently, at each output’s own rate and in continuous time. This strategy is shown to have significant latency and energy benefits over an approach that performs multicast using multiple distinct serial unicasts to each destination. Finally, a systematic CAD methodology is introduced to synthesize asynchronous NoCs on commercial FPGAs. A two-fold goal is targeted: correctness and high performance. For ease of implementation, only existing FPGA synthesis tools are used. Moreover, since asynchronous NoCs involve special asynchronous components, a comprehensive guide is introduced to map these elements correctly and efficiently. Two asynchronous NoC switches are synthesized using the proposed approach on a leading Xilinx FPGA in 28 nm: one that only handles unicast, and the other that also supports multicast. Both showed significant energy benefits with some performance gains over a state-of-the-art synchronous switch

Proceedings of the 5th International Workshop on Reconfigurable Communication-centric Systems on Chip 2010 - ReCoSoC\u2710 - May 17-19, 2010 Karlsruhe, Germany. (KIT Scientific Reports ; 7551)

ReCoSoC is intended to be a periodic annual meeting to expose and discuss gathered expertise as well as state of the art research around SoC related topics through plenary invited papers and posters. The workshop aims to provide a prospective view of tomorrow\u27s challenges in the multibillion transistor era, taking into account the emerging techniques and architectures exploring the synergy between flexible on-chip communication and system reconfigurability

A comparative study of synchronous and self-timed systolic array architectures.

This thesis examines systolic array architectures and their methods of control and communication synchronisation. Systolic array processors suffer from synchronisation problems associated with the clocking mechanism that causally restricts their scalability. To overcome this problem both return-to-zero (RTZ) and non-return-to zero (NRTZ) delay-insensitive self-timed (ST) techniques can be used to realise architectures that operate correctly in the presence of arbitrary delays at all levels in their design. As a consequence, RTZ and NRTZ versions of an existing systolic array architecture, namely the Single instruction Systolic Array (SISA), have been developed in order to investigate the potential for realising architecturally scaleable systolic arrays. The new architectures, called the RTZ and NRTZ ST-SISAs, have been compared with each other and against their synchronous counterpart to establish their relative trade-offs. The new designs exhibit several novel features including: variable length bit-serial data words, average case processing speeds dependent on data word length as well as computational complexity, a novel autonomous inter-processor data communication mechanism and architectural scalability independent of fabrication technology. This thesis introduces an implementation of the RTZ and NRTZ ST-SISA architectures, along with their performance and area characteristics. Guidelines have been developed from the resulting RTZ and NRTZ architectures allowing novel self-timed systolic architectures to be derived

HARD: Hybrid Adaptive Resource Discovery for Jungle Computing

In recent years, Jungle Computing has emerged as a distributed computing paradigm based on simultaneous combination of various hierarchical and distributed computing environments which are composed by large number of heterogeneous resources. In such a computing environment, the resources and the underlying computation and communication infrastructures are highly-hierarchical and heterogeneous. This creates a lot of difficulty and complexity for finding the proper resources in a precise way in order to run a particular job on the system efficiently. This paper proposes Hybrid Adaptive Resource Discovery (HARD), a novel efficient and highly scalable resource-discovery approach which is built upon a virtual hierarchical overlay based on self-organization and self-adaptation of processing resources in the system, where the computing resources are organized into distributed hierarchies according to a proposed hierarchical multi-layered resource description model. The proposed approach supports distributed query processing within and across hierarchical layers by deploying various distributed resource discovery services and functionalities in the system which are implemented using different adapted algorithms and mechanisms in each level of hierarchy. The proposed approach addresses the requirements for resource discovery in Jungle Computing environments such as high-hierarchy, high-heterogeneity, high-scalability and dynamicity. Simulation results show significant scalability and efficiency of the proposed approach over highly heterogeneous, hierarchical and dynamic computing environments