Location of Repository

Numerical investigation of recess casing treatments in axial flow fans

By Abdurazag M. Ghila


T he casing treatment technique for the axial fan has never been more significant since its potential applications were recognized in gas turbines, tunnel ventilation and many other industrial applications where the axial fan would benefit from the casing treatment. In the last two decades experimental investigations were carried out at Cranfield University to examine the influence of recess casing treatment on stall margin, operating efficiency and flow field of a low-speed axial flow fan. They showed more than 50% improvement in the stall margin with a negligible loss in the efficiency. However, a little work has been done on the numerical simulation of casing treatments due to its complexities, even though in recent years computational fluid dynamics [CFD] analysis has been very active in the prediction of various phenomena in turbomachinery. This work presents numerical investigation of flow in a single axial-flow fan with and without recess casing treatment. It involves the detailed effect of the recess casing on stall margin improvement as well as its influence on global performance parameters. The project offers a contribution to the understanding of the physical processes occurring when approaching stall and the working mechanism by which recess casing treatments improve stall margin. A Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes CFD code was used for the analysis using steady and unsteady simulations. The numerical investigation of the overall performance, efficiency and work-input characteristics of the fan were found to agree very well with the previously reported experimental results. The effect of casing treatment was investigated using two types of configurations, vaneless and vaned casing. The vaneless casing treatment produced a sizeable stall margin improvement with a measurable loss in both pressure rise and efficiency. The recess was fitted later with vanes and was shown to offer both a further stall margin improvement and an increase in the pressure rise coefficient without any significant drop in efficiency at design conditions. The effect of number of vanes inside the recess was also investigated by doubling and halving the number of vanes originally adopted. The predicted results highlighted the importance of the vane inside the casing. Unsteady simulations for the fan with solid and treated casing were carried out. The solid casing simulated for a single blade passage as well as for the entire fan containing all 27 blades highlighted the flow physics of the tip stall growth process, as a large amount of radial flow injected from the hub at the blade suction side near the trailing edge towards the outer casing and occupy this through a mechanism of radial low momentum flow transport. This transport process is the main contributor to the very large separation observed in the shroud region in addition to the locally induced separation due to high blade loading and tip clearance. Although the examination of the unsteady simulation of the recess treatment cavities does not offer an image of large scale unsteady activity at the flow condition investigated, this is on itself quite significant and enables the drawing of an important conclusion namely that large casing treatments rely primarily on a steady-state flow process. The corollary of this conclusion is of course that a steady-state simulation should then be sufficient to capture the essential features of the recess treatment

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 2003
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/7495
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles



  1. A Low-Speed Investigation into the Compressor Windmilling and Turbine Characteristics of Several Compressor Stages.
  2. (1986). A Multiscale Model for Turbulent Flows. doi
  3. (0439). A One-Equation Turbulence Model for Aerodynamic Flows. doi
  4. A Study of Stall in a Low liub-Tip Ratio Fan. doi
  5. A Two-Equation Turbulence Model for Wall-Bounded and Free-Shear Flows. doi
  6. (1995). An Introduction to Computational Fluid Dynamics, the Finite Volume Method.
  7. Analytical Study of Effect of Casing Treatment on Performance of Multi-stage Compressor.
  8. (2002). Computational Analysis of Heed Axial-Flow Compressors Using Two Deterministic Stress Models. PhD thesis,
  9. Development of Turbulence Models for Shear Flows by a Double Expansion Technique. doi
  10. (1976). Effect of Casing Treatment on Performance of an Inlet Stage for a Transonic Multi-stage Compressor.
  11. Efficiency and Accurarcy Issues in Contemporary CFD Algorithms. doi
  12. Flow Phenomena in Compressor Casing Treatment. doi
  13. (1980). Gerry Casing Treatment.
  14. (1986). Low Aspect Ratio Axial Flow Compressor - Why and What It Means. The 3M Elliot Garett Turbomachinery Award Lecture,
  15. (1992). Numerical Modelling of Viscous Turbomachinery Flows with Pressure Correction Method. PhD thesis,
  16. On the partial flow performances ow compressor and rotating stall. doi
  17. Removal of unstable operation of axial flow fan by means of separators.
  18. Stall in Low Hub-Tip Ratio Fans. IMechE,
  19. Stall Margin Improvement by Casing Treatment; Its Mechanism and Effectivness. doi
  20. Stator Hub Treatment Study.
  21. (1991). Viscous Fluid Flow. doi
  22. Wall-Function Boundary Conditions in the Solution of the Navier-Stockes Equations for Complex Compressible Flows. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.