Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Measuring ideas more effectively: an analysis of Bush and Kerry's national security speeches

By Cheryl Schonhardt-Bailey


On Sunday, October 10th, 2004, the New York Times Magazine featured an article with the cover title, “Really, What Does He Think? John Kerry and the Post-9/11 World” (Bai 2004). On the cover of the magazine was a serious-looking photo of Senator Kerry, superimposed with keywords such as “Terrorism,” “Iraq,” “Al Qaeda,” “Multilateralism,” “Nuclear proliferation,” and so on. While the article itself was intriguing, even more intriguing was the magazine's attempt to capture Kerry's core ideas on American national security with the use of keyword graphics—namely, the keywords on the cover, placed in what appeared to be a random order around the photo of Kerry, and the underlining of “John Kerry,” “terrorism,” and “Americans” in the inside title. Catchy graphics, but hardly an accurate depiction of the keywords that might actually represent Kerry's thinking on American national security. And, for all the comparison made in the article itself with President Bush's stance on national security, where were the graphics for George W.? (They did not emerge in the next New York Times Magazine.) The magazine was, nonetheless, making an important point: that words (and the ideas they represent) are emotive—particularly in the highly charged climate of the 2004 presidential campaign

Topics: JK Political institutions (United States), JZ International relations
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Year: 2005
DOI identifier: 10.1017/S1049096505050195
OAI identifier:
Provided by: LSE Research Online

Suggested articles


  1. (1998). A Social Representations Approach to the Comparison of Three Textual Corpora Using Alceste.
  2. George Bush Wins: Back to Basics.” The Economist,
  3. (2004). Kerry’s Undeclared War: John Kerry Has a Thoughtful, Forwardlooking Theory about Terrorism and How to Fight It. But Can
  4. (2005). Central Bankers and Big Ideas: Independence, Credibility, Uncertainty and Measurement in FOMC Transcripts.” Paper presented at European Public Choice Society Annual Meeting, at
  5. (1998). Choosing Qualitative Data Analysis Software: Atlas0ti and doi
  6. (2000). Classical Content Analysis: A Review.”
  7. (1981). Pratique de l’analyse des donnees: linguistique et lexicologie. doi
  8. (1973). L’Analyse des Donnees. Tome1: La Taxinomie. Tome 2: L’Analyse des Correspondances.
  9. (1975). Analyse des donnees multidimensionnelles.
  10. (1998). Epitaphs. Francois Mitterrand’s Image: An Analysis of an
  11. (2000). The Discourse of Demands and Action
  12. (1982). Elements d’analyse des donnees.
  13. (2004). Moral Values and the Next ‘Big Story’.” National Public Radio,N o -vember 8,
  14. (1998). A Spot Check: Casting Doubt on the Demobilizing Effect of Attack Advertising.” doi
  15. (2000). Putting Parties in Their Place: Inferring Party Left-Right Ideological Positions from Party Manifestos Data.” doi
  16. (2002). Researching and Teaching Political Culture through WebBased Content Profile Analysis.” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association,
  17. (2003). Doing Web-Based Content Profile Analysis.” doi
  18. (1984). Theory and Applications of Correspondence Analysis. doi
  19. (1993). Correspondence Analysis in Practice.
  20. (1982). Scaling a Data matrix in Lowdimensional Euclidean Space.” doi
  21. (1950). On the Quantification of Qualitative Data from the Mathematicsstatistical Point of View.”
  22. (1997). The Liberal-Conservative Ideology of U.S. doi
  23. (1974). An Historical Note on the Use of Word-Frequency Contingencies doi
  24. (1974). WORDS: A Computer System for the Analysis of doi
  25. (1991). Explaining Change in Policy Subsystems: Analysis of Coalition Stability and Defection over Time.” doi
  26. (1996). Computers Can Read as Well as Count: How Computer-aided Text Analysis Can Benefit Organisational Research.” doi
  27. (1996). Changes in the Espoused Values of Australian Organizations 1986–1990.” doi
  28. (1992). Does Being Male Help? An Investigation of the Effects of Candidate Gender and Campaign Coverage on Evaluation of U.S. doi
  29. (2004). Personal communication with the author,
  30. (2000). Keywords in Context: Statistical Analysis of Text Features.” doi
  31. (1996). A Method to Extract Social Representations from Linguistic Corpora.” doi
  32. (1998). Penser manger. doi
  33. (2002). Locating TDs in Policy Spaces: Wordscoring Dail Speeches.” doi
  34. (2000). Estimating Policy Positions from Political Texts.” doi
  35. (1995). Is American Foreign Policy Exceptional? doi
  36. (1982). Coding Open-Ended Answers with the Help of a
  37. (1997). Frame Mapping and Analysis of doi
  38. (2004). Surfing the Money Tides: Understanding the Foreign Exchange Market through Metaphors.” doi
  39. (2000). Computer-assisted Text Analysis. doi
  40. (1983). Remarks at the Annual Convention of the National Association of Evangelicals. speeches/ronaldreaganevilempire.htm Reinert,
  41. (1940). The Great Arsenal of Democracy. www.american democracy.html Ruggie,
  42. (2006). From the Corn Laws to Free Trade: Interests, Ideas and Institutions in Historical Perspective. doi
  43. (1990). Metric Scaling: Correspondence Analysis. London: Sage Publications. PSOnline 711

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.