Location of Repository

The discrepancy between actual and unreported incidents of violence in a learning disability nursing service

By Joanne Skellern and Andy Lovell


This article is not available through ChesterRep. It can be accessed at http://www2.hud.ac.uk/hhs/mhrg/journal/discrepancy.pdfThis study reports on research carried out within the Learning Disability Division of a major Mental Health NHS Trust in the North of England, and relates to the discrepancy between the actual number of incidents of violence and aggression and those reported. The literature review demonstrated that violence is a particular issue for nurses, particularly those working in the areas of mental health and learning disability where studies have indicated that as many as one in five may be affected. A questionnaire was distributed to all learning disability nurses currently employed in the Trust, a total of 411, with a response rate in excess of 40%.\ud The study revealed that a discrepancy does exist between actual and reported incidents of violence within the Trust. It confirmed previous claims that the predominant difficulty is cultural, violence being regarded as part of the job and non-reporting primarily revolving around perceptions of incidents being considered 'minor', not worth the time to complete the paperwork. The paper concludes that more work is needed to achieve a united, consistent approach across the NHS, in order that a high quality, accessible service for people with learning disabilities and complex needs can be delivered without violence being considered an acceptable part of the job

Topics: violence, aggression, discrepancy, unreported, learning disabilities, minor
Publisher: South West Yorkshire Mental Health NHS Trust and the University of Huddersfield
Year: 2008
OAI identifier: oai:chesterrep.openrepository.com:10034/76734
Provided by: ChesterRep

Suggested articles



  1. (2004). 15M That’s How Much Attacks on
  2. (2004). 15M That’sH ow Much Attacks on
  3. (2006). A clearer picture of abuse,
  4. (1994). A Comparison of Video Cameras and Official Incident Reports in Detailing In-Patient Assaults,
  5. (1998). A Lovell Health & Safety Executive
  6. (1998). A Lovell United Kingdom Central Council
  7. (1999). A National Service Framework for Mental Health, Modern Standards and Service Models, doi
  8. (2003). A Safer Place to Work - doi
  9. (1998). A Study of Incidents of Violence Towards Staff by Patients in an NHS Trust Hospital, doi
  10. (1998). AL ovell208 United Kingdom Central Council
  11. (1999). AN ational Service Frameworkf or Mental Health, ModernS tandards and Service Models, Department of Health, CrownC opyright.
  12. (1998). AS tudy of Incidents of ViolenceT owards Staff by Patients
  13. (1993). Central Council1 993. Standards for Recordsa nd Record Keeping,
  14. (1988). Challenging Behaviour and Community Services: Who are the People Who Challenge Services?, doi
  15. (1995). Cited in:U nited Kingdom Central Council
  16. (1995). Defining and Treating Challenging Behaviour, NursingS tandard,
  17. (2001). Design and Use of Questionnaires: A Review of Best Practice Applicable to Surveys of Health Service Staff and Patients,
  18. (2001). Designa nd Useo f Questionnaires: AR eviewo fB estP ractice Applicablet oS urveys of Health Service Staff and Patients,
  19. (1999). Doing Your Research Project, doi
  20. (1999). Doing Your Research Project, London: Open UniversityP ress.
  21. (1995). Expressed Emotion, Attributions and Coping in Staff who have been Victims of Violent Incidents. doi
  22. (1995). ExpressedE motion, Attributions and Copingi nS taff whoh aveb een Victimso fV iolent Incidents.
  23. (1994). Facing up to the Challenge: Av iewo ft he Capacityo fS ervices to Meet the Needs of Peoplew ithC hallenging Behaviour,
  24. (1996). Guidelines for Professional Practice, doi
  25. (1988). hallengingB ehaviour and Community Services: Whoa re the People Who Challenge Services?,M ental doi
  26. HealthS ervicesA dvisoryC ommittee 1987. Violence to Staff in theH ealth Services, Health ServicesA dvisory Committee report,
  27. (1999). Learning Disabilities, (3 rd Ed), London: Churchill Livingstone – An inprint of
  28. (2002). Liberating the Talents, Department of Health,
  29. (2002). Liberating the Talents,D epartment of Health,
  30. (1992). London: United Kingdom CentralC ouncil for Nursing, Midwifery&Health Visiting.
  31. (1999). McCafferty,G .&McMahon,A .1 999. Danger at Work?–Violence and Mental Health Nursing, Mental HealthP ractice,A pril
  32. (1998). Morale and Collaboration Keys to Managing Violence,
  33. (1998). Moralea nd Collaboration Keyst oM anaging Violence,
  34. (2003). NationalA udit Office,L ondon: TheS tationaryO ffice.
  35. (2005). NHS Staff Attacked Every Two Hours, retrieved on 04/12/05 from: http://www.paramedic.org.uk/news_archive/2005/07/news24070501/view
  36. (1993). NHS Staff Attacked EveryT wo Hours, retrievedo n0 4/12/05 from: http://www.paramedic.org.uk/news_archive/2005/07/news24070501/view
  37. (2005). NonSomatic Effectso fP atient Aggressiono nN urses: AS ystematic Review,
  38. (1996). Phasing out Seclusion Through Staff Training
  39. (1996). PracticalS ocialR esearch:P roject Work in the Community.B asingstoke:
  40. (2006). Press release, retrieved on Wednesday 19/07/06 from: www.cfsms.nhs.uk/press/index.html,
  41. (2006). Pressr elease, retrieved on Wednesday 19/07/06 from: www.cfsms.nhs.uk/press/index.html,
  42. (1996). Risk Assessment. “A Word to the Wise?” doi
  43. (1996). Risk Assessment. “A Word to theW ise?” Advancesi n Psychiatric Treatment, 2: 3–1 0. doi
  44. (1995). Roleo ft he Organisation.
  45. RoyalC ollege of Nursing1 998. Dealingw ithV iolenceA gainstN ursingS taff: An RCN Guidef or Nurses&Managers,A pril 1998, London: Royal College of Nursing.
  46. (1994). Sexual Behaviour in Britain: The National Survey of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles. doi
  47. (2007). Snyder,W .&Merrill,G .L .1 981. Underreporting of Assaults on Staff in aS tate Hospital,H ospital and Community Psychiatry3 2: 497- 8
  48. (1993). Standards for Records and Record Keeping, doi
  49. (2002). The Recognition, Prevention and Therapeutic Management of Violence in Mental Health Care,
  50. (2001). TheP atient from Hell,
  51. (2002). TheR ecognition, Prevention and TherapeuticM anagement of Violence
  52. (2000). TheR esearch Processi nn ursing, (4 th Ed.),O xford:
  53. (1981). Underreporting of Assaults on Staff in a State Hospital, Hospital and Community Psychiatry 32: 497- 8
  54. (1996). United KingdomC entral Council
  55. (1999). Using and Conducting Nursing Research doi
  56. (1999). Usinga nd Conducting NursingR esearchi n the Clinical Setting (2 nd Ed),P hiladelphia: W.B.SaundersC ompany –ADivision of HarcourtB race &C ompany.
  57. (2006). Violence against HS Staff Down and Prosecutions Up: New Measures to Tackle A & E Louts Announced.
  58. (1997). Violence to Nurses: Prevalence and Risk Factors,
  59. (1997). Violencet oN urses: Prevalencea nd Risk Factors, Nursing Standard,
  60. (2003). Violent Incidents and Staff Stress. doi
  61. (1998). Working Together - Securing a Quality Workforce for the NHS,
  62. (1998). WorkingT ogether -S ecuringaQ ualityW orkforce for the NHS,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.