Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Small Countries and Preferential Trade Agreements "How Severe is the Innocent Bystander Problem?"

By M. Ayhan Kose and Raymond Riezman


This paper examines the welfare implications of preferential trade agreements (PTAs) from the perspective of small countries in the context of a multi-country, general equilibrium model. We calibrate our model to represent one relatively small country and two symmetric big countries. We consider two cases. In one case, the small country is an 'innocent bystander', that is, it is left out of a PTA between the two large countries. In the second case, the small country signs a PTA with one of the large countries. We simulate the model and calculate consumption allocations, prices, t rade volume, and tariffs in these two cases considering three different equilibria: Free Trade (FT), Free Trade Area (FTA), and Customs Union (CU). We find that free trade is the best outcome for the small country. If the large country PTA takes the for m of a CU then the cost of being an 'innocent bystander' is very large. If it is a FTA then the cost of being an 'innocent bystander' is relatively modest. In fact, the small country prefers to be an 'innocent bystander' to being a member of a FTA with one of the large countries.Preferential trade agreements, general equilibrium, tariffs, welfare, small countries

OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1987). 1991b, Is bilateralism bad?,
  2. (1999). Can bilateral trade agreements help induce free trade?,
  3. (1991). Commodity trade and International risk sharing: How much do Financial Markets Matter?,
  4. (1985). Customs unions and the core,
  5. (1988). Do big countries win tariff wars?,
  6. (1993). Endogenous protection and trade diversion,
  7. (1993). Expanding E.C. membership and association accords: recent experience and future prospects,
  8. (1996). How severe is global retaliation risk under increasing regionalism?,
  9. (1993). New dimensions in regional integration,
  10. (1990). Optimal tariff equilibria with customs unions,
  11. (1996). Regionalism in a multilateral world, mimeo,
  12. (1996). Some welfare effects of sequential customs union formation,
  13. (1991). The move toward free trade zones, in Policy Implications of Trade and Currency Zones. A symposium sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City.
  14. (1996). The size of trading blocs: Market power and world welfare effects,
  15. (1999). Understanding the welfare implications of preferential trade agreements, forthcoming,
  16. (1999). Welfare and customs unions, forthcoming,
  17. (1998). Why do countries seek regional trade agreements?,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.