Article thumbnail

Arts practices in unreasonable doubt? Reflections on understandings of arts practices in healthcare contexts

By Sheelagh Broderick


This article suggests that the discourse on arts and health encompass contemporary arts practices as an active and engaged analytical activity. Distinctions between arts therapy and arts practice are made to suggest that clinical evidence-based evaluation, while appropriate for arts therapy, is not appropriate for arts practice and in effect cast them in unreasonable doubt. Themes in current discourse on “arts” and “health” are broadly sketched to provide a context for discussion of arts practices. Approaches to knowledge validation in relation to each domain are discussed. These discourses are applied to the Irish healthcare context, offering a reading of three different art projects; it suggests a multiplicity of analyses beyond causal positive health gains. It is suggested that the social turn in medicine and the social turn in arts practices share some similar pre-occupations that warrant further attention

Topics: Policy
Publisher: Taylor & Francis
OAI identifier:
Provided by: PubMed Central

Suggested articles


  1. (2007). (More or less) Democratic form: Relational aesthetics and the rhetoric of globalisation.
  2. (2000). 6). Medical humanities.R etrieved October 12, 2009, from Hacking, S. (2006).M entalh ealtha nd arts participation: thes tate of thea rt in England. TheJ ournal of theR oyal Societyf or theP romotion of Health,
  3. (2008). Ac linically useful artwork? Between a dialogical and ar elational approach to art in ac linical environment.
  4. (2004). Antagonism and relational aesthetics.
  5. (1997). Ar ebuttal on health.
  6. (2010). Art in the social sphere.P resented at the Art and the Social: Exhibitions of Contemporary Art
  7. (2008). Closing the gap in ag eneration: Health equity through action on the social determinants of health.G eneva: Commission on Social Determinants of Health, World Health Organization.
  8. (2007). Editorial: Community development and the arts: Reviving the democratic imagination.
  9. (2006). Establishing Common ground in community-baseda rtsi nh ealth. TheJ ournal of theR oyal Societyf or theP romotion of Health,
  10. (2001). Evidence-based art?
  11. (1999). Evidence-based medicine and medical authority.
  12. (2001). Evidence-based medicine, clinical uncertainty, and learning to doctor.
  13. (2009). Exhibition Review Article. The power of presence: The ‘Cradle to Grave’installation at the British Museum.
  14. (2008). from 07/socially_engage.php
  15. (2006). Genning up: Ar esearch paper for Blue Drum on community based arts in health. Durham: Centre for Arts &H umanities in Health &M edicine,
  16. (2008). Include me out. Art Monthly,
  17. (2009). On creating the discipline, profession, and evidence in the field of arts and healthcare. Arts &H ealth: An International Journal for Research, Policy and Practice,
  18. (2002). Photo images: Jo Spence’s narratives of living with illness.
  19. (2008). Playing in the mud: Health psychology, the arts and creative approaches to health care.
  20. (2009). Reflections on the politics of practice and the art of Conde
  21. (2002). Relational aesthetics.C ollection Documents sur l’art.
  22. (2005). Researching the benefits of arts in health.
  23. (2006). Socially engaged art, critics and discontents: An interview with Claire Bishop.
  24. (2008). Striving to do good things: Teaching humanities in Canadian medical schools.
  25. (2003). The arts and health handbook: Ap ractical guide.D ublin: Arts Council of Ireland.
  26. (2005). The impact of inequality.L ondon:
  27. (2007). The Lost Children.
  28. (2009). The radicant.N ew
  29. (1993). The social impact of the arts: Ad iscussion document.S troud:
  30. (2008). The social impact of the arts: An intellectual history.
  31. (2006). The social turn: Collaboration and its discontents.
  32. (2009). The spirit level: Why more equal societies almost always do better.L ondon:
  33. (1999). The World Health Report
  34. (2005). Toward an ew understanding of the social impact of the arts.
  35. (2004). Training to be aS ervice User.
  36. (2010). Two voices.P resented at the Professional Development Seminar, Waterford Healing Arts Trust,
  37. (2008). Using narrative inquiry to explore the impact of art on individuals.
  38. (2009). Vital signs: The value of arts and health.P resented at the Vital Signs Conference, Dublin: Arts Council of Ireland. Retrieved from 2009/10/1354/ Pharmacopoeia.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.