Does it take two to tango? RING domain self-association and activity in TRIM E3 ubiquitin ligases.

TRIM proteins form a protein family that is characterized by a conserved tripartite motif domain comprising a RING domain, one or two B-box domains and a coiled-coil region. Members of this large protein family are important regulators of numerous cellular functions including innate immune responses, transcriptional regulation and apoptosis. Key to their cellular role is their E3 ligase activity which is conferred by the RING domain. Self-association is an important characteristic of TRIM protein activity and is mediated by homodimerization via the coiled-coil region, and in some cases higher order association via additional domains of the tripartite motif. In many of the TRIM family proteins studied thus far, RING dimerization is an important prerequisite for E3 ligase enzymatic activity though the propensity of RING domains to dimerize differs significantly between different TRIMs and can be influenced by other regions of the protein

Interactions with Natural Polyamines and Thermal Stability of DNA. A DSC Study and a Theoretical Reconsideration

The effects of different amounts of four natural polyamines on the thermodynamics of the thermal denaturation of calf thymus and herring sperm DNA have been studied by means of differential scanning calorimetry. Enthalpy changes and the temperature of the maximum heat effect were determined. The stability of the double helix increases by increasing the polyamine/phosphate ratio and the number of positively charged groups on the polyamine molecule. A combination of Manning's polyelectrolyte theory and McGhee and von Hippel's multiple-site exclusion approach has been demonstrated to give a very good reproducibility of experimental results

Characterisation of class VI TRIM RING domains: linking RING activity to C-terminal domain identity.

TRIM E3 ubiquitin ligases regulate multiple cellular processes, and their dysfunction is linked to disease. They are characterised by a conserved N-terminal tripartite motif comprising a RING, B-box domains, and a coiled-coil region, with C-terminal domains often mediating substrate recruitment. TRIM proteins are grouped into 11 classes based on C-terminal domain identity. Class VI TRIMs, TRIM24, TRIM33, and TRIM28, have been described as transcriptional regulators, a function linked to their C-terminal plant homeodomain and bromodomain, and independent of their ubiquitination activity. It is unclear whether E3 ligase activity is regulated in family members where the C-terminal domains function independently. Here, we provide a detailed biochemical characterisation of the RING domains of class VI TRIMs and describe the solution structure of the TRIM28 RING. Our study reveals a lack of activity of the isolated RING domains, which may be linked to the absence of self-association. We propose that class VI TRIMs exist in an inactive state and require additional regulatory events to stimulate E3 ligase activity, ensuring that associated chromatin-remodelling factors are not injudiciously degraded

Structure-function analyses of the bacterial zinc metalloprotease effector protein GtgA uncovers key residues required for deactivating NF-κB

The closely related type III secretion system zinc metalloprotease effector proteins GtgA, GogA, and PipA are translocated into host cells during Salmonella infection. They then cleave nuclear factor κ-light-chain-enhancer of activated B cells (NF-κB) transcription factor subunits, dampening activation of the NF-κB signaling pathway and thereby suppressing host immune responses. We demonstrate here that GtgA, GogA, and PipA cleave a subset of NF-κB subunits, including p65, RelB, and cRel but not NF-κB1 and NF-κB2, whereas the functionally similar type III secretion system effector NleC of enteropathogenic and enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli cleaved all five NF-κB subunits. Mutational analysis of NF-κB subunits revealed that a single nonconserved residue in NF-κB1 and NF-κB2 that corresponds to the P1' residue Arg-41 in p65 prevents cleavage of these subunits by GtgA, GogA, and PipA, explaining the observed substrate specificity of these enzymes. Crystal structures of GtgA in its apo-form and in complex with the p65 N-terminal domain explained the importance of the P1' residue. Furthermore, the pattern of interactions suggested that GtgA recognizes NF-κB subunits by mimicking the shape and negative charge of the DNA phosphate backbone. Moreover, structure-based mutational analysis of GtgA uncovered amino acids that are required for the interaction of GtgA with p65, as well as those that are required for full activity of GtgA in suppressing NF-κB activation. This study therefore provides detailed and critical insight into the mechanism of substrate recognition by this family of proteins important for bacterial virulence

Divergent self-association properties of paralogous proteins TRIM2 and TRIM3 regulate their E3 ligase activity

Tripartite motif (TRIM) proteins constitute a large family of RING-type E3 ligases that share a conserved domain architecture. TRIM2 and TRIM3 are paralogous class VII TRIM members that are expressed mainly in the brain and regulate different neuronal functions. Here we present a detailed structure function analysis of TRIM2 and TRIM3, which despite high sequence identity, exhibit markedly different self-association and activity profiles. We show that the isolated RING domain of human TRIM3 is monomeric and inactive, and that this lack of activity is due to a few placental mammal-specific amino acid changes adjacent to the core RING domain that prevent self-association but not E2 recognition. We demonstrate that the activity of human TRIM3 RING can be restored by substitution with the relevant region of human TRIM2 or by hetero-dimerization with human TRIM2, establishing that subtle amino acid changes can profoundly affect TRIM protein activity. Finally, we show that TRIM2 and TRIM3 interact in a cellular context via their filamin and coiled-coil domains, respectively

Determinants of E2-ubiquitin conjugate recognition by RBR E3 ligases

RING-between-RING (RBR) ubiquitin ligases work with multiple E2 enzymes and function through an E3-ubiquitin thioester intermediate. The RBR module comprises three domains, RING1, IBR and RING2 that collaborate to transfer ubiquitin from the E2~Ub conjugate, recognised by RING1, onto a catalytic cysteine in RING2 and finally onto the substrate in a multi-step reaction. Recent studies have shown that RING1 domains bind E2~Ub conjugates in an open conformation to supress ubiquitin transfer onto lysine residues and promote formation of the E3 thioester intermediate. However, how the nature of the E2 influences the ubiquitin transfer process is currently unclear. We report here a detailed characterization of the RBR/E2-conjugate recognition step that indicates that this mechanism depends on the nature of the E2 enzyme and differs between UbcH5 and UbcH7. In the case of UbcH5~Ub an interaction with ubiquitin is necessary to stabilize the transfer complex while recognition of UbcH7~Ub is driven primarily by E2-RING1 contacts. Furthermore our analysis suggests that RBRs, in isolation and in complex with ubiquitin-loaded E2s, are dynamic species and that their intrinsic flexibility might be a key aspect of their catalytic mechanism

Functional role of TRIM E3 ligase oligomerization and regulation of catalytic activity

TRIM E3 ubiquitin ligases regulate a wide variety of cellular processes and are particularly important during innate immune signalling events. They are characterized by a conserved tripartite motif in their N-terminal portion which comprises a canonical RING domain, one or two B-box domains and a coiled-coil region that mediates ligase dimerization. Self-association via the coiled-coil has been suggested to be crucial for catalytic activity of TRIMs; however, the precise molecular mechanism underlying this observation remains elusive. Here, we provide a detailed characterization of the TRIM ligases TRIM25 and TRIM32 and show how their oligomeric state is linked to catalytic activity. The crystal structure of a complex between the TRIM25 RING domain and an ubiquitin-loaded E2 identifies the structural and mechanistic features that promote a closed E2~Ub conformation to activate the thioester for ubiquitin transfer allowing us to propose a model for the regulation of activity in the full-length protein. Our data reveal an unexpected diversity in the self-association mechanism of TRIMs that might be crucial for their biological function

Domain organisation and expression screen of human NLRP1.

(A) Human NLRP1 domain organisation; black lines indicate some of the key residues reported to be important for protein function. K340 and E414 belong to the Walker A and Walker B motifs, respectively and are important for ATP processing. H623 is a conserved residue across all the NLRs, the correspondent residues in NLRC4 and in Apaf1 are involved in stabilising the ADP-bound conformation. H1190, F1216 and S1217 are reported to be important for the auto-proteolysis of the FIIND domain. (B) Schematic representation of the soluble constructs produced in insect cells. The boundaries of each construct are indicated on the left. (C) SDS-gels of the recombinant proteins from insect cells after the first metal affinity purification step. A black star indicates the protein of interest and a black arrow heads indicates proteolytic degradation products.</p

Conformational dynamics of the bacterial E3 ligase SspH1.

The SspH/IpaH family of novel E3 ligases (NELs) are found in a number of Gram-negative bacteria and are used to target host enzymes for degradation to support pathogenesis. These E3 enzymes are autoinhibited in the absence of substrate and different models for release of autoinhibition have been suggested. However, many of the molecular details of individual steps during the ubiquitin transfer reaction remain unknown. Here, we present the crystal structure of Salmonella SspH1 and an analysis of the solution properties of SspH1 on its own and in complex with substrate and ubiquitin. Our data show that SspH1 exists in a conformational equilibrium between open and closed states and that substrate binding only modulates the distribution of these states but does not induce major conformational changes. This suggests that additional mechanisms must exist to bring the substrates close to the active site to mediate transfer of ubiquitin from the E3∼Ub conjugate

The biophysical characterisation and SAXS analysis of human NLRP1 uncover a new level of complexity of NLR proteins

NOD-like receptors represent an important class of germline-encoded pattern recognition receptors that play key roles in the regulation of inflammatory signalling pathways. They function as danger sensors and initiate inflammatory responses and the production of cytokines. Since NLR malfunction results in chronic inflammation and auto-immune diseases, there is a great interest in understanding how they work on a molecular level. To date, a lot of insight into the biological functions of NLRs is available but biophysical and structural studies have been hampered by the difficulty to produce soluble and stable recombinant NLR proteins. NLRP1 is an inflammasome forming NLR that is believed to be activated by binding to MDP and induces activation of caspase 1. Here, we report the identification of a soluble fragment of NLRP1 that contains the NACHT oligomerization domain and the putative MDP-sensing LRR domain. We describe the biophysical and biochemical characterization of this construct and a SEC-SAXS analysis that allowed the calculation of a low resolution molecular envelope. Our data indicate that the protein is constitutively bound to ATP with a negligible ability to hydrolyse the triphosphate nucleotide and that it adopts a monomeric extended conformation that is reminiscent of the structure adopted by NLRC4 in the inflammasome complex. Furthermore, we show that the presence of MDP is not sufficient to promote self-oligomerization of the NACHT-LRR fragment suggesting that MDP may either bind to regions outside the NACHT-LRR module or that it may not be the natural ligand of NLRP1. Taken together, our data suggest that the NLRP1 mechanism of action differs from that recently reported for other NLRs