Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

A comparison of optimal tax policies when compensation or responsibility matter

By Laurent JACQUET and Dirk VAN DE GAER


This paper examines optimal redistribution in a model with high and low-skilled individuals with heterogeneous tastes for labor, that either work or not. With such double heterogeneity, traditional Welfarist criteria including Utilitarianism fail to take the compensation-responsibility trade-off into account. As a response, several other criteria have been proposed in the literature. This paper is the first to compare the extent to which optimal policies based on different normative criteria obey the principles of compensation (for differential skills) and responsibility (for preferences for labor), when labor supply is along the extensive margin. The criteria from the social choice literature perform better in this regard than the traditional criteria, both in first and second best. More importantly, these equality of opportunity criteria push the second best policy away from an Earned Income Tax Credit and in the direction of a Negative Income tax.optimal income taxation, equality of opportunity, heterogeneous preferences for labor

OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2007). A contribution to the theory of optimal utilitarian income taxation,
  2. (1993). A pragmatic theory of responsibility for the egalitarian planner,
  3. (1992). A reexamination of the optimal nonlinear income tax,
  4. (1971). A Theory of Justice,
  5. and F.Maniquet (2009), Compensation and responsibility,
  6. de gaer (2007), Equality of opportunity versus equality of opportunity sets,
  7. (2007). Disability Testing and Retirement,
  8. (1993). Equality of opportunity and investment in human capital.
  9. (1998). Equality of Opportunity.
  10. (1980). Equality of What? In:
  11. (2006). Fair Income Tax,
  12. (2005). Fair social orderings when agents have unequal production skills,
  13. (2008). Fairness, Responsibility and Welfare,
  14. (2005). Health, Wealth and Fairness,
  15. (2007). Help the Low Skilled or Let the Hardworking Thrive? A Study of Fairness in Optimal Income Taxation,
  16. (1980). Income Taxation with Fixed Hours of Work,
  17. (2002). Mar Racionero
  18. (1994). On fair compensation,
  19. (2005). Optimal Incentives for Labor Force Participation,
  20. (2000). Optimal Income Taxation with Quasi linear Preferences Revisited,
  21. (1998). Optimal Income Taxation: An Example with a U Shaped
  22. (2002). Optimal Income Transfer Programs: Intensive versus Extensive Labor Supply responses,
  23. (2008). Optimal Policy with Heterogeneous Preferences, The B.E.
  24. (2003). Optimal Redistribution When Different Workers Are Indistinguishable,
  25. (2009). Optimal redistribution with unobservable disability: wel farist versus non welfarist social objectives,
  26. (2004). Optimal retirement and disability benefits with audit,
  27. (1996). Redistribution and compensation,
  28. (2009). Redistribution and Inequality in a Heterogeneous Society, forthcoming in Economica.
  29. (1995). Redistribution mechanisms based on individual characteristics,
  30. (2004). Responsibility sensi tive egalitarianism and optimal linear income taxation,
  31. (1999). Responsibility, talent, and compensation: a second best analysis,
  32. (2009). Should labor force participation be subsidized?, mimeo INSEE CREST.
  33. (1995). The Requisites of Equal Opportunity.
  34. (1995). Three solutions for the compensation problem,
  35. (2003). To what extent do fiscal regimes equalize opportunities for income acquisition among citizens?,
  36. (2007). Welfare reforms in European coun tries: a microsimulation analysis,
  37. (1981). What is Equality? Part 1. Equality of Welfare.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.