Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Developing SMEs through large firm-small firm linkages

By Catherine Kadenyeka Madete Masinde

Abstract

This thesis aims to explore the prospects for small and medium enterprise (SME) development using inter-finn linkages between large and small finns in Kenya A wide range of strategies has been adopted already for the development of small enterprises globally, but limited use appears to have been made, outside Japan, of inter-finn linkages as a specific strategy. Despite the recent global movement towards inter-finn relationships as a strategy for achieving efficiency through the down-sizing of large finns, externalisation of activities, and adoption of lean production techniques, no attempt appears to have been made to use the strategy for SME development, possibly because little is known about how inter-finn linkages between large and small .finns are fonned. This thesis aims to con1ribute to the development of this understanding by using an inductive, qualitative research approach to explore the fuctors influencing the sourcing strategies of large finns in Kenya, to detennine whether these have some potential for SME development both in the country and more generally. The study focuses on the Kenyan vehicle assembly industry and examines, through in-depth case studies, the sourcing activities of three vehicle assembly plants and four franchise holders. Overnll, the research lends support to the argument that for various reasons largely related to m.arlcet failure, and a non-conducive business environment, large firms in Kenya's motor vehicle industIy are reluctant to outsource voluntarily from local small finns, and that when they do, relations appear to be arms-length and adversarial. The research also reveals that in the Kenyan environment, contrary to the arguments of transaction cost theory, outsourcing decisions are predicated on the need to comply with compulsory regulations in order to gain access to resources and m.arlcets, rather -than primarily on cost minimisation. Consequently, strategies which assure access to resources such as foreign exchange and impo.rt licenses were found to override purely efficiency considerations. The findings imply that although there are some prospects for SME development using this approach, the selection of small enterprises as suppliers by managers of large firms is limited by large firms' perceptions of the suitability of such suppliers, and that if SME development is to take place through such linkages, strategies which either change the image of small suppliers, or improve the attitudes oflarge buyers have to be adopted

Year: 1994
OAI identifier: oai:etheses.dur.ac.uk:694
Provided by: Durham e-Theses

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1986). (1988/89) Industry and Development: Global Report.
  2. (1957). (l986) "Industrial change and territorial organisation: a summing up" in Scott A J and Storper M (eels.) Production, Work, Territory: The Geographical Anatomy of Industrial Capitalism. Allen and Unwin, Boston Seleznick P
  3. (1975). A
  4. (1993). A A doi
  5. (1983). A Framework for Looking at Vertical Integration" doi
  6. (1976). A H doi
  7. (1970). A L (I970) "Theoretical sampling".
  8. (1988). A Study of the life cycle of joint ventures",
  9. (1992). A sub-sector approach to small enteIprise promotion and research", doi
  10. (1987). A systems engineering approach to fundamental change in manufacturing",
  11. (1986). Aboagye A A
  12. (1985). Alliance, the new strategic focus", doi
  13. (1979). An emerging strategy of "direct" research". doi
  14. (1984). Analysing Qualitative Data: A Source Book for New Methods. Sage,
  15. (1984). Ancillary finn development in the Korean automobile industry", in Odaka
  16. (1986). and Green A E doi
  17. APPENDIX G cKita le cEldoret Kisunu Nakuru o c laa II'Ii Nanyuki c cNyeri c Thika • NAIROBI KENYA fopulation 21.3 Million Area (sq 11'11) 221,96a City Population [] Ouer l,aaa,aaa o Ouer saa, aaa o Ouer lea, eee c Under lee,
  18. (1986). Approaches to developing an efficient transport vehicles industry in Kenya",
  19. (1976). Appropriate factor proportions for manufacturing in Less Developed Countries: A survey of the evidence. doi
  20. (1991). Are there decreasing economies of scale over time in Dutch Manufacturing?",
  21. (1982). Asking questions: A practical guide to questionnaire design. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco. doi
  22. (1990). Bases of interorganisational co-operation: Propensity, Power, Persistence", doi
  23. (1993). Beyond Mass Production. doi
  24. (1988). Breaking the entrepreneurial bottleneck in late developing countries: Is there a useful role for government?",
  25. (1989). Building theories from case study research". doi
  26. (1984). Business and the business life cycle in the UK",
  27. (1991). Buyer-seller relations in the UK automotive industry",
  28. (1992). Buyer-supplier relations in the UK automotive industry: Strategic implications of the Japanese manufucturing model", doi
  29. (1982). Capitalist accumulation in the periphery: Kenya, in Martin Frnnsman (ed) Industry and accumulation in Africa.
  30. (1986). Changing Work Patterns: How Companies Achieve Flexibility to Meet New Needs. National Economic Development Office,
  31. (1985). Competitive Advantage. doi
  32. (1980). Competitive Strategy. doi
  33. (1991). Competitive TIes: Subcontracting in the Japanese Automotive Industry. doi
  34. (1983). Cooperative practices among small and medium sized establishments",
  35. (1988). Creating Capitalism: The state and small business since 1945. Basil Blackwell, doi
  36. (1977). Definition et typologie de la sous-traitance", doi
  37. (1977). Dependent Industrialisation in Latin America: The Automotive Industry doi
  38. (1990). Detenninants of interorganisational relationships: Integration and future directions",
  39. (1974). Development Plans.
  40. (1988). Development policy and inappropriate product technology",
  41. (1988). Dismantling flexibility", doi
  42. (1991). Driving a Bargain: Automotive Industrialisation and Japanese Firms in South East Asia.
  43. (1988). Driving Force: The Global Restructuring of Technology, Labor and Investment in the Automobile and Components Industries. doi
  44. (1991). Dynamics of MlCl'D-enterprises: Research Issues and Approaches.
  45. (1993). Economic Survey. Government Printers,
  46. (1988). Economies of scale, capacity utilisation and import substitution: A focus on dies, moulds and patterns",
  47. (1978). Employment and Development of Small Enterprises. Sector Policy Paper. doi
  48. (1972). Employment, Incomes and Equality: A Strategy for Increasing Productive Employment in Kenya. doi
  49. (1982). Entrepreneurship and the New Firm. Croom Helm,
  50. (1982). Entrepreneurship research: Methods and directions",
  51. (1977). Exchange and power in networks of interorganisational relations",
  52. (1964). Exchange andPower in Social Life.
  53. (1961). Exchange as a conceptual framework for the study of interorganisational relations",Administrative Science Quarterly, doi
  54. (1966). Experimentor effects in behavioural research. Appleton-Century-crofts,
  55. (1989). Explaining high perfonnance manufucturing: The international automotive assembly plant study",
  56. (1989). Exploring Corporate Strategy. doi
  57. (1979). External vs internal knowledge acquisition: N activity and R&D intensity",
  58. (1989). Externalisation and the foonation of new industrial operations: A neglected dimension in the dynamics of industrial location."
  59. (1988). Fifth Malaysian Plan 1986-1990. National Printing Department, Kuala Lumpur.
  60. (1985). Flexibility, Uncertainty and Manpower Management,
  61. (1988). Flexible integration, scope economies, and strategic alliances: Social and spatial mediations", Environment and Planning D: doi
  62. (1992). Flexible production, externalisation and the interpretation of business service growth", doi
  63. (1982). Flexible specialisation and the re-emergence of regional economies", doi
  64. (1991). Flexible specialisation versus Post-Fordism: Theory, evidence and policy implications", doi
  65. (1984). Fonnulating Vertical Integration Strategies"
  66. (1973). Foundations of Behavioural Research (2nd ed). doi
  67. (1986). Fragmentation Strategies and the rise of small units: Cases from the North West". doi
  68. (1991). From mass production to flexible specialisation: A case study from a semiindustrialised economy. lDS,
  69. (1984). Government Intervention in the transfer of technology: the case of South Korea", doi
  70. (1991). Government policies for promoting manufacturing innovation",
  71. (1981). Handbook of Successful Franchising. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New Y orle Friedman D
  72. (1982). Hierarchical structure and attitudes towards risk in state-owned enterprises", in LP Jones (ed) Public Enterprises in Less Developed Countries. doi
  73. (1987). Hybrid Organisational arrangements: New form or transitional development?", doi
  74. (1982). In Search of Excellence: Lessons from America's Best Run Companies. Harper and Row, doi
  75. (1981). Industrial Capacity and Employment Promotion: Case Studies of Sri
  76. (1988). Industrial Change in Europe: The pursuit of flexible specialisation in Britain and West Gennany", doi
  77. (1991). Industrial development, technological change and industrial organisation: The Kenyan case", in Coughlin P and Nyong'o P A (eds) Industria/isation at Bay. Academy of Science Publishers,
  78. (1990). Industrial Districts and Inter-firm Cooperation in Ita(V. doi
  79. (1990). Industrial Networks in Japan: Technology Transfer to SMEs." doi
  80. (1989). Industrial restructuring and labour relations in the automotive components industry: "Just-in-time" or "Just-too-late"?
  81. (1991). Industrialisation and the low-level production trap: the handtools and cutlery industry"
  82. (1988). Industrialisation in Kenya: In Search of a Strategy.
  83. (1988). Information, Incentives and Bargaining in the Japanese Economy. doi
  84. (1988). Interest and agency in institutional theory",
  85. (1972). International subcontracting, employment and skill promotion",
  86. (1984). Interorganisational cooperation and decision-making autonomy in a consortium multi hospital system", doi
  87. (1991). Investment strategy and technological policy: Empirical lessons from power alcohol development",
  88. (1987). Job Generation and Labour Market Change. Macmillan, London. Storper M and Scott A J (l990) 'Work, organisation and local labour markets in an era of flexible production",
  89. (1976). Joint ventures and interorganisational interdependence", doi
  90. (1987). Kenya Industrial Sector: Policies/or Investment and Export Growth. World Bank, doi
  91. (1992). KENYA VEHICLE SALES STATISTICS (Locally assembled vehicles only)
  92. (1985). Kenya's experience in technology transfer: A case study of 25 manufacturing finns".
  93. (1991). Kenya's Industrialisation Dilemma.
  94. (1993). Limits of state strength: Toward an institutionalist view of economic development", World Politics. doi
  95. (1988). Longitudinal field research on change: Theory and practice", doi
  96. (1980). Malkets, bureaucracies, and clans", doi
  97. (1992). Management aspects of strategic partnering", doi
  98. (1990). Management in Developing Countries. doi
  99. (1990). Managing in Developing Countries. doi
  100. (1992). Managing Organisations in Africa. Walter de Gruyter, doi
  101. (1984). Marketing Management Analysis, Planning and Control. Engelwood Cl.i..H:
  102. (1975). Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Anti-trust Implications.
  103. (1991). Markets, Hierarchies and Networks: The co-ordination of Social Life.
  104. (1992). Micro-enterprise development in a sub-sector context", doi
  105. (1987). MlCTo-electronics, Automation and Employment in the Automobile Industry. ILO/John Wiley,
  106. (1990). Neither maIket nor hierarchy: Network forms of organisation",
  107. (1992). NetwOIk dyads in en1repreneurial settings: A study of the government of exchange relationships",
  108. (1986). Networks: Between markets and hierarchies", doi
  109. (1986). New Firms and Regional Development in Europe. Croom Helm,
  110. (1984). Of contracts and subcontracts: Small firms in vertically dis-integrated production/distribution systems in LDCs", doi
  111. (1983). OIganisational and institutional responses to international risk. In R J Herring (ed) Managing International Risk.
  112. (1988). On Strategic Networks", doi
  113. (1985). On the licensing of Innovations", doi
  114. (1974). Organisation-Environment: Concepts and issues",
  115. (1971). Organisational boundaries and interorganisational conflict",
  116. (1993). Organisational change in Zimbabwe's manufacturing sector",
  117. (1974). Organisational decision-making as a political process: a case of a university budget",Administrative doi
  118. (1987). Organisational Economics: Notes on the use of transaction cost theory in the study of organisations", doi
  119. (1975). Organisational effectiveness and the institutional environment",
  120. (1972). Organisational structure, environment and performance: The role of strategic choice", doi
  121. (1979). Organisations and Environments. Prentice-Hall, Engelwood Cliffs,
  122. (1967). Organisations in Action. doi
  123. (1958). Organisations.
  124. (1993). Outsourcing and the search for flexibility",
  125. (1972). Participant observation and the development of urban neighbourhood policy.
  126. (1988). Partnerships of large and small firms: Lessons from the Third World".
  127. (1988). Patterns of extemallinkages of innovative small and medium -sized finns in the United Kingdom",
  128. (1988). Politics of strategic decision-making in high velocity environments: Toward a mid-range theory", doi
  129. (1986). Post-industrial manufacturing",
  130. (1962). Power dependence relations", doi
  131. (1992). Prices, Quality and Trust: Inter-firm relations doi
  132. (1987). Productive decentralisation or indigenous growth? Small manufucturing enterprises and regional development on central Portugal", doi
  133. (1990). Project Document: The Kenya subcontracting and partnership exchange" Unpublished Project Document.
  134. (1991). Promoting an efficient transport-vehicle industry",
  135. (1987). Qualitative Analysis for Social Scientists. doi
  136. (1984). Recent Changes and Future Prospects: The West Mullands Industry. West Midlands County Cmmcil,
  137. (1988). Relating Porter's business strategies to environment and structure: Analysis and perfonnance implications". doi
  138. (1977). Resource allocations in United Funds: An examination of power and dependence",Administrative doi
  139. (1976). Resource dependence and inter~rganisation relations",
  140. (1988). Restructuring the capitalist labour process: some lessons from the car industry",
  141. (1982). Reversing Industrial Decline? doi
  142. (1937). Rural and Small Scale Industries and employment in Africa and Asia.
  143. (1971). Second Malaysia Plan 1971-1975. National Printing Department, Kuala Lumpur.
  144. (1989). Sectors and/or districts: some remarks on the conceptual foundations of industrial economics",
  145. (1982). Segmented Work, Divided Workers. doi
  146. (1986). Sessional Paper No. 1: Economic Management for Renewed Growth. Government Printers,
  147. (1992). Sessional Paper No.2 of 1992: Small Enterprise and Jua KaJi Development in Kenya. Government Printers, Nairobi. GOK (Various) Statistical Abstracts. Government Printers.
  148. (1991). Sixth Malaysia Plan 1991-1995. Government Printers, Kuala Lumpur.
  149. (1989). Small business in Japan: A historical perspective", doi
  150. (1982). Small businesses - how many jobs?",
  151. (1977). Small enterprise development: policies and programmes.
  152. (1990). Small finns and flexible specialisation in developing countries",
  153. (1990). Small finns, new finns and uneven regional development in the United Kingdom",Area,
  154. (1986). Small firms and industrial districts: the experience of Italy",
  155. (1982). Small industry in developing countries: a discussion of issues", doi
  156. (1977). Small Scale Industry in
  157. (1982). Small scale industry in Kenya".
  158. (1987). Small scale manufacturing enterprises in developing countries", doi
  159. (1987). Small scale manufacturing in Kenya", in Industrial Sector Policies for Investment in Export Growth, Vol n, The World Bank,
  160. (1986). Small-scale industry in sub-Saharan Africa: Empirical evidence and strategic implications",
  161. (1977). Small-scale Rural Industry in
  162. (1988). Smaller units of employment: a synthesis report on industrial reorganisation in industrialised countries",
  163. (1989). SMFs, inter-finn relationships and technological change", Entrepreneurship and Regional Development, No.l, doi
  164. (1970). Sociological Methods: A source book.. AIdine,
  165. (1982). Stability in interorganisational exchanges: Rulemaking processes of Chicago Board of Trade", doi
  166. (1987). State-Owned Enterprises in High Technology Industries.
  167. (1990). Strategic alliances and the small technology-based finn",
  168. (1992). Strategic alliances between small and large firms",
  169. (1980). Strategic capability: a concept and framework for analysis. doi
  170. (1985). Strategies for Intrafinn Transfers and Outside Sourcing"
  171. (1962). Strategy and Structure.
  172. (1974). Strategy, Strudure, and Economic Performance.
  173. (1986). Strategy: Framing business intentions",
  174. (1975). Street-level governments: Assessing decentralisation and urban services. doi
  175. (1974). Sub-contracting for Modernising Economies.
  176. (1989). Sub-Saharan Africa: From Crisis to Sustainable Growth. The World Bank, doi
  177. (1992). Sub-sector analysis - a macro-analytical tool for micro~nteIprise support",
  178. (1971). Subcontracting, industrialisation and employment creation",
  179. (1989). Survey of micro- and small enterprises".
  180. (1978). Technological complimentaries and industrial patterns of joint venture activity, 1964-1975",
  181. (1987). Technological Innovation, Structural Change and Location in UK Services. Gower, Aldershot. 290 lDS, doi
  182. (1988). Technological trajectories and regional innovation in Europe", in AydaIot P and Keeble D (eds) High Technology Industry and Innovative Environments: The European Experience.
  183. (1983). Technology, Marketing and Industrialisation, Linkages between Large and Small Enterprises,
  184. (1985). The Awakening Giant Basil Blackwell,
  185. (1981). The case study as a serious research strategy. doi
  186. (1990). The Competitive Advantage of Nations. doi
  187. (1991). The Competitiveness of Small Fu-ms. Department of Applied Economics,
  188. (1987). The Concept of Corporate Strategy (3ed). doi
  189. (1971). The Concept of Corporate Strategy. lrwin,
  190. (1946). The Concept of the Corporation. doi
  191. (1981). The contributions of marketing to strategic management", doi
  192. (1990). The core competence of the corporation", Harvard Business Review (May-June).
  193. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. : AIdine,
  194. (1986). The economic importance of small and medium-sized finns in the Federal Republic of Gennany",
  195. (1985). The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. doi
  196. (1981). The Economics of Small Firms. doi
  197. (1979). The Evolution of Giant Firms in Britain. doi
  198. (1978). The External Control of Organisation: A Resource Dependence Perspective. Harper & Row, doi
  199. (1983). The federation as an interorganisational linkage netwOlk",
  200. (1985). The genesis of the Silicon Valley",
  201. (1990). The growth of companies 1985-87 and their contribution to job generation", Employment Gazette, February,
  202. (1979). The instnnnental values of organisational relations: Antecedents and consequences of linkage foonation",
  203. (1989). The International Automotive Components Industry: The 'Next Best Practice'for Suppliers.
  204. (1990). The internationalisation of R&D and the development of global research networks",
  205. (1983). The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organisational fields", doi
  206. (1987). The Japanese finn in transition",
  207. (1992). The Japanisation of British Industry. doi
  208. (1979). The job generation process",
  209. (1988). The logic of joint research and development", California Management Review, Spring, doi
  210. (1985). The manufacture and importation of handtools and cutlery in Kenya"
  211. (1984). The Motor Vehicle Industry in Asia.
  212. (1978). The multinational corporation in the political economy of Kenya", doi
  213. (1986). The nature of small firms in Ireland: empirical evidence and policy implications",
  214. (1990). The New Competition: Institutions of Industrial Restructuring. doi
  215. (1980). The New International Division of Labour. doi
  216. (1983). The New Service Economy. doi
  217. (1989). The Other Path: The invisible Revolution in the Third World. Harper and Row, NewYorlc Decoster E and Tabaries M doi
  218. (1982). The other side of the rising sun", Sunday TImes (UK),
  219. (1991). The Pharmaceutical Industry: Excess Capacity, Missed Opportunities and Planning Failures",
  220. (1984). The plastics processing industry in Kenya Unpublished Ma Thesis,
  221. (1988). The possibilities and historical limitations of import substitution industrialisation in Kenya",
  222. (1954). The Practice of Management Harper and Brothers, New Yorlc Drucker P
  223. (1986). The present and the Future Role of Services
  224. (1993). The recent tnmsfonnation of the Mexican automobile industry",
  225. (1978). The research act: A theoretical introduction to sociological methods. doi
  226. (1966). The Rise of Capitalism.
  227. (1988). The role of Govemment institutions in Kenya's industrialisation",
  228. (1988). The role of government overcoming market failure: Taiwan, Republic of Korea and Japan", in Hughes H (ed) Achieving Industrialisation in East Asia. doi
  229. (1988). The role of small and medium-sized enterprises in European job creation: key issues for policy and research",
  230. (1984). The Second Industrial Divide: Possibilities for Prosperity. Basic Books, doi
  231. (1987). The size distribution, growth potential and job-generation contribution ofUK finns",lnternational
  232. (1993). The South African Paper and Pulp Industry.
  233. (1990). The state and effective control of foreign capital: the case of South Korea", doi
  234. (1991). The state and foreign business interests",
  235. (1979). The Structure of the Japanese Motor Industry. Dodwell Marketing Consultants,
  236. (1990). The subcontracting behaviour of single vs multiplant enterprises in us manufacturing: implications for economic development." World Development, doi
  237. (1967). The Tacit Dimension. doi
  238. (1989). The third Italy: Inter-firm Co-operation and technological innovation", in
  239. (1980). The traditional sector in France and Italy"
  240. (1984). The utilisation of research: Lessons from a muJtj-disciplined field. COSMOS Corporation,
  241. (1983). The vehicle assembly industry in Kenya: an economic evaluation".
  242. (1971). The vertical integration of production: Market failure considerations",
  243. (1969). TheSociaJPsychology of Organising.
  244. (1986). Thinking ahead",
  245. (1985). Three models of strategy", doi
  246. (1987). Thriving on Chaos. doi
  247. (1984). Toward the infonnational city? High technology, economic change and spatial structure", Institute of Urban and Regional Development,
  248. (1984). Towards a a strategic theory of the finn",
  249. (1988). Towards anew industrialisation strategy" in CoughlinP and G Ikiara (op cit.). Coughlin P
  250. (1983). Transaction costs, property rights, and organisational culture: An exchange perspective", doi
  251. (1975). Underdevelopment in Kenya: The Political Economy of Neo-colonialism. doi
  252. (1993). Various Internal News Bulletins Koch A and Lobovitz S
  253. (1983). Vertical Integration and Joint Ventures in the Aluminium Industry.
  254. (1980). Vertical inter-finn linkages in LDCs: An empirical study", doi
  255. (1982). What to study: Generating and developing research questions. doi
  256. (1993). When and when not to vertically integrate",
  257. (1989). When Giants Learn to Dance. George AlIen &
  258. (1988). Why should Finns Cooperate? The Strategy and Economics Basis for Co-<>perative Ventures&quot;
  259. (1991). Wilkins A L doi
  260. (1993). Winners and losers - the 'tiering' of component suppliers in the UK automotive industry&quot;,
  261. (1982). Work and Politics - the Division of Labour in Industry. doi
  262. (1986). Work decentralisation from large to small £inns: Preliminary analysis of subcontracting&quot;, doi
  263. (1990). World Development Report. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.