Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The third way and social welfare : the myth of post-emotionalism

By Hartley Dean


The ‘passive’ welfare state was accused of promoting a dependency culture. ‘Active’ welfare and the ‘what works?’ approach of Britain’s New Labour government is allegedly implicated in an age of post-emotionalism, in which people are largely indifferent to the needs of others and committed primarily to their personal well-being. This paper seeks first, to extend recent debates about agency and motivation in social policy and relate them to the notion of post-emotionalism. Second, it draws on a recent empirical study of popular and welfare provider discourses, which suggests that popular opinion can accommodate an appreciation of human interdependency, while welfare providers remain committed to a public service ethos. None the less, Third Way thinking is associated with a narrowing of solidaristic responsibilities. The problem for the future of health, social care and state welfare policies lies not with the imagined consequences of post-emotionalism, so much as with an ideological context that perpetuates a distorted ethic of responsibility

Topics: H Social Sciences (General), JA Political science (General)
Publisher: Wiley
Year: 2003
DOI identifier: 10.1046/j.1467-9515.2003.00366.x
OAI identifier:
Provided by: LSE Research Online
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • (external link)
  • http://www.blackwellpublishing... (external link)
  • (external link)
  • Suggested articles


    1. 0 ) Towards the Transformation of Philosophy , London : Routle d g e .
    2. (2004). a ) ‘Popu l a r disco u r s e s of depen d e n c y , respo n s i b i l i t y and right s ’ ,
    3. (1999). a ) Putting Rights into Public Service: An introduction for public authorities L ondo n : Hom e Offic e Co mm u n i c a t i o n s Direc t o r a t e .
    4. (1972). A Theory of Justice, doi
    5. (1972). A Theory of Justice, Oxford : Oxford Univer s i t y Press. Rodg e r ,
    6. (2004). Administering rights for dependent subjects’, doi
    7. (1999). Agen c y , m ode r n i t y and soci a l pol i c y ’ ,
    8. (2004). Agency, dependency and welfare: Beyond issues of claim and contribution’, doi
    9. (1999). Agency, modernity and social policy’, doi
    10. (1999). and Schro d e r
    11. (2004). b ) ‘Adm i n i s t e r i n g righ t s for depen d e n t subje c t s ’ ,
    12. (1999). B l a c k m a n doi
    13. (1994). Beyond Left and Right, doi
    14. (2003). Changing Britain, Changing Lives: Three generations at the turn of the century, London: Institute of Education.
    15. (1999). Continuity or modernisation? The emergence of New Labour’s welfare state’,
    16. (1990). Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society, doi
    17. (1992). Dependency Culture: The explosion of a myth, Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf. doi
    18. (1999). Europe: The Third Way/Die Neue Mitte,
    19. (2004). Fost e r i n g a hum an right s disco u r s e in the provi s i o n of socia l care for adults ’ ,
    20. (2004). Fostering a human rights discourse in the provision of social care for adults’, doi
    21. (2000). Fr o m knig h t to kna ve ? Pub l i c po li c y an d m a rk e t ince n t i v
    22. (2000). From a Welfare State to a Welfare Society, doi
    23. (2003). From Knight to Knave and from Pawn to Queen: Motivation and agency in public policy,
    24. (2003). From Knight to Knave and from Pawn to Queen: Motivation and agency in public policy, Oxfor d : Oxfor d Unive r s i t y Press .
    25. (2000). From knight to knave? Public policy and market incentives’,
    26. (1990). G a l l i e , D. an d Vogle r , C. (
    27. (1990). Gidd e n s
    28. (1994). Hard Times: How poor families make ends meet, London: Policy Studies Institute Le Grand, doi
    29. (1995). Himm e l f a r b , G.
    30. Home Office (1999a) Putting Rights into Public Service: An introduction for public authorities London: Home Office Communications Directorate.
    31. (2000). How are the m i ght y f a lle n : What accou n t s for the dram a t i c decli n e of unio n s i n Brit a i n ?
    32. (2000). How are the mighty fallen: What accounts for the dramatic decline of unions in
    33. (1990). Ingl e h a r t
    34. (1997). Kem p s o n . E., Bry s o n , A. and Rowl i n g s o n ,
    35. (2000). Mana g i n g risk by cont r o l l i n g behav i o u r : Socia l secur i t y adm i n i s t r a t i o n and the erosi o n
    36. (2000). Managing risk by controlling behaviour: Social security administration and the erosion of welfare citizenship’,
    37. (1997). Mestr o v i c
    38. (1978). Natural Symbols, doi
    39. (1993). Negotiating Family Responsibilities, doi
    40. (2004). Popular discourses of dependency, responsibility and rights’, doi
    41. (1993). Postmodern Ethics, doi
    42. (1999). Poverty, Riches and Social Citizenship, doi
    43. (2004). Responsibility and welfare: In search of moral sensibility’, doi
    44. (1992). Risk Society: Towards a new modernity , Lond o n : Sage . doi
    45. (1992). Risk Society: Towards a new modernity, doi
    46. (2000). Ro ths t e i n
    47. (1998). Social Security (DSS)
    48. (2003). Social solidarity, welfare and post-emotionalism’, doi
    49. (1981). States of Welfare, doi
    50. (1980). Street-level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the individual in public services, doi
    51. (1982). The Anti-Social Family, doi
    52. (1990). The Consequences of Modernity, doi
    53. (1995). The De-Moralisation of Society, London: Institute of Economic Affairs.
    54. (1996). The death of the social ? ’ doi
    55. (1996). The death of the social?’,
    56. (2000). The Demoralization of Western Culture: Social theory and the dilemmas of modern living, doi
    57. (1988). The Free Economy and the Strong State, doi
    58. (1970). The Gift Relationship: From human blood to social policy, London: Allen and Unwin. doi
    59. (2000). The Government of Risk: Understanding risk regulation regimes, doi
    60. (1997). The Managerial State , Lond o n : S a ge .
    61. (1997). The Managerial State, doi
    62. (1995). The Struggle for Recognition: The moral grammar of social conflicts, doi
    63. (1998). The Third Way, doi
    64. (1998). The Third Way, Cambr i d g e : Polit y . Higg i n s
    65. (1980). Towards the Transformation of Philosophy, doi
    66. (1990). Unemployment and Attitudes to Work, Working Paper no.
    67. (1987). Welf a r e and depen d e n c y ’ , Speech to Conser v a t i v e Consti t u e n c y Partie s ’ Assoc i a t i o n , Septe m b e r .
    68. (1987). Welfare and dependency’, Speech to Conservative Constituency Parties’
    69. (2002). Welfare Rights and Social Policy, doi
    70. (2002). Welfare Rights and Social Policy, Harlow : Prenti c e Hall.
    71. (1999). wit h Melro s e
    72. (2003). y n n e r , J. and W a lsw o r t h doi

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.