Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The pricing of gasoline grades and the third law of demand

By R. Morris Coats, Gary M. Pecquet and Leon Taylor


Alchian and Allen’s “third law of demand” states that as a fixed cost increases by the same amount for low- and high-quality goods, the ratio of the prices of high- to low-quality goods will fall and the quantity demanded of high quality goods relative to low quality goods will increase. We examine the more general hypothesis by estimating the ratio of the quantities of sales of premium to regular grade gasoline using the ratio of premium to regular prices, controlling for supply and demand factors. We find moderate evidence for the more general hypothesis.Third Law of Demand, Price Ratios, Gasoline Grades

OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1980). A heteroskedasticity-consistent covariance matrix estimator and a direct test for heteroskedasticity,
  2. (1967). An alternative approach to the analysis of taxation,
  3. (1991). Analyzing gasoline elasticities: a survey.
  4. (2004). Consumer price index, available at URL: (downloaded 10/10/2004).
  5. (1995). Good grapes and bad lobsters: applying the Alchian and Allen theorem,
  6. (1996). Highway statistics, available at URL: (downloaded 11/1/2004).
  7. (2004). Information Administration,
  8. (2005). Internal Revenue Service data book, available at URL:,,id=102174,00.html (downloaded 5/1/2005).
  9. (2003). Introductory econometrics: A modern approach, 2 nd edition (SouthWestern,
  10. (2004). Monthly motor fuel reported by states, available at URL: ( (downloaded 7/1/2004).
  11. (2005). of Economic Analysis,
  12. (2004). Producer price index for petroleum refineries, available at URL: (downloaded 7/1/2004).
  13. (2005). Quarterly summary of state and local tax revenues, available at URL: (downloaded 5/1/2005).
  14. (1978). Shipping the good apples out: The Alchian and Allen theorem reconsidered,
  15. (2005). Statistical abstract of the United States, available at URL: (downloaded 5/1/2005).
  16. (2005). Taxation and product quality: The gasoline market, working paper
  17. (2002). Taxes and quality: a market-level analysis,
  18. (1969). The substitution effects of transportation costs,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.