Article thumbnail

MEASURING PROTECTION IN AGRICULTURE: THE PRODUCER SUBSIDY EQUIVALENT REVISITED

By William A. Masters

Abstract

In the 1980s, the Producer Subsidy Equivalent (PSE) became the dominant measure of protection in applied studies of international agricultural trade. This paper analyzes potential biases in the ratio form of the PSE introduced by using actual domestic prices rather than social opportunity costs in the denominator. It is shown that doing so introduces a consistent under-estimation of the effects of trade restrictions and other price-support policies, relative to deficiency payments and other income-support policies. It is found that under plausible conditions this bias leads the PSE to rank protection levels across countries or crops incorrectly. In a sample of 250 activities across 33 countries, such errors were found to occur in 5% of crop comparisons and 8% of country comparisons, including a number of politically sensitive cases. An improved formula would therefore provide significantly more accurate results than the conventional PSE, with no additional data or more restrictive assumptions.Agricultural and Food Policy, International Relations/Trade,

OAI identifier:
Downloaded from http://purl.umn.edu/51114

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1992). A Survey of Agriculture." The Economist,
  2. (1990). Agricultural Policies and the GATT: Reconciling Protection, Support and Distortion."
  3. (1993). Agricultural Policies, Markets and Trade: Monitoring and Outlook
  4. (1975). Agricultural Protection and Stabilization Policies: A Framework for Measurement in the Context of Agricultural Adjustment." Report No. C 75LIM2.
  5. (1973). Agricultural Protection: Domestic Policy and International Trade." Report No. C 73LIM9.
  6. (1955). Canadian Tariff Policy."
  7. (1989). Estimation of Agricultural Assistance Using Producer and Consumer Subsidy Equivalents: Theory and Practice."
  8. (1989). Measuring Levels of Protection in Agriculture: A Survey of Methods and Approaches,"
  9. (1989). Negotiating Reductions in Agricultural Support: Implications of Technology and Factor Mobility."
  10. (1990). Of Models and Measures: Some Thoughts on the Use and Abuse of Policy Indicators." Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Agricultural Trade Research Consortium,
  11. (1989). PSEs and the Mix of Measures to Support Farm Incomes." The World Economy,
  12. (1989). The Policy Analysis Matrix for Agricultural Development.