Location of Repository

Perceived environmental uncertainty : understanding the implications for strategy development processes across Barclays Plc

By Jansen Ryder

Abstract

The managerial issue being addressed in this research is perceived environmental uncertainty (experienced by corporate strategists) and its implications for strategy development processes at the strategic business unit level (or business-level strategy) across Barclays Bank PLC. The objectives of the research are achieved through: an extensive review of the strategy and uncertainty literature (Project 1); a series of semi-structured interviews with fifteen members of the Group Executive Committee at Barclays (Project 2); and the completion of 731 selfadministered questionnaires covering the seventeen strategic business units within the Barclays portfolio (Project 3). Through its findings, this research concludes that any link between perceived environmental uncertainty (at the corporate level) and strategy development processes (at the business unit level) across the Barclays portfolio is largely irrelevant. Strategists at Barclays are concerned mainly with the maximisation of shareholder value and concepts such as uncertainty, change and complexity are not within the managerial lexicon. Based on this observation, strategy development at Barclays does not involve a carefully managed reciprocal relationship between the firm and its environment, or a skilfully manipulated balance of the degree of change and the level of complexity with which the organisation is deemed able to cope. Strategy development involves the dedicated and ruthless stewardship of a highly successful and resilient business model that could not fail within the economic environment experienced during the period of this research (1999–2005). Consequently, the Bank’s strategic capability (e.g. people) and assets (e.g. brand and technology) are geared towards protecting and developing the business model, or in simpler managerial terms, ‘defending the money-printing machine’

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 2005
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/7723
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1963). A Behavioural Theory Of The Firm, doi
  2. (1992). A First Course In Factor Analysis (2nd edition), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,
  3. (1967). A Framework For The Comparative Analysis Of Organisations', doi
  4. (1972). A Garbage Can Model Of Organisational Choice', doi
  5. (1976). A Note On 'Environmental Uncertainty' And A Suggestion For Our Editorial Function ',
  6. (1984). A Prescriptive Contingency View Of Organisational Decision-Making', doi
  7. (1983). A Process Model Of Internal Corporate Venturing In The Diversified Major Firm', doi
  8. (1978). A Realist Theory Of Science (2nd edition),
  9. (1978). A Strategic Model Of The U.S. Brewing Industry 1952-1971', doi
  10. (1963). A Strategy Of Decision, doi
  11. (1982). Adaptation: A Promising Metaphor For Strategic Management', doi
  12. (1998). Against The Gods: The Remarkable Story Of Risk, doi
  13. (1969). Aiding The Decision-Maker - A Decision-Making Process Model', doi
  14. (1992). An Integrative Framework For Strategy-Making Processes', doi
  15. (1995). Analysing Social Settings: A Guide To Qualitative Observation And Analysis (3rd edition),
  16. (1900). Annals Of An East Anglian Bank,
  17. (1991). Areas Of Agreement And Common Ground. Conference On Strategy Process Research Papers
  18. (2005). Barclays Audited Accounts doi
  19. (2001). Barclays: The Business Of Banking 1690–1996, Cambridge doi
  20. (2000). Blown To Bits, The Boston Consulting Group,
  21. (2002). Causal Ambiguity: Some Empirical And Conceptual Developments',
  22. (1985). Certaincy-Equivalence And The Theory Of The Firm Under Uncertainty', doi
  23. (1981). Challenging Strategic Planning Assumptions, doi
  24. (1972). Characteristics Of Organizational Environments And Perceived Environmental Uncertainty', doi
  25. (1988). Chief Executive Scanning, Environmental Characteristics, And Company Performance: An Empirical Study', doi
  26. (1976). Choice, Complexity And Ignorance, doi
  27. (1998). Clarifying Frank Knight's Discussion Of The Meaning Of Risk And Uncertainty', doi
  28. (1998). Collecting And Interpreting Qualitative Materials, Sage, doi
  29. (1991). Comparative Statistics For Rank-Dependent Expected Utility Theory', doi
  30. (1996). Competing For The Future, doi
  31. (1998). Competing On The Edge, doi
  32. (1985). Competitive Advantage: Creating And Sustaining Superior Performance, doi
  33. (1967). Competitive Production For Constant Risk Utility Functions', doi
  34. (1980). Competitive Strategy: Techniques For Analysing Industries And Competitors, doi
  35. (2000). Confessions Of A Philosopher, Weidenfield and Nicolson,
  36. (1978). Consensual Uncertainty', doi
  37. (1980). Construct Validity In Organisational Behaviour',
  38. (1986). Convergence And Upheaval: Managing The Unsteady Pace Of Organisational Evolution', doi
  39. (1998). Cost, Uncertainty And Welfare: Frank Knight's Theory Of Imperfect Competition,
  40. (1987). Crafting Strategy', Harvard Business Review,
  41. (1984). Dimensions Of Task Organisational Environments', doi
  42. (1993). Divergence Between Archival And Perceptual Measures Of The Environment: Causes And Consequences', doi
  43. (2001). Does Leadership Matter? Chief Executive Officer Leadership Attributes And Profitability Under Conditions Of Perceived Environmental Uncertainty', doi
  44. (1999). Doing Quantitative Research, Sage, London.Cranfield School of Management Executive Doctorate –
  45. (1981). Effects Of Environmental Uncertainty On Information And Decision Processes In Banks', doi
  46. (1985). Empirically Derived Models Of Strategic DecisionMaking', doi
  47. (1993). Environmental Uncertainty And Environmental Scanning Activities Of Nigerian Manufacturing Executives: A Comparative Analysis', doi
  48. (1975). Environmental Uncertainty: Comments On Objective And Perceptual Indices', doi
  49. (1971). Essence Of Decision: Explaining The Cuban Missile Crisis, doi
  50. (2000). Essence Of Leadership, doi
  51. (1997). Explaining The Premium Paid For Large Acquisitions: Evidence Of Chief Executive Officer Hubris ', doi
  52. (1972). Field Research On Complex Decision-Making Processes',
  53. (1990). Fifth Discipline: The Art And Practice Of The Learning Organisation, doi
  54. (1957). Games And Decisions, doi
  55. (1997). Grounded Theory In Practice (2nd edition), Sage, London.Cranfield School of Management Executive Doctorate –
  56. (1981). Hierarchies, Clans And Theory Z: A New Perspective On Organisation And Development', doi
  57. (1994). How Strategy-Making Processes Can Make A Difference', doi
  58. (1994). How We Talk And How We Act: Administrative Theory And Administrative Life',
  59. (1995). Hyper-Competitive Rivalries: Competing In Highly Dynamic Environments,
  60. (1982). In Search Of Excellence, Harper and Row, doi
  61. (1977). Individual Characteristics As Sources Of Perceived Uncertainty Variation', doi
  62. (1992). Introduction To The Summer doi
  63. (1994). Introduction: From Social Engineering To Reflective Action In Organisational Behaviour',
  64. (1996). Is Simulation Better Than Experience',
  65. (1974). Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics And Biases', doi
  66. (1995). Keynes, Knowledge And Uncertainty, doi
  67. (2000). Letter To Senior Leadership Team, Barclays Bank PLC,
  68. (2001). Making Sense Of The Organisation, Blackwell, Oxford.Cranfield School of Management Executive Doctorate –
  69. (1997). Management Research: An Introduction, Sage, London.Cranfield School of Management Executive Doctorate –
  70. (2003). Managerial Consensus And Corporate Strategy: Why Do Executives Agree Or Disagree About Corporate Strategy ', doi
  71. (1989). Managerial Decisions With The Microcomputer, Phillip Allan,
  72. (1989). Managerial Economics: The Analysis Of Business Decisions,
  73. (2004). Managerial Involvement And Perceptions Of Strategy Process', doi
  74. (1970). Managing The Resource Allocation Process, doi
  75. (1998). Managing Uncertainty: Competition And Strategy In Emerging Markets,
  76. (1987). New Philosophies Of Social Science: Realism, Hermeneutics And Critical Theory, doi
  77. (1985). Of Strategies, Deliberate And Emergent', doi
  78. (1981). On The Measurement Of Organisational Slack', doi
  79. (1973). On The Measurement Of The Environment: An Assessment Of The Lawrence And Lorsch Environmental Uncertainty Scale', doi
  80. (1980). Operationalizing The Concept Of Business-Level Strategy In Research', doi
  81. (1984). Order Out Of Chaos: Man's New Dialogue With Nature, Bantam, doi
  82. (1967). Organisation And Environment,
  83. (1979). Organisation And Environments,
  84. (1985). Organisation Evolution: A Metamorphic Model Of Convergence And Re-Orientation',
  85. (1967). Organisation In Action,
  86. (1997). Organisation Theory, doi
  87. (1974). Organisation-Environment: Concepts And Issues', doi
  88. (1985). Organisational Culture And Leadership, Jossey-Bass, doi
  89. (1967). Organisational Decision-Making Behaviour Under Varying Conditions Of Uncertainty', doi
  90. (1989). Organisational Ecology, doi
  91. (1975). Organisational Effectiveness And The Institutional Environment', doi
  92. (1978). Organisational Learning: A Theory Of Action Perspective, doi
  93. (1972). Organisational Structure, Environment And Performance: The Role Of Strategic Choice', doi
  94. (1976). Organisations And Their Environments,
  95. (1958). Organisations, Wiley, New York.Cranfield School of Management Executive Doctorate –
  96. (1999). Patching: Restitching Business Portfolios In Dynamic Markets',
  97. (1978). Patterns In Strategy Formation', doi
  98. (1975). Perceived Environmental Uncertainty: Effects Of Information And Structure', doi
  99. (1980). Performance And Consensus', doi
  100. (2000). Perspectives On The Process Of Strategy Development,
  101. (1955). Politics, Planning And The Public Interest, doi
  102. (1971). Power And Conflict In doi
  103. (1979). Prospect Theory: An Analysis Of Decision Under Risk', doi
  104. (1978). Quantitative Decision Making,
  105. (2001). Rational Analysis For A Problematic World Revisited: Problem Structuring Methods For Complexity, Uncertainty And Conflict (2nd edition), doi
  106. (1988). Re-Thinking Incrementalism',
  107. (1995). Research Methods And Organisation Studies, doi
  108. (1999). Research Methods For Managers,
  109. (1995). Risk, Uncertainty And Bayesian Decision Theory: A Keynesian View',
  110. (1996). Scenarios: The Art Of Strategic Conversation, doi
  111. (1968). Stages In The Decision-Making Process',
  112. (1980). Strategic Capability: A Concept And Framework For Analysis', doi
  113. (1987). Strategic Change And The Management Process, doi
  114. (1993). Strategic Decision Making, doi
  115. (1988). Strategic Decision Processes In High Velocity Environments: Four Cases In The Microcomputer Industry', doi
  116. (1984). Strategic Decision Processes: Comprehensiveness And Performance In An Industry With An Unstable Environment', doi
  117. (1998). Strategic Decision-Making Processes: The Role Of Management And Context', doi
  118. (1995). Strategic Decision-Making', doi
  119. (1969). Strategic Factors In Business Success, Financial Executives Research Foundation,
  120. (1985). Strategic Goals, Perceived Uncertainty, And Economic Performance On Volatile Environments', doi
  121. (2000). Strategic Innovation In The New Economy', doi
  122. (1986). Strategic Management Of Uncertainty', doi
  123. (1998). Strategic Management Theory: An Integrated Approach (4th edition), Houghton-Mifflin,
  124. (1979). Strategic Management: A New View Of Business Policy And Planning, doi
  125. (1980). Strategies for Change: Logical Incrementalism, doi
  126. (1980). Strategy And Environment: A Conceptual Integration', doi
  127. (1962). Strategy And Structure, doi
  128. (2000). Strategy Development Processes In The Public Sector',
  129. (2000). Strategy From An Individual Perspective', doi
  130. (1984). Strategy Implementation: Five Approaches To An Elusive Phenomenon', doi
  131. (1998). Strategy In Practice, doi
  132. (1973). Strategy Making In Three Modes', doi
  133. (1992). Strategy Process Research: Focusing On Corporate Self-Renewal', doi
  134. (1997). Strategy Under Uncertainty',
  135. (1991). Strategy: Seeking And Securing Competitive Advantage (12th edition),
  136. (1974). Structural Conditions Of Interorganisational Power ', doi
  137. (1992). Suggestions For Studying Strategy Process: A Research Note', doi
  138. (1999). Tailored, Not Benchmarked: A Fresh Look At Corporate Planning',
  139. (1981). The Art Of Japanese Management, Simon and Schuster, doi
  140. (1974). The Bases And Uses Of Power In Organisational Decision-Making: The Case Of A University Budget', doi
  141. (1965). The Causal Texture Of Organisational Environments', doi
  142. (1992). The Character And Significance Of Strategy Process Research', doi
  143. (1988). The Cognitive Perspective On Decision-Making', doi
  144. (1984). The Comprehensiveness Of Strategic Decision Processes: Extension, Observations, Future Directions', doi
  145. (1971). The Concept Of Corporate Strategy, doi
  146. (1981). The Contributions Of Marketing To Strategic Management', doi
  147. (1980). The Experience Of Workplace Politics', doi
  148. (1978). The External Control Of Organisations, Harper and Row, doi
  149. (1982). The Four Phases Of Strategic Management',
  150. (1936). The General Theory Of Employment, Interest And Money, Prometheus Books, doi
  151. (1979). The Impact Of Comprehensive Planning On Financial Performance', doi
  152. (1984). The Impact Of Environmental Uncertainty On Long-Range Planning Practices Of The U.S. Savings And Loan Industry', doi
  153. (1987). The Impact Of Grand Strategy And Planning Formality In Financial Performance', doi
  154. (1988). The Leadership Factor, doi
  155. (1987). The Managerial Decision-Making Process, doi
  156. (1997). The Options Approach To Capital Investment', doi
  157. (1985). The Paradox Of 'Corporate Culture': Reconciling Ourselves To Socialisation', doi
  158. (1977). The Population Ecology Of Organisations', doi
  159. (1999). The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think In Action, Basic Books, doi
  160. (1986). The Relationship Of Strategic Planning To Financial Performance', doi
  161. (1959). The Science Of 'Muddling Through'', doi
  162. (1966). The Social Psychology Of Organisations, doi
  163. (1979). The Social Psychology Of Organising (2nd edition),
  164. (1998). The Strategy Process (revised European edition),
  165. (1976). The Structure Of Unstructured Decision Processes', doi
  166. (2002). The Theory And Practice Of Change Management, doi
  167. (2000). The Tipping Point, doi
  168. (1983). The Uniqueness Paradox In Organisational Stories', doi
  169. (1998). The Use Of Hoshi Kanri Planning And Deployment Systems In The Service Sector', doi
  170. (2000). The Validation Of A Multi-Dimensional Measure Of Strategy Development Processes', doi
  171. (1974). Theory In Practice: Increasing Professional Effectiveness, Jossey-Bass, doi
  172. (1978). Theory Z: How American Business Can Meet The Japanese Challenge, doi
  173. (1991). Thinking Strategically: The Competitive Edge doi
  174. (1985). Three Models Of Strategy', doi
  175. (1987). Three Types Of Perceived Uncertainty About The Environment: State, Effect And Response Uncertainty', doi
  176. (1988). Thriving On Chaos: Handbook For A Management Revolution, doi
  177. (1986). Top Decisions -Strategic Decision-Making In Organisations, doi
  178. (1982). Top Management Agreement And Organisational Performance', doi
  179. (1988). Toward Middle-Up-Down Management: Accelerating Information Creation',
  180. (1962). Uncertainty And Structure As Psychological Concepts, doi
  181. (1987). Uncertainty, Flexibility And Buffers: Three Case Studies',
  182. (1975). Uncertainty: Measures Research And Sources Of Variation', doi
  183. (2001). Upper Echelons: Donald Hambrick On Executives And Strategy', doi
  184. (1984). Upper Echelons: The Organisation As A Reflection Of Its Top Managers', doi
  185. (1998). Value-Based Management - The Only Way To Manage For Value',
  186. (2000). Value-Based Management, doi
  187. (1986). Varieties Of Realism: A Rationale For The Natural Sciences, doi
  188. (1989). What Constitutes A Theoretical Contribution?', doi
  189. (2003). What Does Value Mean And How Is It Created, Maintained And Destroyed?', Paper Presented At The Academy Of Management Meeting,
  190. (2003). What Is This Thing Called Complexity? (Unpublished)
  191. (1997). What's Wrong With Strategy?',

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.