Estimation of vertical walking ground reaction force in real-life environments using single IMU sensor

This is the author accepted manuscript. The final version is available from Elsevier via the DOI in this recordMonitoring natural human gait in real-life environments is essential in many applications, including quantification of disease progression, monitoring the effects of treatment, and monitoring alteration of performance biomarkers in professional sports. Nevertheless, developing reliable and practical techniques and technologies necessary for continuous real-life monitoring of gait is still an open challenge. A systematic review of English-language articles from scientific databases including Scopus, ScienceDirect, Pubmed, IEEE Xplore, EBSCO and MEDLINE were carried out to analyse the ‘accuracy’ and ‘practicality’ of the current techniques and technologies for quantitative measurement of the tri-axial walking ground reactions outside the laboratory environment, and to highlight their strengths and shortcomings. In total, 679 relevant abstracts were identified, 54 full-text papers were included in the paper and the quantitative results of 17 papers were used for meta-analysis and comparison. Three classes of methods were reviewed: (1) methods based on measured kinematic data; (2) methods based on measured plantar pressure; and (3) methods based on direct measurement of ground reactions. It was found that all three classes of methods have competitive accuracy levels with methods based on direct measurement of the ground reactions showing highest accuracy while being least practical for long-term real-life measurement. On the other hand, methods that estimate ground reactions using measured body kinematics show highest practicality of the three classes of methods reviewed. Among the most prominent technical and technological challenges are: (1) reducing the size and price of tri-axial load-cells; (2) improving the accuracy of orientation measurement using IMUs; (3) minimizing the number and optimizing the location of required IMUs for kinematic measurement; (4) increasing the durability of pressure insole sensors, and (5) enhancing the robustness and versatility of the ground reactions estimation methods to include pathological gaits and natural variability of gait in real-life physical environment.The authors acknowledge the financial support provided by the UK Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) for the following research grants: Frontier Engineering Grant EP/K03877X/1 (Modelling complex and partially identified engineering problems: Application to the individualized multi-scale simulation of the musculoskeletal system); and Platform Grant EP/G061130/2 (Dynamic performance of large civil engineering structures: an integrated approach to management, design and assessment)

Hardware and Software Optimization for of Smart Insole Systems for Gait Analysis

Gait analysis is vital in human biomechanicals, clinical diagnostics, and rehabilitation, providing essential insights into human locomotion. Ground reaction forces play a significant role in understanding gait dynamics, detecting abnormalities, and assessing treatment outcomes. Accurate measurement and analysis of ground reaction forces and other gait parameters are crucial for developing effective interventions and improving patient outcomes. The first part of this thesis explores methods to optimize and standardize the number of pressure sensors and their optimum placements within the insole for accurate and reliable estimation of temporal gait parameters. Standardization of sensor position for temporal gait analysis is crucial for ensuring that data collected from various devices are comparable,enabling broader applicability of the technology in clinical and research settings. Consistent sensor placement allows for reliable replication of results, facilitating longitudinal studies and multi-center trials. Next, a customizable smart insole system was developed to validate the proposed sensor standardization method. Seven temporal gait parameters were analyzed across three different foot sizes and walking speeds. The final section of the thesis explores advancements in estimating ground reaction forces using a novel center of pressed sensor sensing mechanisms, inertial sensing, and machine learning. The performances of three machine-learning models in estimating ground reaction estimation methods in relation to unseen data are analyzed. Finally, the accuracy and reliability enhancements of the ground reaction force estimation, fusing the inertial sensing data with the center of the pressed sensor measurements, are discussed

A New Proxy Measurement Algorithm with Application to the Estimation of Vertical Ground Reaction Forces Using Wearable Sensors

Measurement of the ground reaction forces (GRF) during walking is typically limited to laboratory settings, and only short observations using wearable pressure insoles have been reported so far. In this study, a new proxy measurement method is proposed to estimate the vertical component of the GRF (vGRF) from wearable accelerometer signals. The accelerations are used as the proxy variable. An orthogonal forward regression algorithm (OFR) is employed to identify the dynamic relationships between the proxy variables and the measured vGRF using pressure-sensing insoles. The obtained model, which represents the connection between the proxy variable and the vGRF, is then used to predict the latter. The results have been validated using pressure insoles data collected from nine healthy individuals under two outdoor walking tasks in non-laboratory settings. The results show that the vGRFs can be reconstructed with high accuracy (with an average prediction error of less than 5.0%) using only one wearable sensor mounted at the waist (L5, fifth lumbar vertebra). Proxy measures with different sensor positions are also discussed. Results show that the waist acceleration-based proxy measurement is more stable with less inter-task and inter-subject variability than the proxy measures based on forehead level accelerations. The proposed proxy measure provides a promising low-cost method for monitoring ground reaction forces in real-life settings and introduces a novel generic approach for replacing the direct determination of difficult to measure variables in many applications

Smart Technology for Telerehabilitation: A Smart Device Inertial-sensing Method for Gait Analysis

The aim of this work was to develop and validate an iPod Touch (4th generation) as a potential ambulatory monitoring system for clinical and non-clinical gait analysis. This thesis comprises four interrelated studies, the first overviews the current available literature on wearable accelerometry-based technology (AT) able to assess mobility-related functional activities in subjects with neurological conditions in home and community settings. The second study focuses on the detection of time-accurate and robust gait features from a single inertial measurement unit (IMU) on the lower back, establishing a reference framework in the process. The third study presents a simple step length algorithm for straight-line walking and the fourth and final study addresses the accuracy of an iPod’s inertial-sensing capabilities, more specifically, the validity of an inertial-sensing method (integrated in an iPod) to obtain time-accurate vertical lower trunk displacement measures. The systematic review revealed that present research primarily focuses on the development of accurate methods able to identify and distinguish different functional activities. While these are important aims, much of the conducted work remains in laboratory environments, with relatively little research moving from the “bench to the bedside.” This review only identified a few studies that explored AT’s potential outside of laboratory settings, indicating that clinical and real-world research significantly lags behind its engineering counterpart. In addition, AT methods are largely based on machine-learning algorithms that rely on a feature selection process. However, extracted features depend on the signal output being measured, which is seldom described. It is, therefore, difficult to determine the accuracy of AT methods without characterizing gait signals first. Furthermore, much variability exists among approaches (including the numbers of body-fixed sensors and sensor locations) to obtain useful data to analyze human movement. From an end-user’s perspective, reducing the amount of sensors to one instrument that is attached to a single location on the body would greatly simplify the design and use of the system. With this in mind, the accuracy of formerly identified or gait events from a single IMU attached to the lower trunk was explored. The study’s analysis of the trunk’s vertical and anterior-posterior acceleration pattern (and of their integrands) demonstrates, that a combination of both signals may provide more nuanced information regarding a person’s gait cycle, ultimately permitting more clinically relevant gait features to be extracted. Going one step further, a modified step length algorithm based on a pendulum model of the swing leg was proposed. By incorporating the trunk’s anterior-posterior displacement, more accurate predictions of mean step length can be made in healthy subjects at self-selected walking speeds. Experimental results indicate that the proposed algorithm estimates step length with errors less than 3% (mean error of 0.80 ± 2.01cm). The performance of this algorithm, however, still needs to be verified for those suffering from gait disturbances. Having established a referential framework for the extraction of temporal gait parameters as well as an algorithm for step length estimations from one instrument attached to the lower trunk, the fourth and final study explored the inertial-sensing capabilities of an iPod Touch. With the help of Dr. Ian Sheret and Oxford Brookes’ spin-off company ‘Wildknowledge’, a smart application for the iPod Touch was developed. The study results demonstrate that the proposed inertial-sensing method can reliably derive lower trunk vertical displacement (intraclass correlations ranging from .80 to .96) with similar agreement measurement levels to those gathered by a conventional inertial sensor (small systematic error of 2.2mm and a typical error of 3mm). By incorporating the aforementioned methods, an iPod Touch can potentially serve as a novel ambulatory monitor system capable of assessing gait in clinical and non-clinical environments

Comparison of knee loading during walking via musculoskeletal modelling using marker-based and IMU-based approaches

openThe current thesis is the result of the candidate's work over a six-month period with the assistance of the supervisor and co-supervisors, thanks to the collaboration between the Human Movement Bioengineering Laboratory Research group at the University of Padova (Italy) and the Human Movement Biomechanics Research group at KU Leuven (Belgium). Gait analysis, at a clinical level, is a diagnostic test with multiple potentials, in particular in identifying functional limitations related to a pathological path. Three-dimensional motion capture is now consolidated as an approach for human movement research studies and consists of a set of very precise measurements, the latter are processed by biomechanical models, and curves relating to the kinematics and indirect dynamics, i.e., the joint angles and the relative forces and moments, can be obtained. These results are considered fully reliable and based on these curves it is decided how to intervene on the specific subject to make the path as less pathological as possible. However, the use of wearable sensors (IMUs) consisting of accelerometers, gyroscopes, and magnetic sensors for gait analysis, has increased in the last decade due to the low production costs, portability, and small size that have allowed for studies in everyday life conditions. Inertial capture (InCap) systems have become an appealing alternative to 3D Motion Capture (MoCap) systems due to the ability of inertial measurement units (IMUs) to estimate the orientation of 3D sensors and segments. Musculoskeletal modelling and simulation provide the ideal framework to examine quantities in silico that cannot be measured in vivo, such as musculoskeletal loading, muscle forces and joint contact forces. The specific software used in this study is Opensim: an open-source software that allows modelling, analysis, and simulation of the musculoskeletal system. The aim of this thesis is to compare a marker-based musculoskeletal modelling approach with an IMUs-based one, in terms of kinematics, dynamics, and muscle activations. In particular, the project will focus on knee loading, using an existing musculoskeletal model of the lower limb. The current project was organized as follows: first, the results for the MoCap approach were obtained, following a specific workflow that used the COMAK IK tool and the COMAK algorithm to get the secondary knee kinematics, muscle activations, and knee contact forces. Where COMAK is a modified static optimization algorithm that solves for muscle activations and secondary kinematics to obtain measured primary DOF accelerations while minimizing muscle activation. Then these results were used to make a comparison with those obtained by the inertial-based approach, with the attempt to use as little information as possible from markers while estimating kinematics from IMU data using an OpenSim toolbox called OpenSense. Afterward, in order to promote an approach more independent from the constraints of a laboratory, the Zero Moment Point (ZMP) method was used to estimate the center of pressure position of the measured ground reaction forces (GRFs), and a specific Matlab code was implemented to improve this estimation. Using the measured GRFs with the new CoPs, the results of Inverse Dynamics, muscle activations, and finally knee loading were calculated and compared to the MoCap results. The final step was to conduct a statistical analysis to compare the two approaches and emphasize the importance of using IMUs for gait analysis, particularly to study knee mechanics

Master of Science

thesisGait analysis is an important tool for diagnosing a wide variety of disorders, with its increasingly accepted benefits culminating in the widespread adoption of motion analysis laboratories. A modern analysis laboratory consists of a multicamera marker tracking system for 3D reconstruction of kinematics and multiple high-fidelity load transducers to determine ground reaction force and enable inverse-dynamics for biomechanics. There is a need for an alternative motion analysis system which does not require a fixed laboratory setting and is lower in cost; freeing the motion capture from the laboratory and reducing the technology costs would enable long-term, home-based, natural monitoring of subjects. This thesis describes two contributions to the end goal of an inexpensive, mobile, insole-based motion analysis laboratory. First is the application of an inertialmeasurement-unit calibration routine and zero-velocity-update algorithm to improve position and orientation tracking. Second is the development, from basic sensor to prototype, of an insole capable of measuring 3 degree-of-freedom ground reaction force. These contributions represent a proof-of-concept that quantitative gait analysis, complete with dynamics, is possible with an insole-based system

Estimation of Kinetics Using IMUs to Monitor and Aid in Clinical Decision-Making during ACL Rehabilitation:A Systematic Review

After an ACL injury, rehabilitation consists of multiple phases, and progress between these phases is guided by subjective visual assessments of activities such as running, hopping, jump landing, etc. Estimation of objective kinetic measures like knee joint moments and GRF during assessment can help physiotherapists gain insights on knee loading and tailor rehabilitation protocols. Conventional methods deployed to estimate kinetics require complex, expensive systems and are limited to laboratory settings. Alternatively, multiple algorithms have been proposed in the literature to estimate kinetics from kinematics measured using only IMUs. However, the knowledge about their accuracy and generalizability for patient populations is still limited. Therefore, this article aims to identify the available algorithms for the estimation of kinetic parameters using kinematics measured only from IMUs and to evaluate their applicability in ACL rehabilitation through a comprehensive systematic review. The papers identified through the search were categorized based on the modelling techniques and kinetic parameters of interest, and subsequently compared based on the accuracies achieved and applicability for ACL patients during rehabilitation. IMUs have exhibited potential in estimating kinetic parameters with good accuracy, particularly for sagittal movements in healthy cohorts. However, several shortcomings were identified and future directions for improvement have been proposed, including extension of proposed algorithms to accommodate multiplanar movements and validation of the proposed techniques in diverse patient populations and in particular the ACL population.</p

Indirect Estimation of Vertical Ground Reaction Force from a Body-Mounted INS/GPS Using Machine Learning

Vertical ground reaction force(vGRF)can be measured by forceplates or instrumented treadmills, but their application is limited to indoor environments. Insoles remove this restriction but suffer from low durability (several hundred hours). Therefore, interest in the indirect estimation of vGRF using inertial measurement units and machine learning techniques has increased. This paper presents a methodology for indirectly estimating vGRF and other features used in gait analysis from measurements of a wearable GPS-aided inertial navigation system (INS/GPS) device. A set of 27 features was extracted from the INS/GPS data. Feature analysis showed that six of these features suffice to provide precise estimates of 11 different gait parameters. Bagged ensembles of regression trees were then trained and used for predicting gait parameters for a dataset from the test subject from whom the training data were collected and for a dataset from a subject for whom no training data were available. The prediction accuracies for the latter were significantly worse than for the first subject but still sufficiently good. K-nearest neighbor (KNN) and long short-term memory (LSTM) neural networks were then used for predicting vGRF and ground contact times. The KNN yielded a lower normalized root mean square error than the neural network for vGRF predictions but cannot detect new patterns in force curves.publishedVersionPeer reviewe

Gait event detection in laboratory and real life settings: Accuracy of ankle and waist sensor based methods

Wearable sensors technology based on inertial measurement units (IMUs) is leading the transition from laboratory-based gait analysis, to daily life gait monitoring. However, the validity of IMU-based methods for the detection of gait events has only been tested in laboratory settings, which may not reproduce real life walking patterns. The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of two algorithms for the detection of gait events and temporal parameters during free-living walking, one based on two shank-worn inertial sensors, and the other based on one waist-worn sensor. The algorithms were applied to gait data of ten healthy subjects walking both indoor and outdoor, and completing protocols that entailed both straight supervised and free walking in an urban environment. The values obtained from the inertial sensors were compared to pressure insoles data. The shank-based method showed very accurate initial contact, stride time and step time estimation (<14 ms error). Accuracy of final contact timings and stance time was lower (28–51 ms error range). The error of temporal parameter variability estimates was in the range 0.09–0.89%. The waist method failed to detect about 1% of the total steps and performed worse than the shank method, but the temporal parameter estimation was still satisfactory. Both methods showed negligible differences in their accuracy when the different experimental conditions were compared, which suggests their applicability in the analysis of free-living gait