Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The changing nature of U.S. card payment fraud: industry and public policy options

By Richard J. Sullivan


As credit and debit card payments have become the primary payment instrument in retail transactions, awareness of identity theft and concerns over the safety of payments has increased. Traditional forms of card payment fraud are still an important threat, but fraud resulting from unauthorized access to payment data appears to be rising, and we are only beginning to get a sense of the dimensions of the problem. ; Thus far, the role of public policy has been to encourage the card payment industry to limit fraud by developing its own standards and procedures. Whether this policy stance is sufficient depends on the effectiveness of industry efforts to limit fraud in light of the dramatic shift toward card payments. ; Sullivan provides an overview of card payment fraud in the United States. He develops a preliminary estimate of the rate of U.S. card payment fraud and suggests that such fraud is higher than in several other countries for which data are available. The U.S. payment industry is taking steps to combat payment fraud, but progress has been slowed by conflicts of interest, inadequate incentives, and lack of coordination. Thus, policymakers should monitor the card payment industry to see if it better coordinates security efforts, and if not, consider actions to help overcome barriers to effective development of security.

OAI identifier: oai:RePEc:fip:fedker:y:2010:i:qii:p:101-133:n:v.95no.2

Suggested articles


  1. (2009). 14, at
  2. (2007). 8th Annual Online Fraud Report.” ____________.
  3. (2009). ABA Deposit Account Fraud Survey Highlights of Survey Results.”
  4. (2007). Association.
  5. (2008). Can Smart Cards Reduce Payments Fraud and Identity Theft?” Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City,
  6. (2009). Credit Card Skimming Survey: What’s Your Magstripe Worth?” Wired Magazine Threat Level blog, October 2, at threatlevel/2009/10/ florida_skimming.
  7. (2008). Data Breaches and Identity Theft,” Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, working
  8. (2009). Data Security Slugfest: Tokenization Vs End-to-End Encryption,” Storefront Backtalk website, April 15, at
  9. (2009). Data Security, Privacy, and Identity Theft: The Economics Behind the Policy Debates,” Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Economic Perspectives, First Quarter,
  10. (2009). Debate Lingers Over Definition Of ‘End-To-End’
  11. (2009). End-to-End Encryption and Chip Cards in the U.S. Payments Industry,” September, at pdf/End-toEnd_Encryption_Position Paper_090809.pdf.
  12. (2009). Fraud: The Facts
  13. (2010). Global Internet Security Threat Report,” April, at http://
  14. (2007). Introduction,”
  15. (2008). Merchants Call Credit Card Industry’s Bluff on Compliance,” The Register,
  16. (2006). National Data Breach Analysis.” Javelin Strategy and Research.
  17. (2010). New Card and Banking Fraud Figures,” press release,
  18. (2009). New Security Focus Goes Beyond
  19. (2007). Observatory for Payment Card Security (OPCS).
  20. (2009). Probe Targets Archives’ Handling of
  21. (2007). Promoting E-business Through Vertical IS Standards: Lessons from the U.S. Home Mortgage Industry,”
  22. (2008). Recent Payment Trends in the United
  23. (2007). Risk Management and Nonbank Participation in the U.S. Retail Payments System,” Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City,
  24. (2003). Security of Payments: A Retailer’s Viewpoint,” British Retail Consortium, at
  25. (2009). Signature Makes Cards ‘Less Secure’,” ZDNet Asia website,
  26. (2009). The Benefits of Collecting and Reporting Payment Fraud Statistics for the United States,” Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, Payment System Research Briefing,
  27. (1990). The Credit Card Industry: A History. Boston: Twayne Publishers.
  28. (2009). TJX Hacker Charged With Heartland, Hannaford Breaches,” Wired Magazine Threat Level Blog,
  29. (2008). Understanding Risk Management in Emerging Retail Payments,” Federal Reserve Bank of New York,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.