Article thumbnail

Narrative and descriptive text revising strategies and procedures

By A Piolat and JY Roussey

Abstract

Forty-eight children and forty-eight adults of contrasting degrees of expertise made a series of corrections in order to improve a text (narrative or description) in which three within-statement errors and three between-statement errors had been inserted. Subjects used a simplified word processor (SCRIPREV) which recorded all movements of linguistic units. The purpose of this research was to study revising strategies by examining the correction-sequencing procedures implemented by these subjects. The procedures, which were coded in the form of time series, were compared to the time series of model revising procedures (i.e. effective ones) representing three strategies based on certain predefined functional principles (linguistic level, execution order). The adults used two of these strategies. The Simultaneous Strategy for the narrative, and the Local-then-Global Strategy for the description. The children used the Local-then-Global Strategy for the narrative, but did not use any identifiable procedure to revise the description, which they did not manage to totally improve in the expected manner

Topics: Psycholinguistics
Year: 1991
DOI identifier: 10.1007/bf03191934
OAI identifier: oai:cogprints.org:3622

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1981). A Cognitive Process Theory of Writing.
  2. (1981). Analyzing revision.
  3. (1987). Cognitive processes in revision.
  4. (1986). Detection, diagnosis, and the strategies of revision.
  5. (1985). Fostering the development of self-regulation in children's knowledge Processing. In
  6. (1987). Le retour de l'auteur sur son texte: Bilan provisoire des recherches psycholinguistiques.
  7. (1982). Learning to revise: Some component processes. In
  8. (1980). Notes and comments. Children's rewriting strategies.
  9. (1989). Play as thought: Thinking strategies of young writers.
  10. (1986). Proposition de logiciel pour le traitement des chroniques. Congrès Annuel de la S.F.P. (section de Psychologie Expérimentale), Aix-En-Provence,
  11. (1990). Revising strategies for different text types. doi
  12. (1987). Révision de texte par l'enfant et l'adulte en production assistée par ordinateur.
  13. (1985). Revision, addition, and the power of the unseen text. In
  14. (1989). Text revising strategies. doi
  15. (1983). The word processor and revision strategies.
  16. (1990). Time series: A tool for analyzing complex cognitive activities. Application to the study of text revising strategies.
  17. (1987). Using word processing to enhance strategies during student writing activities.