Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

A commerce of the old and new: how classroom teacher mentors work in multiple activities

By Gill Boag-Munroe


A study of the literature relating to Initial Teacher Education (ITE) suggested that, while mentors had been studied as instruments of their partnership Higher Education Institutions (HEIs), there was little work which investigated the mentor as acting subject in ITE. Through an analysis of spoken and written data, this empirical study offers insights into how two teachers in a secondary school in England appeared to develop subjectivities to assist them in their work in ITE, in the context of the HEI partnership and government policy for ITE. A post-Vygotskyan Activity Theory (Engeström, 1987) and Critical Discourse Analysis (Fairclough, 1995) were used to explore the rules and conceptual and language tools that those teachers seemed to be drawing on when they worked as mentors. The study concludes that, even though the school or partnership appeared to offer few spaces for the development of robust identities, where a mentor had a pre-existing strong pedagogic orientation to mentoring, s/he was better able to construct a subject identity to help her work with students. Where a mentor lacked such a pedagogic orientation and drew on more managerial approaches, s/he experienced more tension in mentoring work and struggled to find an identity which might resolve those tensions

Topics: LB Theory and practice of education, L Education (General)
Year: 2007
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1987). Definitions of mentoring .
  2. (1995). Education and power. 2 nd edn.
  3. (1994). Mar ket Forces and Parental Choice: Self-Interest and Competitive Advantage
  4. (2001). Markets, Standards, Teaching and Teacher Education’ doi
  5. (1997). One Developmental Line in European Activi ty Theories’.
  6. (1976). Rethinking case study: notes from the second Cambridge conference’, doi
  7. (2002). Subject-Object-Knowledge: The Quiet Br illiance of Vladislav Lektorsky. Paper given at
  8. (1994). The Language of Partnership ’.
  9. (1992). Theory in Practice:
  10. (1995). Towards a Conceptualisation of Mentoring," in:

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.