Article thumbnail

Can we design a market for competitive health insurance? CHERE Discussion Paper No 53

By Jane Hall


The topic of this paper is whether it is possible, given the current state of knowledge and technology, to design the appropriate market structure for managed competition. The next section reviews market failure in the private health insurance market. The subsequent two sections describe the principles of managed competition and its development and application in other countries. Then, the paper outlines recent developments in private health insurance policy in Australia, and proposals to apply managed competition in this country. The required design of the managed competition market place is described, and four major issues, risk adjustment, budget holding, consumer behaviour, and insurer behaviour, are identified. The final sections of the paper review the evidence on these four issues to determine if managed competition can be implemented, given current knowledge.Health Insurance, Managed competition, Australia

OAI identifier:

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.

Suggested articles


  1. (1989). A consumer-choice health plan for the 1990s. Universal health insurance in a system designed to promote quality and economy (1). New England
  2. (1989). A consumer-choice health plan for the 1990s. Universal health insurance in a system designed to promote quality and economy (2). New England
  3. (1991). A Healthy Risk? Use of Private Insurance: National Health Strategy Background Paper No 4. Melbourne,
  4. (1996). A social contract for 21st century health care: three-tier health care with bounty hunting.
  5. (2003). Can Managed Care And Competition Control Medicare Costs? Health Affairs,
  6. (1999). Carrots and sticks--the fall and fall of private health insurance in Australia.
  7. (1997). Choosing a health plan: what information will consumers use? Health Affairs;
  8. (2002). Churchill’s dictum and the next new thing in American health care: Paper presented at The Commonwealth Fund’s Harkness Fellowships in Health Care Policy Orientation Dinner.
  9. (1996). Competition and game theory.
  10. (1999). Competition, cooperation, or control? Tales from the British National Health Service. Health Affairs;
  11. (1996). Comprehension of quality care indicators: differences among privately insured, publicly insured, and uninsured. Health Care Financing Review;
  12. (1997). Consumer health plan choice: current knowledge and future directions.
  13. (1996). Consumer perspectives on information needs for health plan choice. Health Care Financing Review;
  14. (1978). Consumer-choice health plan (first of two parts). Inflation and inequity in health care today: alternatives for cost control and an analysis of proposals for national health insurance.
  15. (1996). Consumer’s information needs: results of a national survey.
  16. (2001). Do consumers know how their health plan works? Health Affairs;
  17. (1997). Does managed care lead to better or worse quality of care?
  18. (1999). Economics and Australian Health Policy.
  19. (1999). European Observatory on Health Care Systems
  20. (1998). From competition to co-operation: new economic relationships in the National Health Service.
  21. (2002). Getting more for their dollar: a comparison of the NHS with California’s Kaiser Permanente.
  22. (1994). GP fundholding: Wild card or winning hand?” in
  23. (2003). Health and Ageing Private Health Insurance Branch
  24. (2001). Health Care Systems in Transition: Australia. London, European Observatory on Health Care Systems.
  25. (2003). Health insurance scams: How government is responding and what further steps are needed”
  26. (1971). Health maintenance strategy.
  27. (1998). Health plan report cards and insurance choice.
  28. (2002). Health spending projections for 2001-2011: the latest outlook. Faster health spending growth and a slowing economy drive the health spending projection for
  29. (1994). How consumers choose health insurance: Analyzing employees’ selection process in a multiplan environment identifies the trade-offs consumers make and the benefits that affect their decision making.
  30. (1980). How does the quality of health care in HMOs compare to that in other settings? An analytic literature review:
  31. (1999). Incremental change in the Australian health care system.
  32. (1990). Integrating Medicare with private health insurance: The best of both worlds?”
  33. (2000). International comparisons of health expenditure: Theory, data and econometric analysis” in
  34. (2003). It’s the prices, stupid: why the United States is so different from other countries.
  35. (2000). Managed care at a crossroads. Health Affairs;
  36. (1997). Managed Care Choice and Patient Satisfaction.
  37. (2000). Managed care in the United States: a dilemma for evidence-based policy?
  38. (2000). Managed care” in
  39. (2002). Managed Competition in Health Care: Workshop Proceedings,
  40. (2003). Market design: The policy uses of theory.
  41. (1972). Medical care in the melting pot : an Australian review. Sydney, Angus and Robertson.
  42. OECD Health Data 2000: A Comparative Analysis of 29 Countries.
  43. (2001). of Health and Aged Care
  44. (2003). of Health and Ageing (2003a). Health and Ageing Portfolio Budget Statements: Budget 2003-04. Australian Department of Health and Ageing,
  45. (2002). of Health and Welfare
  46. (2002). Opening remarks” in Productivity Commission Managed Competition in Health Care.
  47. (2002). Private Health Insurance Advisory Council
  48. (1991). Reforming health care in seven European nations.
  49. (2000). Risk adjustment in competitive health plan markets”
  50. (1996). Role of information in consumer selection of health plans. Health Care Financing Review;
  51. (2000). The Australian Health Care System.
  52. (1975). The Health Cost Explosion.
  53. (2000). The new health insurance rebate: an inefficient way of assisting public hospitals.
  54. (2000). The NHS Plan: A Plan for Investment, a Plan for Reform. London, Department of Health.
  55. (2000). The political economy of health sector reform”
  56. (1999). Towards a reinforced agency role of health insurers in Belgium and The Netherlands. Health Policy;