A comparison of transaction costs on Xetra and on Nasdaq

Abstract

In today's financial world, providing high quality of order execution at low transaction costs is vitally important to the competitiveness of trading platforms; thus the stock market's microstructure has become a subject of fierce debate and models for computing transaction costs have been needed for quite a while. Capital market synergetics is appropriate to investigate the market microstructure's effectiveness and is implemented in the computer program KapSyn. In this paper we compare transaction costs for small, medium-size and block-size orders on each exchange, examining different market scenarios. By investigating the peculiarities of Xetra and of Nasdaq we point out their comparative advantages: calculation results clearly show the high operating efficiency of Nasdaq's small-order execution system and Xetra's favourable execution of medium-size and block-size orders. Investors' trading decisions may benefit from taking these results into account. For policy makers and academics these findings contribute to the debate about the optimal design of a market microstructure by highlighting the areas of high performance.