The cost of continuity: performance of iterative solvers on isogeometric finite elements

In this paper we study how the use of a more continuous set of basis functions affects the cost of solving systems of linear equations resulting from a discretized Galerkin weak form. Specifically, we compare performance of linear solvers when discretizing using $C^0$ B-splines, which span traditional finite element spaces, and $C^{p-1}$ B-splines, which represent maximum continuity. We provide theoretical estimates for the increase in cost of the matrix-vector product as well as for the construction and application of black-box preconditioners. We accompany these estimates with numerical results and study their sensitivity to various grid parameters such as element size $h$ and polynomial order of approximation $p$. Finally, we present timing results for a range of preconditioning options for the Laplace problem. We conclude that the matrix-vector product operation is at most \slfrac{33p^2}{8} times more expensive for the more continuous space, although for moderately low $p$, this number is significantly reduced. Moreover, if static condensation is not employed, this number further reduces to at most a value of 8, even for high $p$. Preconditioning options can be up to $p^3$ times more expensive to setup, although this difference significantly decreases for some popular preconditioners such as Incomplete LU factorization

A Combined Preconditioning Strategy for Nonsymmetric Systems

We present and analyze a class of nonsymmetric preconditioners within a normal (weighted least-squares) matrix form for use in GMRES to solve nonsymmetric matrix problems that typically arise in finite element discretizations. An example of the additive Schwarz method applied to nonsymmetric but definite matrices is presented for which the abstract assumptions are verified. A variable preconditioner, combining the original nonsymmetric one and a weighted least-squares version of it, is shown to be convergent and provides a viable strategy for using nonsymmetric preconditioners in practice. Numerical results are included to assess the theory and the performance of the proposed preconditioners.Comment: 26 pages, 3 figure