Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Conservation with a gun: Understanding landowner attitudes to deer hunting in the Scottish Highlands

By Douglas C. MacMillan and Kirsty Leitch


Conservation conflicts are often difficult to resolve due to a combination of poorly defined property rights, inadequate funding, high transaction costs, and contrasting value systems among stakeholders. This paper explores these barriers to collaboration in the context of the emerging deer crisis in the Scottish Highlands, where deer numbers are now higher than at any time in recorded history. In particular we explore the potential role of recreational hunting in the government's strategy to contain rising deer numbers from the landowners' perspective. Using both qualitative and quantitative analysis we find that hunting traditions and personal preferences, reinforced by antipathy to conservationists and their perceptions of land stewardship, are the major barriers to shooting more deer for conservation objectives. We conclude that an expansion of commercial hunting opportunities is the best practical approach to resolving the current conflict over deer, but conservationists and landowners must work together to create a more positive context for hunter-conservation initiatives and activities

Topics: GE, GN
Year: 2008
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2008). 36:473–484 483 483Roos,
  2. (2003). Adapting Adaptive Management to a Cultural Understanding of Land Use Conflicts. doi
  3. (2002). Annual Report 2001/02. Deer Commission for
  4. (2005). Annual Report 2004/05. Deer Commission for
  5. (2000). Capercaillie in Scotland—Demography of a Declining Population.
  6. (2004). Country Sports Tourism in Scotland. TNS Travel and Tourism,
  7. (1994). Culling Regimes and Sex Ratio Biases in Highland Red Deer.
  8. (2000). Deer: Law and Liabilities.
  9. Developing a Strategic Plan for Future Hunting Participation in Texas.
  10. (2007). Economic and Conservation Significance of the Trophy Hunting Industry in Sub-Saharan Africa.
  11. (2004). Economic impacts of wild deer in the East of England., Rep. No. Report to the Forestry Commission and
  12. (2004). Economic impacts of wild deer in the East of England., Rep. No. Report to the Forestry Commission and English Nature.
  13. (2003). Enhancing Sport-Hunting Opportunities for Urbanites.
  14. (1996). Estimating the Minimum Population Size that Allows a Given Number of Mature Red Deer Stags to be Culled Sustainably.
  15. (2006). Exploding Deer Populations. Science.
  16. (2000). Guns, Game and the Grandee: the Cultural Politics of Deerstalking in the Scottish Highlands.
  17. (2003). Hunting Ruralities: Nature, Society and Culture in ‘Hunt Countries’ of England and Wales.
  18. (2003). Impacts of Wild Deer
  19. (2008). Investors in Sporting Estates Land a Better Return than Shares Traders The Scotsman,
  20. (1994). Land Use Change on Scottish Highland Estates.
  21. (2000). Making Collaboration Work: Lessons from Innovation in Natural Resource Management. doi
  22. (1990). Monitoring the Status of European and North American Cervids. The Global Environmental Monitoring Information Series.
  23. (2000). Raptors and Red Grouse: Conservation Conflicts and Management Solutions. doi
  24. (2004). Red Deer Stocks in the Highlands of Scotland.
  25. Scottish Wild Game: Feasibility Study. SAOS cooperating enterprises.
  26. (2002). Sex Differences in Emigration and Mortality Affect Optimal Management of Deer Populations.
  27. (2006). Sportsman shot, Poacher’s Pot
  28. (1994). Talking About Trees. Environment and Society in Forest Workers’ Culture.
  29. (2006). Temporal and Spatial Development of Red Deer Harvesting in Europe: Biological and Cultural Factors.
  30. (1997). Texas Females Who Hunt.
  31. (1960). The Deer Stalking Grounds of Great Britain and
  32. (2000). The Future of Hunting as a Mechanism to Control White-Tailed Deer Populations.
  33. (1994). The Implications of Red Deer Grazing to Ground Vegetation and Invertebrate Communities of Scottish Native Pinewoods.
  34. (1920). The Influence of Man on the Animal Life of Scotland.
  35. (1983). The Invention of Tradition: The Highland Tradition of Scotland.
  36. (1983). The Invention of Tradition: The Highland TraditionofScotland.InHobsbawm,E.,andRanger,T.(eds.),The Invention of Tradition.
  37. (2004). The Management of Wild Large Herbivores to Meet Economic, Conservation and Environmental Objectives.
  38. (1998). The Non-market Benefits and Costs of Native Wodland Restoration.
  39. (1883). The Population, Crofts, Sheep Walks, and Deer Forests of the Highlands and Islands.
  40. (2003). Tradeable Deer Obligations—A CostEffective Answer to Too Many Deer?

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.