Location of Repository

Premature thoughts on writing disorders

By I. Barrière and Marjorie Lorch

Abstract

Three papers appeared in the 19th century describing the dissociation between speech and writing: Marce (1856), Ogle (1867) and Pitres (1884). An account of the convincing evidence of dissociations put forward in these papers is presented. Three explanations are proposed as to the reason why the observations reported by these authors were overlooked or rejected by their contemporaries, namely: (a) in the first half of the century it seems that very little knowledge of the processes underlying writing (as opposed to speech) was available, (b) the debates focussed on the independence of speech versus motor control and language versus the intellect, (c) parallelisms between phylogeny, ontogeny and aphasia impeded the application of the principle of double dissociations, including the dissociations between speech and writing. It is argued that this phenomenon in the history of aphasia is best captured by the concept of prematurity in scientific discovery proposed by Stent (1972, 2003)

Topics: alc
Publisher: Taylor and Francis
Year: 2004
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.bbk.ac.uk.oai2:333

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (2002). (a) Evolution, language modalities and localization: 19 th century perspectives. Poster presented at TENNET XIII,
  2. (2002). (a) Evolution, language modalities and localization: 19th century perspectives. Poster presented at TENNET XIII,
  3. (2002). (b) Pitres’ two remarkable cases: pure agraphia (1884) and polyglot aphasia (1895).
  4. 1866a. Notes on the physiology and pathology of language.
  5. 1866b. On a case of loss of power of expression: inability to talk, to write, and to read correctly after convulsive attacks. doi
  6. 1866c, Case of disease of the left side of the brain, involving corpus striatum, etc; the aphasia of Trousseau; clinical remarks on psychico-physical symptoms. doi
  7. (1958). A study of convulsions.
  8. (2003). Acquired language disorders in 19 th century Ireland. Paper presented at TENNET 14,
  9. (2003). Acquired language disorders in 19th century Ireland. Paper presented at TENNET 14,
  10. (1843). Analyse de la parole pour servir à la théorie de divers cas d’alalie et de paralalie (de Mutisme et d’Imperfection du parler) que les nosologistes ont mal connus: leçons tirées du cours de physiologie de l’année scolaire 1842-1843. Louis Castel:
  11. (1995). Aux origines du cerveau: localisation, langage et mémoire dans l’oeuvre de Charcot. doi
  12. (2002). Brain plasticity and cognitive and behavioural changed in early development : 19th century perspectives.
  13. Case illustrating the supposed connexion of aphasia (loss of the cerebral faculty of speech) with right hemplegia and lesion of the external left frontal convolution of the brain.
  14. (1866). Case of Aphasia, or speechlessness. Reprinted from the Glasgow Medical Journal,
  15. (1903). Case of Pure Agraphia: an enigma for classical models of written language processing.
  16. (2001). Claude-François Lallemand, and the role of the Frontal Lobe. Archives of Neurology, doi
  17. (1998). Clinique de l’écriture: une histoire du regard médical sur l’écriture. Institut Synthélabo pour le progrès de la connaissance : Le Plessis-Robinson doi
  18. (2003). Considérations sur l'agraphie. Revue de Médecine, 1884 ; 4:855-873. English translation by
  19. (1878). D.The localization of cerebral disease: Gulstonian lectures to the Royal College of Physicians. Smith and Elder: London;
  20. (1877). Darwinism tested by language. doi
  21. (1921). Dictionnaire encyclopédique des sciences médicales. Masson : Paris ;
  22. Differanti forme d’afasia.
  23. (1903). Ein Fall von isolierter Agraphie. Monatschrift für Psychiatrie und Neurologie, doi
  24. (1883). Étude critique et clinique de la doctrine des localisation motrices dans l’écorce des hémisphères cérébraux de l’homme.
  25. (1992). Everyday reading and writing practices of normal adults: implications for aphasia assessment. Aphasiology, doi
  26. George’s Hospital Reports, doi
  27. Hospital Reports doi
  28. (1970). Hughlings Jackson’s first encounter with the work of Paul Broca: the physiological and philosophical background.
  29. (1978). Hughlings Jackson’s fundamental principles applied to psychiatry. In
  30. (2003). I The History of Written Language Disorders: Reexamining Pitres’ case (1884) of pure agraphia. Brain and Language, doi
  31. (1968). L’aphasie et le langage pathologique. JB Baillière:
  32. (1884). L’uomo delinquente in rapporto all’antropologia giurisprudenza ed all discipline carcerarie delinquente-nati e pazzo morale. Fratellu Bocca:
  33. (1879). La psychologie allemande contemporaine. Baillière:
  34. (1870). La psychologie anglaise contemporaine. Baillière:
  35. (2002). Language Modalities and Localization: 19 th century perspectives. Poster presentation. TENNET,
  36. (2002). Language Modalities and Localization: 19th century perspectives. Poster presentation. TENNET,
  37. Le langage intérieur et les diverses formes de l’aphasie. Alcan: Paris. 1886 Ballet, G. L’écriture de Léonard de Vinci. Contribution à l’étude de l’écriture en miroir.
  38. Les maladies de la mémoire. Alcan. Paris 1881. Roch Lecours, A. Jacques Lordat. Symposium on motor and sensory language processes.
  39. (1877). Lésions du centre ovale des hémisphères cérébraux étudiées au point de vue des localisation cérébrales. Doctoral thesis. Delahaye :
  40. (2000). Making sense of early literacy: A practicioner’ perspective. Trentham Books: Stoke-on-Trent;
  41. Mémoire sur quelques observations de physiologie pathologique tendant à démontrer l’existence d’un principe coordinateur de l’écriture et ses rapports avec le principe coordinateur de la parole.
  42. Nouvelle contribution à l’étude des localisations motrices dans l’écorce des hémisphères du cerveau.
  43. Observations on the Physiology of Language.
  44. On the connexion between loss of speech and paralysis of the right side.
  45. (1866). On the function of articulate speech. Reprinted from the
  46. On the varsious forms of loss of speech in cerebral disease.
  47. (2002). Paralysis and Aphasia: The role of Jabez Spence Ramskill in John Hughlings Jackson’s early development.
  48. (2001). Post-Gutenberg Galaxy: The Fourth Revolution in the Means of Production of Knowledge. The Public-Access Computer Systems Review
  49. (2003). Prematurity in scientific discovery. doi
  50. Rapport sur la question des aphasies. Congrès français de médecine interne
  51. Recherches expérimentales et critiques sur les convulsions épileptiformes d’origine corticale. Archives de Physiologie 1883
  52. (2000). Remarques sur le siège de la faculté du langage articulé, suivies d'une observation d'aphémie (perte de la parole). Bulletin de la Société Anatomique 1861; 6 : 330-357. English translation by C.D. doi
  53. Review of St. George’s Hospital Reports.
  54. (1914). Sémiologie des affections du système nerveux. doi
  55. TABLE 1: cases of dissociations between speech and writing disorders reported by Marcé (1856) Obs.
  56. (1994). The aphasia symptom-complex: a psychological study on an anatomical basis. doi
  57. (2000). the History of the Neurosciences,
  58. (1999). Théodule Ribot (1839-1916), founder of French psychology: a biographical introduction. History of Psychology, doi
  59. (1858). Traité de la folie des femmes enceintes, des nouvelles accouchées et des nourrices, et considérations médico-légales qui se rattachent à ce sujet. J.B. Baillière : doi
  60. (1865). Ueber Aphasie, Agraphie und verwandte pathologische Zustände.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.