Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Standards of evidence in chronobiology: critical review of a report that restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial hypothalamus is sufficient to restore circadian food anticipatory rhythms in Bmal1-/- mice

By Ralph E Mistlberger, Ruud M Buijs, Etienne Challet, Carolina Escobar, Glenn J Landry, Andries Kalsbeek, Paul Pevet and Shigenobu Shibata

Abstract

Daily feeding schedules generate food anticipatory rhythms of behavior and physiology that exhibit canonical properties of circadian clock control. The molecular mechanisms and location of food-entrainable circadian oscillators hypothesized to control food anticipatory rhythms are unknown. In 2008, Fuller et al reported that food-entrainable circadian rhythms are absent in mice bearing a null mutation of the circadian clock gene Bmal1 and that these rhythms can be rescued by virally-mediated restoration of Bmal1 expression in the dorsomedial nucleus of the hypothalamus (DMH) but not in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (site of the master light-entrainable circadian pacemaker). These results, taken together with controversial DMH lesion results published by the same laboratory, appear to establish the DMH as the site of a Bmal1-dependent circadian mechanism necessary and sufficient for food anticipatory rhythms. However, careful examination of the manuscript reveals numerous weaknesses in the evidence as presented. These problems are grouped as follows and elaborated in detail: 1. data management issues (apparent misalignments of plotted data), 2. failure of evidence to support the major conclusions, and 3. missing data and methodological details. The Fuller et al results are therefore considered inconclusive, and fail to clarify the role of either the DMH or Bmal1 in the expression of food-entrainable circadian rhythms in rodents

Topics: Review
Publisher: BioMed Central
OAI identifier: oai:pubmedcentral.nih.gov:2670815
Provided by: PubMed Central

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1997). Anticipation and entrainment to feeding time in intact and SCN-ablated C57BL/6j mice. Brain Res
  2. (2004). Bult-Ito A: Entrainment of the master circadian clock by scheduled feeding.
  3. (2000). CA: Mop3 is an essential component of the master circadian pacemaker in mammals. Cell
  4. (2005). CA: Progressive arthropathy in mice with a targeted disruption of the Mop3/Bmal-1 locus. Genesis
  5. (2008). Challet E: Forebrain oscillators ticking with different clock hands. Mol Cell Neurosci
  6. (2006). Challet E: Lack of food anticipation in Per2 mutant mice. Curr Biol
  7. (1994). Circadian food-anticipatory activity: formal models and physiological mechanisms. Neurosci Biobehav Rev
  8. (2009). CJ: Daily rhythms of food anticipatory activity do not require the known circadian clock.
  9. (2008). CJ: Physiological significance of a peripheral tissue circadian clock.
  10. (2008). Expectancy for food or expectancy for chocolate reveals timing systems for metabolism and reward. Neuroscience
  11. (1980). Feeding schedules and the circadian organization of behavior in the rat. Behav Brain Res
  12. (1980). Food availability and daily biological rhythms. Neurosci Biobehav Rev
  13. (2004). GA: BMAL1 and CLOCK, two essential components of the circadian clock, are involved in glucose homeostasis. PLoS Biol
  14. (2009). GJ: Phenotyping food entrainment: motion sensors and telemetry are equivalent.
  15. (2008). H: An ensemble of novel circadian oscillators in the mouse mediobasal hypothalamus. Comp Biochem Physiol A Comp Physiol
  16. (2008). Kiyatkin EA: Fluctuations in central and peripheral temperatures associated with feeding behavior in rats.
  17. (2007). Mistlberger RE: Food entrainment: methodological issues.
  18. (2006). Mistlberger RE: Persistence of a behavioral food-anticipatory circadian rhythm following dorsomedial hypothalamic ablation in rats.
  19. (2007). Piggins HD: Challenging the omnipotence of the suprachiasmatic timekeeper: are circadian oscillators present throughout the mammalian brain?
  20. (2007). Restricted feeding schedules phase shift daily rhythms of c-Fos and protein Per1 immunoreactivity in corticolimbic regions in rats. Neuroscience
  21. (2001). Restricted-feeding-induced anticipatory activity rhythm is associated with a phase-shift of the expression of mPer1 and mPer2 mRNA in the cerebral cortex and hippocampus but not in the suprachiasmatic nucleus of mice.
  22. (2009). Robust food anticipatory activity in BMAL1-deficient mice. PLoS One
  23. (2007). S: Differential regulation of the expression of Period2 protein in the limbic forebrain and dorsomedial hypothalamus by daily limited access to highly palatable food in food-deprived and free-fed rats. Neuroscience
  24. (2009). S: The dorsomedial hypothalamic nucleus is not necessary for food-anticipatory circadian rhythms of behavior, temperature or clock gene expression in mice.
  25. (2003). SA: Peripheral circadian oscillators in mammals: time and food.
  26. (2008). Saper CB: Differential rescue of light- and foodentrainable circadian rhythms. Science
  27. (2008). Saper CB: Response to comment on "Differential rescue of light- and food-entrainable circadian rhythms. Science
  28. (2006). Saper CB: The dorsomedial hypothalamic nucleus is critical for the expression of food-entrainable circadian rhythms. Nat Neurosci
  29. (2006). Search for the feeding-entrainable circadian oscillator: a complex proposition.
  30. (1979). Sisk CL: Entrainment of circadian rhythms by feeding schedules in rats with suprachiasmatic lesions. Behav Neural Biol
  31. (2002). Suprachiasmatic nucleus. Curr Biol
  32. (1989). T: Feeding cycles entrain circadian rhythms of locomotor activity
  33. (2002). The "other" circadian system: food as a Zeitgeber.
  34. (2006). The dorsomedial hypothalamic nucleus as a putative foodentrainable circadian pacemaker. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
  35. (2007). The dorsomedial hypothalamic nucleus is not necessary for the expression of circadian food-anticipatory activity in rats.
  36. (1998). The suprachiasmatic nucleus: a 25-year retrospective.
  37. (2008). Timed restricted feeding restores the rhythms of expression of the clock protein, Period2, in the oval nucleus of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis and central nucleus of the amygdala in adrenalectomized rats. Neuroscience
  38. (2008). W: Comment on "Differential rescue of light- and food-entrainable circadian rhythms". Science

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.