Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Ethical psychiatry in an uncertain world: conversations and parallel truths

By Alexander M Carson and Peter Lepping


Psychiatric practice is often faced with complex situations that seem to pose serious moral dilemmas for practitioners. Methods for solving these dilemmas have included the development of more objective rules to guide the practitioner such as utilitarianism and deontology. A more modern variant on this objective model has been 'Principlism' where 4 mid level rules are used to help solve these complex problems. In opposition to this, there has recently been a focus on more subjective criteria for resolving complex moral dilemmas. In particular, virtue ethics has been posited as a more sensitive method for helping doctors to reason their way through difficult ethical issues. Here the focus is on the character traits of the practitioner. Bloch and Green advocated another way whereby more objective methods such as Principlism and virtue ethics are combined to produce what they considered sound moral reasoning in psychiatrists. This paper points out some difficulties with this approach and instead suggests that a better model of ethical judgment could be developed through the use of narratives or stories. This idea puts equal prima facie value on the patient's and the psychiatrist's version of the dilemma they are faced with. It has the potential to lead to a more genuine empathy and reflective decision-making

Topics: Review
Publisher: BioMed Central
OAI identifier:
Provided by: PubMed Central

Suggested articles


  1. (2003). An ethical review of consent in medicine. Psychiatric Bulletin
  2. (1985). An introduction to medical phenomenology: I can't hear you while I'm listening. Ann Intern Med.
  3. (1995). Kottow KH: In defence of medical ethics.
  4. (2004). Mental Health Nursing: Principles in practice.
  5. Philosophical Investigations Oxford:
  6. (2006). SA: An ethical framework for psychiatry.
  7. (1992). Sources of the Self: The making of the Modern Identity Cambridge:
  8. (2001). That's another story: Narrative methods and ethical practice. J Med Ethics.
  9. (1930). The Right and the Good

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.