Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Landscapes without the car : a counterfactual historical geography of twentieth-century Britain.

By Colin Pooley


Despite increased concern about environmental damage and resource depletion, the private motor car, and associated automobility, are taken-for granted aspects of 21st century life. This paper makes the counterfactual assumption that private ownership of cars was severely restricted at the start of the twentieth century, and uses a range of historical data to examine the ways in which such a scenario might have impacted on transport infrastructure, personal mobility and urban life. It is argued that, even without the wholesale adoption of the motor car as a means of personal transport, patterns of everyday mobility would not have differed significantly from today so long as other forms of transport had remained or expanded to cope with this demand. However, such a scenario would probably have required journeys to be planned in different ways, and may have disadvantaged particular groups of the population, including some women. A landscape without cars would probably also have altered the form of cities, with services provided closer to where people live, and levels of air pollution substantially lower. The counterfactual historical analysis is used to argue that, although there is little likelihood of cars being banned in Britain, greater restrictions on private motor vehicles would not necessarily lead to the fundamental changes in everyday mobility that some might predict

Year: 2010
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Lancaster E-Prints

Suggested articles


  1. (2005). A mobile century? Changes in everyday mobility
  2. (2003). A new deal for transport?
  3. A similar point was made in a Guardian editorial on
  4. (1978). A social history of housing, 1815-1970,
  5. (1997). Accidents in history: injuries, fatalities and social relations,
  6. (2007). All material on the development of the road system in NW England from The Motorway Archive: (accessed
  7. (2008). and Vehicle Licensing Authority, Annual Report 2007-8,
  8. (2003). and Vehicle Licensing Authority, Press Release 3,
  9. (2007). Animating suspension: waiting for mobilities,
  10. (1936). Annual Report of the Medical Officer of Health,
  11. (1996). Aramis, or the love of technology, doi
  12. Association between child and adolescent television viewing and adult health: a longitudinal birth cohort study,
  13. (2002). Association between mortality and indicators of traffic-related air pollution in the Netherlands: a cohort study, The Lancet 360: 9341,
  14. (1969). British transport: an economic survey from the seventeenth century to the twentieth,
  15. (2000). Commuting, transport and urban form: Manchester and Glasgow in the mid-twentieth century,
  16. (2000). Commuting, transport and urban form: Manchester and Glasgow in the mid-twentieth century, Urban History 27,
  17. (1926). Corporation Tramways Department, Annual Report,
  18. (1989). Counterurbanization: the changing pace and nature of population deconcentration,
  19. (2000). Cultures of mothering and car use in suburban Sydney: a preliminary investigation,
  20. (2007). Cycling and Society,
  21. (2004). Department for Transport, Speed: Know your limits.
  22. (1926). Department for Transport, Transport Statistics (various years): 532,506 killed
  23. Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions, A new deal for transport: better for everyone. The Government White Paper on the future of transport,
  24. (2007). Driving spaces,
  25. (2007). For a detailed consideration of these issues see:
  26. (1984). For a fuller discussion of some of these issues see: J Dodgson, Railway costs and closures,
  27. (1971). For overviews of the development of motoring in
  28. (2003). Global complexity,
  29. (2002). Globalization in world history, doi
  30. (2004). Greater London Authority, The mayor’s transport strategy revision,
  31. (2005). H.Bell, An evaluation of national road user charging in England and Wales, Transportation Research, Part A: Policy and Practice, doi
  32. Mobilities, networks, geographies, doi
  33. (1969). Motorways in London,
  34. (2007). National Air Quality Archive: (accessed
  35. (2004). Obesity and health-related quality of life: a cross-sectional analysis of the US population,
  36. (2007). On the development of the German autobahn network see
  37. (1971). On various aspects of regulation and the impact of cars on pedestrians and traffic
  38. p11; Department for Transport, Speed: Know your limits.
  39. Planning and the Big C: Challenging Auto Dependence through Conviction Politics in London, Planning Theory and Practice, doi
  40. (1991). Plausible Worlds: Possibility and Understanding in History and the Social Sciences,
  41. Policies to attract drivers out of their cars for short trips,
  42. (1995). Producing hegemony: the politics of mass production and American global power, doi
  43. (1934). Quoted in The Times,
  44. (1964). Railroads and American Economic Growth: Essays in Econometric History,
  45. (2002). Reading retail: a geographical perspective on retailing and consumption spaces,
  46. (2005). Rural accesibility, social inclusion and social justice: towards conceptualsiation, doi
  47. (2000). Sociology beyond societies: mobilities for the 21 st century,
  48. (2000). Sociology beyond societies: mobilities for the 21st century,
  49. (1996). Speed control and transport policy,
  50. (1933). Street Traffic Flow,
  51. The British railway network in the Beeching era,
  52. (1998). The car in British society: class gender and motoring 1896-1939,
  53. (2000). The city and the car,
  54. (2007). The digital nexus of post-automobility, on-line
  55. (2007). The digital nexus of post-automobility, on-line paper,
  56. (2006). The impact of new transport technologies on intra-urban mobility: a view from the past, Environment and Planning A 38,
  57. (2005). The limits to integration: Hypermobility:a challenge to governance, in
  58. (1998). The motor car and politics 1896-1970, London; S. O’Connell, The car in British society: class gender and motoring 1896-1939,
  59. (2007). The Motorway Archive: (accessed
  60. The Motorway Archive.
  61. (1997). The past and future of global mobility, Scientific American.
  62. (1990). The pedestrian and city traffic,
  63. The reshaping of British railways: report and maps,
  64. (2005). Travel-time use in the information age,
  65. (2005). Turnbull and Adams, A mobile century?
  66. (2003). Vehicle Licensing Authority, Press Release 3,
  67. (2004). What if? The world’s foremost military historians imagine what might have been,
  68. (2001). Why do people use their cars for short trips?,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.