Location of Repository

Estimation of conditional and marginal odds ratios using the prognostic score

By David Hajage, Yann De Rycke, Guillaume Chauvet and Florence Tubach


International audienceIntroduced by Hansen in 2008, the prognostic score (PGS) has been presented as ‘the prognostic analogue of the propensity score’ (PPS). PPS-based methods are intended to estimate marginal effects. Most previous studies evaluated the performance of existing PGS-based methods (adjustment, stratification and matching using the PGS) in situations in which the theoretical conditional and marginal effects are equal (i.e., collapsible situations). To support the use of PGS framework as an alternative to the PPS framework, applied researchers must have reliable information about the type of treatment effect estimated by each method. We propose four new PGS-based methods, each developed to estimate a specific type of treatment effect. We evaluated the ability of existing and new PGS-based methods to estimate the conditional treatment effect (CTE), the (marginal) average treatment effect on the whole population (ATE), and the (marginal) average treatment effect on the treated population (ATT), when the odds ratio (a non-collapsible estimator) is the measure of interest. The performance of PGS-based methods was assessed by Monte Carlo simulations and compared with PPS-based methods and multivariate regression analysis. Existing PGS-based methods did not allow for estimating the ATE and showed unacceptable performance when the proportion of exposed subjects was large. When estimating marginal effects, PPS-based methods were too conservative, whereas the new PGS-based methods performed better with low prevalence of exposure, and had coverages closer to the nominal value. When estimating CTE, the new PGS-based methods performed as well as traditional multivariate regression

Topics: [ INFO.INFO-LO ] Computer Science [cs]/Logic in Computer Science [cs.LO], [ MATH.MATH-ST ] Mathematics [math]/Statistics [math.ST]
Publisher: Wiley-Blackwell
Year: 2017
DOI identifier: 10.1002/sim.7170
OAI identifier: oai:HAL:hal-01486782v1
Provided by: Hal-Diderot
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • https://hal.archives-ouvertes.... (external link)
  • https://hal.archives-ouvertes.... (external link)
  • https://hal.archives-ouvertes.... (external link)
  • Suggested articles

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.