Article thumbnail

“Just one animal among many?” Existential phenomenology, ethics, and stem cell research

By Norman K. Swazo

Abstract

Stem cell research and associated or derivative biotechnologies are proceeding at a pace that has left bioethics behind as a discipline that is more or less reactionary to their developments. Further, much of the available ethical deliberation remains determined by the conceptual framework of late modern metaphysics and the correlative ethical theories of utilitarianism and deontology. Lacking, to any meaningful extent, is a sustained engagement with ontological and epistemological critiques, such as with “postmodern” thinking like that of Heidegger’s existential phenomenology. Some basic “Heideggerian” conceptual strategies are reviewed here as a way of remedying this deficiency and adding to ethical deliberation about current stem cell research practices

Topics: Article
Publisher: Springer Netherlands
OAI identifier: oai:pubmedcentral.nih.gov:2883080
Provided by: PubMed Central

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2007). A Heideggerian defense of therapeutic cloning.
  2. (2007). A Heideggerian reflection on the prospects of technology.
  3. (2006). A natural stem cell therapy? How novel findings and biotechnology clarify the ethics of stem cell research.
  4. (2007). After Dolly: The uses and misuses of human cloning.
  5. (2001). Authentic values and individual autonomy.
  6. (1994). Authenticity as a foundational principle of medical ethics.
  7. (1962). Being and time.
  8. (2005). Being queasy about reconstructing animals.
  9. (2005). Beyond the body of bioethics: Challenging conventions.
  10. (2009). Calculative thinking and essential thinking in Heidegger’s phenomenology.
  11. (2004). Can the sciences help us to make wise ethical judgments?
  12. (2006). Continental contributions to philosophy of science.
  13. (2006). Delivering on the promise of human stem cell research: What are the real barriers?
  14. (2009). Embryonic, fetal and postnatal animal-human mixtures: An ethical discussion. http://www.schb.org.uk/publications/report%20-%20animal-human%20mix tures.htm.
  15. (2009). Ethical and policy issues at the cutting edge of stem cell science: A summer intensive course. Human/animal chimeras and hybrids—history and scientific utility.
  16. (1985). Existential and ontological dimensions of time in Heidegger and Dogen.
  17. (2000). Experts on philosophical reflection in public discourse—the German Sloterdijk debate as an example.
  18. (2009). First transgenic primate group glows and grows.
  19. (2009). For the love of the game: Peter Sloterdijk and public controversies in bioethics.
  20. (2006). Fraudulent human embryonic stem cell research in South Korea: Lessons learned.
  21. (2008). Fundamentals of the stem cell debate.
  22. (2000). Gene ontology: Tool for the unification of biology.
  23. (2002). Genomic metaphysics.
  24. (2009). Glowing monkeys ‘to aid research’. BBC News. http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/ 2/hi/science/nature/8070252.stm.
  25. (2006). Harvard stem cell researchers granted approval: will attempt creation of diseasespecific embryonic stem cell lines. Harvard Gazette.
  26. (2005). Heidegger and the place of ethics.
  27. (2005). Heidegger on science and naturalism.
  28. (2003). Heidegger, medicine and ‘scientific method’: The unheeded heritage of the Zollikon Seminars. New Gnosis Publications.
  29. (2009). Hiroshi Suemizu, Akiko Shimada, Kisaburo Hanazawa, Ryo Oiwa, Michiko Kamioka, Ikuo Tomioka, et al.
  30. (2009). How Heidegger defends the possibility of a correspondence theory or truth with respect to the entities of natural science.
  31. (2008). Human embryonic stem cell research, justice, and the problem of unequal biological access. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine. doi:10.1186/1747-5341-3-22. Just one animal among many?
  32. (2009). Human sperm created from embryonic stem cells.
  33. (2007). Hwang case review committee misses the mark.
  34. (2007). International perspectives on the ethics and regulation of human cell and tissue transplantation.
  35. (2006). Is a consensus possible on stem cell research? Moral and political obstacles.
  36. (2009). Kevin Eggan Lab home page.
  37. (2009). Letter on humanism (trans: Miles Groth). http://www.wagner.edu/depart ments/psychology/grothpubs.
  38. (2007). Making manimals.
  39. (2005). Modern science and technology. A review of the proceedings of the 35th annual meeting of The North American Heidegger Society,
  40. (1993). Modern science, metaphysics, and mathematics.
  41. (2007). On Heidegger, medicine, and the modernity of modern medical technology.
  42. (2004). On the origin, use, and destination of human embryos.
  43. (1972). On time and being (trans:
  44. (2005). Panel finds against South Korean scientists. Global Technology Forum. December 28. http://globaltechforum.eiu.com/index.asp?layout?rich_story&doc_ id?7936&title=Panel?finds?against?South?Korean?scientist&categoryid=7&channelid=3.
  45. (2009). Paper announcing creation of sperm retracted for plagiarism.
  46. (2009). Phenomenology and genetic engineering. http://www.heidegger.org.uk/dean_ lauer.pdf.
  47. (2008). Pluripotency and nuclear reprogramming.
  48. (2006). Primer on ethics and crossing species boundaries.
  49. (2003). Renovating the house of being: Genomes, souls, and selves.
  50. (2009). Scientists create human sperm from stem cells.
  51. (2007). Scottish ethics body extremely concerned about HFEA decision to support animal-human hybrids. http://www.schb.org.uk/publications/press%2046%20-%20animal-human%20combinations%20-%202.htm.
  52. (2001). Segregation of human neural stem cells in the developing primate forebrain.
  53. (2009). Sperm from stem cells sparks media furor.
  54. (1998). Spha ¨ren, 3 vols.
  55. (2002). Stem cell research: ‘With no law, the situation is very permissive’.
  56. (2008). Stem cell summit hails bench progress, looks to bedside future.
  57. (2008). Stem cells. In From birth to death and bench to clinic: Bioethics briefing book for journalists, policymakers,
  58. (1999). The appearance of Kant’s deontology in contemporary Kantianism: Concepts of patient autonomy in bioethics.
  59. (2002). The destiny of technology: Modern science and human freedom in the later Heidegger.
  60. (2004). The dilemmas of German bioethics.
  61. (2007). The ethics of uncertainty: In the light of possible dangers, research becomes a moral duty.
  62. (2004). The evolution of molecular biology into systems biology.
  63. (2009). The metaphysics of appearance: Heidegger’s critique of technology.
  64. (1994). The moral significance of our biological nature: Methodological consequences of hermeneutical ethics.
  65. (2007). The OBO Foundry: Coordinated evolution of ontologies to support biomedical data integration.
  66. (2009). The operable man: On the ethical state of gene technology.
  67. (2009). The power of imagination.
  68. (2009). The problem of science in Heidegger’s thought.
  69. (2007). The problem of science’ in Nietzsche and Heidegger. Revista Portuguesa de Filosofia 63: 205–237. http://fordham.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1006&context=phil_ research.
  70. (1982). The question concerning technology.
  71. (2007). The role of transgenic animals in biomedical research. April 24. http:// www.gsk.com/research/about/about_animals_roles.html.
  72. (2006). Therapeutic perspectives of human embryonic stem cell research versus the moral status of a human embryo—does one have to be compromised for the other? Medicine [Kaunas]
  73. (2001). Transgenic monkeys produced by retroviral gene transfer into mature oocytes.
  74. (1967). What is a thing?. Chicago: Henry Regnery
  75. (2002). What to call human cloning: The technical terminology increasingly used in the cloning debate sidesteps the ethical questions raised.
  76. (2001). Zollikon seminars.