Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Dialectics and difference: against Harvey's dialectical post-Marxism

By Andrew M. Jones


David Harvey`s recent book, Justice, nature and the geography of difference (JNGD), engages with a central philosophical debate that continues to dominate human geography: the tension between the radical Marxist project of recent decades and the apparently disempowering relativism and `play of difference' of postmodern thought. In this book, Harvey continues to argue for a revised `post-Marxist' approach in human geography which remains based on Hegelian-Marxian principles of dialectical thought. This article develops a critique of that stance, drawing on the work of Jacques Derrida, Gilles Deleuze and Felix Guattari. I argue that dialectical thinking, as well as Harvey's version of `post-Marxism', has been undermined by the wide-ranging `post-' critique. I suggest that Harvey has failed to appreciate the full force of this critique and the implications it has for `post-Marxist' ontology and epistemology. I argue that `post-Marxism', along with much contemporary human geography, is constrained by an inflexible ontology which excessively prioritizes space in the theory produced, and which implements inflexible concepts. Instead, using the insights of several `post-' writers, I contend there is a need to develop an ontology of `context' leading to the production of `contextual theories'. Such theories utilize flexible concepts in a multilayered understanding of ontology and epistemology. I compare how an approach which produces a `contextual theory' might lead to more politically empowering theory than `post-Marxism' with reference to one of Harvey's case studies in JNGD

Topics: geog
Publisher: Sage Journals
Year: 1999
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1976). [1967] O f Gramma t o l o g y
  2. (1976). [1967] Of Grammatology.
  3. (1988). [1968] Difference and Repetition. trans. doi
  4. (1982). [1972] M a r g i n s of Philos o p h y
  5. (1982). [1972] Margins of Philosophy. trans A. Bass. (Chicago: doi
  6. (1992). [ed] A Sociology of Monsters.
  7. (1994). [eds] G l o b a l i z a t i o n , Insti t u t i o n s , and Regio n a l Develop me n t
  8. (1994). [eds] Globalization, Institutions, and Regional Development doi
  9. (1996). A hundr e d thous a n d lines of fligh t : a machin i c intro d u c t i o n to the nomad thoug h t and scrumpl e d geogr a p h y of Gille s Deleu z e and Félix Guatt a r i .
  10. (1996). A hundred thousand lines of flight: a machinic introduction to the nomad thought and scrumpled geography of Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari. doi
  11. (1994). A thous a n d tiny sexes : femi n i s m and rhizo ma t i c s . " in Boundas,
  12. (1982). A Thousa n d Platea u ’ s . (Londo n : Athlon e
  13. (1982). A Thousand Plateau’s. doi
  14. (1994). A thousand tiny sexes: feminism and rhizomatics." in Boundas, doi
  15. (1988). B e r g s o n i s m. trans. H. Tomlims o n & B. Habber j a m (New York: Zone Books) Deleuze,
  16. (1983). B e y o n d objec t i v i s m and relat i v i s m: Scien c e , herme n e u t i c s and praxis. (Oxfor d :
  17. (1994). B r i n g i n g It All Back Home: class , gende r and power in the modern househ o l d . (Londo n :
  18. (1983). Beyond objectivism and relativism: Science, hermeneutics and praxis. doi
  19. (1993). Bodies that Matter. doi
  20. (1997). C a p i t a l Cultu r e . (Oxfo r d : Black w e l l
  21. (1997). C l a s s : The Next Postmo d e r n Front i e r . (New York: Guilfo r d
  22. (1996). C u t t i n g the networ k .
  23. (1990). Camb r i d g e : Cambr i d g e Unive r s i t y
  24. (1997). Capital Culture. doi
  25. (1997). Class: The Next Postmodern Frontier.
  26. (1978). Co g i t o and the Histor y of Madnes s ' in Writing and Difference ( L o n d o n : Routle d g e & Kegan Paul.) Derrida,
  27. (1978). Cogito and the History of Madness' in Writing and Difference (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.) Derrida,
  28. (1996). Cutting the network. doi
  29. (1989). D e l e u z e and Guatta r i . (Lond o n : Routl e d g e
  30. (1997). D i s s e c t i n g the auton o mo u s self: hybri d carto g r a p h i e s for a relat i o n a l ethi c s . '
  31. (1987). Deleuze and the Theater of Philosophy. ( L o n d o n : Routle d g e . ) Habermas,
  32. (1996). Diffusing Geography' ( L o n d o n : )
  33. (1975). E a r l y Polit i c a l Writi n g s (Peng u i n : Harmo n d s w o r t h
  34. (1996). E mpl o y me n t , femi n i s a t i o n and gentri f i c a t i o n in London
  35. (1993). E s s e n t i a l i s m and the econo my in the post- M a r x i s t imagi n e r y : reope n i n g the sutur e s .
  36. (1975). Early Political Writings (Penguin: Harmondsworth.)
  37. (1996). Employment, feminisation and gentrification in London 1981-93." doi
  38. (1993). Essentialism and the economy in the post-Marxist imaginery: reopening the sutures. doi
  39. (1986). F o u c a u l t : A Critic a l Reade r . (Oxfo r d : Black w e l l
  40. (1986). Foucault: A Critical Reader. doi
  41. (1991). G e n t r i f i c a t i o n as consu mp t i o n : issue s of class and gender .
  42. (1991). Gentrification as consumption: issues of class and gender. doi
  43. (1987). Gilles Deleuze and the Theater of Philosophy. doi
  44. (1992). H e a d to Head: The Comi ng Economi c Battle Among Japan, Europ e and Americ a . (New York: Willi a m Morro w ) .
  45. (1964). H e g e l 's Metap h y s i c s . (Chic a g o )
  46. (1985). H e g e mo n y and Social i s t Strat e g y . (Lond o n : Verso
  47. (1982). H e r me s : Art, Liter a t u r e and Scien c e . (Balt i mo r e : John Hopki n s Unive r s i t y Press
  48. (1993). H o me l e s s / G l o b a l : Scali n g Place s , ’
  49. (1992). Head to Head: The Coming Economic Battle Among Japan, Europe and America. doi
  50. (1982). Hegel's Dialectic and Its Criticism. doi
  51. (1964). Hegel's Metaphysics. doi
  52. (1985). Hegemony and Socialist Strategy. doi
  53. (1982). Hermes: Art, Literature and Science. doi
  54. (1993). Homeless/Global: Scaling Places,’
  55. (1995). I r o n i n g out the famil y : class , ge nde r and power in the house h o l d . Unpubl i s h e d paper, Dept. of Geogra p h y & Enviro n me n t a l Scienc e , Monash Unive r s i t y , Clayt o n , Austr a l i a .
  56. (1995). Ironing out the family: class, gender and power in the household. Unpublished paper,
  57. (1996). Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference. doi
  58. (1997). Leaky Bodies and Boundaries: feminism, postmodernism and (bio)ethics. doi
  59. (1992). Lond o n : Harve s t e r Wheat s h e a f
  60. (1993). Lond o n : Routl e d g e
  61. (1995). M a p p i n g the Subje c t : geogr a p h i e s of cultu r a l transf o r ma t i o n . (Londo n : Routle d g e
  62. (1982). M i c h e l Fouca u l t : Beyon d Struc t u r a l i s m and Herme n e u t i c s . (Chic a g o : Chica g o Unive r s i t y Press .
  63. (1992). M o d e r n Condi t i o n s , Postmo d e r n Contr o v e r s i e s . (Lond o n : Routl e d g e
  64. (1994). M u l t i c u l t u r a l i s m and 'The Po lit i c s of Recog n i t i o n ' with comme nta r y by
  65. (1995). Mapping the Subject: geographies of cultural transformation. (London: Routledge.) Probyn, E.
  66. (1997). Mich i g a n : Michi g a n Unive r s i t y
  67. (1982). Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics. doi
  68. (1992). Modern Conditions, Postmodern Controversies. doi
  69. (1994). Multiculturalism and 'The Politics of Recognition' with commentary by
  70. (1973). N e g a t i v e Diale c t i c s . (Lond o n : Routl e d g e & Kegan Paul) Albert,
  71. (1973). Negative Dialectics. (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul) Albert, doi
  72. (1991). P o l i t i c a l Theor y and Postmo d e r n i s m. (Camb r i d g e :
  73. (1981). P o s i t i o n s . trans. Alan Bass. (Londo n :
  74. (1995). P o s t - M a r x i s m: democ r a c y and ident i t y .
  75. (1994). P o s t mo d e r n revis i o n i n g s of the politi c a l . (Lond o n : Routl e d g e . )
  76. (1991). Political Theory and Postmodernism. doi
  77. (1981). Positions. trans. doi
  78. (1995). Post-Marxism: democracy and identity. doi
  79. (1994). Postmodern revisionings of the political. (London: Routledge.) Young, I. (1990a) Justice and the Politics of Difference.
  80. (1990). Putting dialectics to work: the process of abstraction in Marx's method.' doi
  81. (1993). R a d i c a l Polit i c a l Econo my . (Lond o n :
  82. (1998). R e a d i n g David Harve y : Entri e s , Voice s , Loyal t i e s .
  83. (1996). R e f i g u r i n g the econo mi c in econo mi c geogr a p h y .
  84. (1987). R e t h i n k i n g moder n i s m: minor i t y and major i t y theor i e s .
  85. (1993). Radical Political Economy. doi
  86. (1998). Reading David Harvey: Entries, Voices, Loyalties. doi
  87. (1996). Refiguring the economic in economic geography. doi
  88. (1987). Rethinking modernism: minority and majority theories. doi
  89. (1985). S c i e n c e and the modern world . (Lond o n : )
  90. (1985). Science and the modern world. doi
  91. (1988). Si t u a t e d Knowl e d g e s : The Scienc e Quest i o n in Femi ni s m and the Privi l e g e of the Parti a l Persp e c t i v e . '
  92. (1988). Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of the Partial Perspective.' doi
  93. (1997). Society & Space 9: 223-Whatmore, S. doi
  94. (1993). T h e Althus s e r i a n Legacy . doi
  95. (1989). T h e Despe r a t e Polit i c s of Postmo d e r n i s m. (Amhu r s t : Unive r s i t y of Massa c h u s e t t s
  96. (1985). T h e Diale c t i c a l Biolo g i s t . (Camb r i d g e , MA: Black w e l l
  97. (1996). T h e End of Capita l i s m (as we knew it). (Oxfor d : Black w e l l
  98. (1982). T h e Limit s to Capit a l . (Oxfo r d : Black w e l l
  99. (1969). T h e Logic of Meanin g . [ Logique de sens. doi
  100. (1991). T h e New Conste l l a t i o n . (Camb r i d g e :
  101. (1984). T h e Postmo d e r n Condi t i o n : a report on knowl e d g e . (Manc h e s t e r : Manch e s t e r Unive r s i t y Press ) .
  102. (1996). T h e Rise of the Networ k Societ y . (Oxfor d : Blackw e l l
  103. (1994). T h e Transf o r ma t i o n of Cultur a l Geogra p h y '
  104. (1993). T h e Truth about Postmo d e r n i s m. (Oxfor d : Blackw e l l
  105. (1996). T o w a r d s minor theory . doi
  106. (1992). Th e Quest i o n of Cultu r a l Ident i t y ' in
  107. (1993). The Althusserian Legacy. doi
  108. (1989). The Desperate Politics of Postmodernism. (Amhurst: doi
  109. (1985). The Dialectical Biologist. doi
  110. (1996). The End of Capitalism (as we knew it). doi
  111. (1982). The Limits to Capital. doi
  112. (1969). The Logic of Meaning. [Logique de sens. doi
  113. (1991). The New Constellation. (Cambridge: Polity.)
  114. (1984). The Postmodern Condition: a report on knowledge. doi
  115. (1992). The Question of Cultural Identity'
  116. (1996). The Rise of the Network Society. doi
  117. (1994). The Transformation of Cultural Geography' doi
  118. (1993). The Truth about Postmodernism. doi
  119. (1996). Towards minor theory. doi
  120. (1989). Wholeness and the Implicate Order. (London: Routledge doi
  121. (1993). Worlds: Essays in Cultural Politics. doi
  122. (1993). Worlds: Essays in Cultural Politics. ( L o n d o n : Methue n doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.