Article thumbnail

A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF ALTERNATIVE ECONOMETRIC PACKAGES: AN APPLICATION TO ITALIAN DEPOSIT INTEREST RATES

By Ricardo De Bonis and Giuseppe Bruno

Abstract

In examining the determinants of Italian deposit interest rates, we compares alternative econometric packages for estimating panel data. We focus on bank deposits, one of the main forms Italian households use to invest their financial wealth. We survey the literature on deposit rates, with particular reference to the large number of US studies. The empirical analysis is based on more than 8,000 observations for the years 1990-1996. Bank interest rates are taken from the Central Credit Register. We consider the rates on current accounts, certificates of deposit, and total deposits. Other variables are obtained from the Banking Supervision1s statistical returns. We look at the influence on interest rates of the Herfindahl index, the number of banks in each province, the rate of growth in deposits, the custodial holdings of bonds, the ratio of banking costs to total assets.With this abundance of panel data, many different specifications have been estimated using the fixed- and random-effects models. Our purpose is to examine the caveats about numerical accuracy raised by McCullogh and Vinod, who are concerned that little attention is paid to numerical accuracy in the selection of econometric packages. We compare the numerical value of the estimates of three of the most popular econometric packages featuring built-in panel data estimation algorithms: LIMDEP, STATA, and TSP. As a numerical benchmark we used Modeleasy, a general-purpose language allowing matrix operations.The preliminary results look quite promising:1) fixed-effects algorithms are numerically the same to the available decimal places.2) random-effects algorithms yield slightly different results because of the method for computing the variance components.In addition, we compare the relative efficiency of the random-effects algorithms provided by the three packages. This is done by means of a set of suitably designed Monte Carlo experiments, varying the time span and the number of provinces taken into account.

OAI identifier:

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1973). A Comparative Study of Alternative Estimators for Variance Components Models Used in Econometric Applications,
  2. (1989). A Review of Concentration-Price Studies in Banking,
  3. (1990). Bank pricing of retail deposit accounts and the “California rate mistery”, Economic Review (Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco),
  4. (1984). Bank, Market Structure and Competition,
  5. (1992). Banking Structure and Competition, in The New Palgrave: Dictionary of Money and Finance.
  6. (1989). Bias Correction and Bootstrapping of Error Component Models for Panel data: Theory and Applications,
  7. (1972). Carosio e T. Padoa-Schioppa
  8. (1998). Concentration, Technology, and Markey Power in Banking: Is Distance Dead ? Financial Industry Studies, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas,
  9. (1989). Deposit Interest Rates and Local Market Concentration,
  10. Di Battista 1994,(a cura di), “ Tendenze e prospettive della raccolta bancaria in Italia”, Il
  11. (1998). Do Substantial Horizontal Mergers Generate Significant Price Effects? Evidence from the Banking Industry,
  12. (1995). Econometric Analysis of Panel Data,
  13. Ferrando (1997b), Da che cosa dipendono i tassi di interesse sui prestiti nelle province?, Banca d’Italia, Temi di discussione,
  14. (1998). Freixas e Rochet
  15. (1999). Gli effetti delle concentrazioni bancarie sulle caratteristiche concorrenziali dei mercati dei depositi: evidenze empiriche e considerazioni teoriche,
  16. (2000). L’applicazione della disciplina antitrust nel settore bancario statunitense, in M. Polo (a cura di) “Industria bancaria e concorrenza”,
  17. (1994). La concorrenza nel mercato dei depositi bancari,
  18. (1996). La modifica del trattamento fiscale degli interessi sui depositi,
  19. (1997). Le determinanti del tasso di interesse sui crediti alle imprese, Banca d’Italia, Temi di discussione,
  20. (1996). Le politiche di raccolta delle banche, Il
  21. (1997). Market Share Inequality, the Number of Competitors, and the HHI: An Examination of Bank Pricing,
  22. (1992). Market Structure and the Nature of Price Rigidity: Evidence from the Market for Consumer Deposits,
  23. (1992). Software Review, in “The Econometrics of Panel Data: handbook of theory and appplications”,
  24. (1979). Struttura dell’offerta e tassi d’interesse nei mercati bancari italiani,
  25. (1974). The Concentration-Profits Relationship
  26. (1995). The Credit Channel of Monetary Policy across Heterogeneous Banks: The Case of Italy, Banca d’Italia, Temi di discussione,
  27. (1997). The Effect of Consumer Switching Costs on Prices: A Theory and its Application to the Bank Deposit Market,
  28. (1972). The exact finite sample properties of the estimators of coefficients in the error components regresion models,
  29. (1998). The Expanding Geographic Reach of Retail Banking Markets, Federal Reserve41 Bank of
  30. (1999). The Numerical Reliability of Econometric Software,
  31. (1989). The Price-Concentration Relationship in Banking,
  32. (1992). The Price-Concentration Relationship in Banking: A Reply,
  33. (1992). The Price-Concentration Relationship,
  34. (1991). The Pricing of Retail Deposits: Concentration and Information,
  35. (1991). The Rigidity of Prices: Evidence from the Banking Industry,