Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The Evolution of Music: A comparison of Darwinian and dialectical methods

By Dr Derek Gatherer


Music provides a challenging system for the analysis of cultural evolution. The dialectical approach to music seeks to identify the internal stylistic tensions and contradictions (in terms of thesis and antithesis) which give rise to new musical forms (synthesis). The Darwinian alternative to dialectics, which in its most reductionist form is becoming known as memetics, seeks to interpret the evolution of music by examining the adaptiveness of its various component parts in the selective environment of culture. This essay compares the memetic and dialectical approaches with special reference to the development of jazz in the era of recorded sound, in the light of Benzon’s classification of musical styles into evolutionary Ranks (Benzon 1993). It is concluded that the basic postulate of memetics is falsifiable and therefore that memetics qualifies as scientific in the Popperian sense, rather than being simply a pseudo-scientific metanarrative for cultural evolution. Some suggestions for empirical analysis are provided. In contrast, the dialectical perspective is not scientific in the Popperian sense, but does provide a good explanatory framework for the history of jazz in the years 1900-1970, and shows how transitions between Ranks may be generated. However, dialectics is considerably less successful in the construction of a model to explain the period since 1970

Topics: Evolution
Publisher: JAI Press Inc.
Year: 1997
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1991). 1) Mankind Evolving. New York: Bantam Books. Feyerabend, P.K. (196311968) “How to be a Good Empiricist - a Plea for Tolerance in Matters Epistemological,”
  2. (1986). 1) The Genetics of Human Populations.
  3. (1982). 989) The Logic of Life: a History of Heredity, and, The Possible and the Actual.
  4. (1993). A Population Memetics Approach to Cultural Evolution in
  5. (1994). A Population Memetics Approach to Cultural Evolution in Chaffinch Song-Differentiation Among Populations.”
  6. (1995). A Short History
  7. (1966). Aduptation and Nuturul Selection.
  8. (1995). American Pioneers: Ives to Cage and Beyond.
  9. (1972). An Introduction to Social Anthropology, 2nd ed.
  10. (1981). Cultural Transmission and Evolution: A Quantitative Approach.
  11. (1996). Culture as an Evolutionary Arena.”
  12. (1974). Intellectual Autobiography,”
  13. (1993). Jazz Milestones: A Pictorial Chronicle of Jazz 1900-1990.
  14. (1977). Lenin and Philosophy, and Other Essays,
  15. (1990). Memetic Science: l-General Introduction.”
  16. (1997). Music Making History: Africa Meets Europe in the United States of the Blues,”
  17. (1982). Social Anthropology.
  18. (1993). Stages in the Evolution of Music.”
  19. (1959). The Concept of Culture.”
  20. (1959). The Future of Man.”
  21. (1930). The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection.
  22. (1983). The Jazz Book: From New Orleans to Jazz Rock
  23. (1993). The Land Where the Blues Begun.
  24. (1995). The Major Transitions in Evolution.
  25. (1978). The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes. Philosophical Papers Vol.
  26. (1945). The Open Society and its Enemies.
  27. (1959). The Phenomenon ofMun.
  28. (1957). The Poverty of Historicism. London: Routledge and Kegan
  29. (1976). The Selfish Gene.
  30. (1990). The Threat and the Glory.
  31. (1982). Theory and Observation in
  32. (1996). Thought Contagion.
  33. (1983). Universal Darwinism, ”
  34. (1993). Viruses of the Mind, ”

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.