Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Moderate monism, persistence and sortal concepts

By Harold Noonan


Coincidence (e.g., of a statue and the piece of bronze which constitutes it) comes in two varieties – permanent and temporary. Moderate monism (about coincidence) is\ud the position that permanent coincidence, but not temporary coincidence, entails identity. Extreme monism (also known as the stage theory) is the position that even\ud temporary coincidence entails identity. Pluralists are opponents of monism tout court. The intuitively obvious, commonsensical position (= my own position) is moderate\ud monism. It is therefore important to see if it can be sustained

OAI identifier:
Provided by: Nottingham ePrints

Suggested articles


  1. (1993). Constitution is identity. doi
  2. (1992). Constitution is not Identity. doi
  3. (2005). Counterpart theory and three-dimensionalism: a reply. doi
  4. (1971). Counterparts of persons and their bodies. doi
  5. (2006). How things might Have Been: Individuals, Kinds and Essential Properties. doi
  6. (2001). How Things Persist. doi
  7. (1991). Indeterminate identity, contingent identity and Abelardian predicates. doi
  8. (1986). Is a Thing just the Sum of its Parts?
  9. (2006). Metaphysical Essays.
  10. (1986). On the Plurality of Worlds. doi
  11. (1987). Persons and other Beings,
  12. (1980). Reference and Generality, 3rd edition. Ithaca and London:
  13. (1997). Relative identity. doi
  14. (1976). The Four-Dimensional World. Analysis 37:32-39. doi
  15. (1980). The Logic of Common Nouns. doi
  16. (2003). The Non-identity of a Material thing and its Matter. doi
  17. (2006). The Paradox of Increase.
  18. (1981). The Problem of the Many, doi
  19. (1997). Why Constitution is not Identity. doi
  20. (2005). Why counterpart theory and four-dimensionalism are incompatible. doi
  21. (2005). Why counterpart theory and three-dimensionalism are incompatible. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.