Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

An investigation of the young adult beginner learning piano in comparison with the child beginner.

By Myung Shin. Kim


The present study is an attempt to understand the differences between the\ud child and young adult beginner in learning how to play the piano as a basis\ud towards improving college-level beginning piano teaching. The purpose of this\ud study then is three fold: (1) to examine to what extent there is a difference of\ud learning achievement and rate between the child and young adult beginner,\ud centering on psychomotor skills, the process of music reading, and elements of\ud interpretation in learning how to play the piano; (2) to find out factors affecting\ud these three elements of musical learning in two groups; and (3) to drive ways\ud towards improving college level beginning piano teaching.\ud To examine these questions, comparisons were drawn between\ud undergraduate non-music majors (19 - 24 years) and primary school children (8\ud years). The 10-week instructional period consisted of two 40-minute lessons per\ud week for each individual. The investigator taught all subjects individually with the\ud investigator-designed instructional programme focused on keyboard fluency,\ud music reading, and interpretation. Through the pilot study materials and\ud sequencing in the instructional programme were revised and a system of\ud categories for learning-relevant variables emerged. Hypotheses related to a basis\ud of differences in music learning between two groups were investigated using a\ud three-point achievement measurement tool designed by the investigator. Other\ud variables (physical capacity, intelligence, musical background, motivation to\ud learn, learning attitude, emotional factors) affecting musical learning were\ud investigated using IQ tests, the students' self-reports, investigator's reports, and\ud parents' reports.\ud The results of the principal investigation indicate that the young adult\ud beginners performed in all three musical learning elements better than the child\ud group. No evidence was found in support of stereotypical assumptions in the\ud beginning piano study-related literature that the young adult beginner is at\ud disadvantage to the child beginner in the acquisition of keyboard fluency skills. It\ud appears that the young adult did not have problems related to physical capacity\ud taught in this instruction. In addition, it appears that selection variables (physical\ud capacity, intelligence, and musical background) played an important role in the\ud musical achievement of the child beginner group compared with the young adult\ud group. On the other hand, in the case of the young adult group, it appears that\ud learning-related characteristics (motivation to learn, learning attitude, and\ud emotional factors) were likely to be more important factors affecting the musical\ud development compared with the child group

Year: 1996
OAI identifier:
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • (external link)
  • (external link)
  • Suggested articles

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.