Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository




Abstract\ud \ud In Thailand, s. 231 Criminal Procedure Code provides the court the broad discretion to direct the physician to disclose medical confidentiality in judicial proceedings. No criteria or guidelines have been formulated by the law to limit the judge’s discretion. This can lead to a problem in the standardisation of judgements, as different judges hold different views concerning the protection of medical confidentiality. Therefore, this thesis argues that some criteria should be set up to support the judge in exercising the discretion about the disclosure of medical confidentiality in judicial proceedings. The argument has been supported by the results of empirical study which aims to explore the stakeholders’ about the mentioned issue. The thesis findings are; (1) more education about the law concerning medical confidentiality should be provided to the public, (2) the court should interpret the law to give effect the Constitutional right to privacy, (3) S.231 Criminal Code should be revised to include the clause: “The court should direct the person to disclose confidential information only in the circumstance that the information is relevant and material to the case, and also balance the interest between maintaining confidentiality and the interest of justice”. More relevant factors lie in English laws such as necessity, proportionate and safeguards against abuse should also be considered. (4) more study is needed about the possibility of appointing an expert to a panel of judges. \u

Topics: Confidentiality, court proceedings.
Year: 2010
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Durham e-Theses

Suggested articles


  1. (2004). An Overview of Directive 95/46/EC in Relation to Medical Research.”
  2. (1999). Case Commentary of the Entrance Examination Case”, Matichon Weekly Review, ( Vol.30,
  3. (1997). Chaisarn, Vatchara, Right to Access to Government Information Under
  4. (2001). Challenges of Thailand’s Freedom of Information”,
  5. (1993). Civil Liberties & Human Rights in England & Wales,
  6. (1992). Civil Right and Duty,
  7. (1970). Confidentiality and Medical Profession”,
  8. (2004). Confidentiality and Medical Records.”
  9. (1999). Confidentiality and the Courts”,
  10. (1979). Confidentiality”,
  11. (1980). Criminal Code and Moral”,
  12. (1996). Criminal Code Part I,
  13. (1996). Criminal Procedure Code, (Thammasat University : 6 th ed.,
  14. (1997). Defence Right of Government Agencies against the Decision of Official Information Board Under the
  15. (1983). Description of the 1982 Medical Profession Act, (Medical Council :
  16. (2000). Disclosure of personal information under the Official Information Act B.E.2540,
  17. (1987). Doctor and Confidentiality”, The Clinic,
  18. (2000). Elise “Betrayal of Confidence in The Court of Appeal”, doi
  19. (1999). Elise “Case Commentary Anonymisation Is Not Exoneration”, doi
  20. (1985). Ethics and the legal problem of the surgeons”,
  21. (2000). Fundamental rights and human dignity under the Constitution,
  22. (2005). Giving the Reasonable Patient A voice: Information Disclosure and The Relevance of Empirical Evidence”, doi
  23. (2002). Horizontal Applicability and Direct Effect”,
  24. (1997). Human Right : The Development of Thai Legal System,
  25. (1995). Human Rights and Human Dignity”,
  26. (1998). Intellectual Property And International Trade Court : A New Dimension For Intellectual Property Rights Enforcement In Thailand, (Judicial Material :
  27. (1998). Intellectual Property and International Trade Court,
  28. (1997). Intellectual Property and International Trade Court”,
  29. (1978). Lawyer’s Attitudes About Medical Sciences”,
  30. (2000). Legal Aspect of Official Information Board and In Formation Disclosure Tribunal”,
  31. (2003). Medical Confidentiality and Crime,(Aldershot : Ashgate,
  32. (1993). Medical Confidentiality and Legal Privilege, doi
  33. (1995). Medical Ethics and Social Moral”,
  34. (2003). Medical Law :
  35. (2000). Medical Law: Text with Material, doi
  36. (1993). Medical Professional Liability Under Wronful Act,
  37. (2004). Medical Records : doi
  38. (2000). Office of the Council of State, Consultation Document Concerning Legal Issues in the Entrance Examination Case.
  39. (1999). Office of the Prime-Minister, Office of the Official Information Board, Yearly Report of Official Information Broad
  40. (1999). Official Information Broad’s Decision Under the 1997 Official Information Act,
  41. (1991). Patient’s rights,
  42. (1984). Patient’s Rights”,
  43. (1997). Patients’ legal rights : perspectives from health care members and patients of university hospitals in
  44. (1986). Problems of Interpretation of Article 8 of the European Convention on doi
  45. (2000). Reference Book for Criminal Code, (Vinyuchon : 9 th ed.,
  46. (1981). Right and Liberties of Thai People Under the Constitution”,
  47. (1998). Right to access information under Official Information Act,
  48. (1997). Right to Privacy and Media Responsibility,
  49. (1992). Right to Privacy and the Media”, Thai Judiciary Journal,
  50. (1995). Rights and liberties under the Constitution, (Vinyouchon Press : 1 st ed.,
  51. (1984). Social Order and Wrongful Act under Civil Code”,
  52. (1998). Southeast Asian Media : Building Freedom in the Midst of Crisis”, Paper presented at Press freedom Seminar Bangkok,
  53. (1997). Supanee and Varaporn Veerasuntorn, Patients’ legal rights : perspectives from health care members and patients of university hospitals in Bangkok, (National Research Council,
  54. (2006). Thailand : a case study in the interrelationship between freedom of information and privacy”, paper given at an International
  55. (1997). The
  56. (1941). The Argument on Press Control Act
  57. (1982). The breach of privacy right,
  58. The description of Civil and Commercial Code Title V: Wrongful Acts,
  59. (1997). The Description of Criminal Code Part II and III,
  60. (1997). The Description of the
  61. (1997). The disclosure of patient’s information,
  62. (1997). The interpretation and Enforcement of Thai Constitution”
  63. (2007). The Media Law;
  64. (1997). The Past and Future of Medical Ethics”, Paper Presented at the 6 th,National Conference of Physicians, (King Mongkut Hopital,
  65. (2000). The Problem related to Public Access to Personal Information Under the 1997 Official Information Act.
  66. (1995). The Protection of Privacy under Criminal Law,
  67. (2004). When Is Personal Data Rendered Anonymous?” Interpreting Recital 26 of Directive 95/46//EC., doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.