Location of Repository

Effects of 'Authorized-Generics' on Canadian Drug Prices

By Paul Grootendorst

Abstract

This paper examines how the use of ‘authorized-generics’ (AGs) influences Canadian prescription drug prices. An authorized-generic is the actual brand name drug product, manufactured by the brand firm, but sold as a generic by a licensee or subsidiary of the brand, competing with independent generics (IGs), which operate independently from the brand firm. In theory, AGs have offsetting effects on drug prices. On the one hand, AGs compete against IGs and increases in the number of generic competitors should lower prices. On the other hand, the threat of AG entry into a therapeutic market might deter entry by IGs and this would lessen competition. Moreover, brand firms might increase prices of their brand drugs to increase demand for their AG. I find that when AGs are first to enter a drug market, average drug prices drop by about 12%; average prices drop by smaller amounts, the larger the AG share of the generic market. I could not directly assess whether the threat of AG entry into a market might deter entry by IGs. IG executives, however, state that the threat of AG entry has decreased their incentive to challenge ‘marginal’ drug markets. In particular the threat of AG entry has increased from $5m to $10m the threshold market size – the value of brand drug sales in the 10th year that it has been on the market, below which the IG firm will not attempt to enter. IG executives also stated that AGs have seriously reduced IG retained earnings. The reduction in retained earnings has hampered their ability to challenge brand drugs with annual sales well above $10m, but which have particularly high entry costs. Finally, the IG executives claimed that brand firms have attempted to use the threat of AG entry to negotiate agreements with the IG to delay entry (or not enter at all). A comprehensive evaluation of the competitive effects of AGs would need to verify and quantify these costs and compare these to the benefits of AG competition.authorized-generic drugs, independent generic drugs, drug prices, Canada

OAI identifier:

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (2006). Assessing the effects of authorized generics on consumer prices.
  2. (2004). Generic drugopoly: Why non-patented prescription drugs cost more in Canada than in the United States and Europe. Fraser Institute Public Policy Sources,
  3. (2005). How do brands’ ‘own generics’ affect pharmaceutical prices? Review of Industrial Organization
  4. (2003). Lowering generic drug prices: less regulation equals more competition. Medical Care
  5. (1992). Pharmaceutical prices with insurance coverage and formularies.
  6. (2004). Review of Industrial Organization
  7. The anti-competitive effects of brand-controlled ‘pseudo-generics’ in the Canadian pharmaceutical market. Canadian Public Policy 2003; 29(1):21–31. Hollis A. The importance of being first: Evidence from Canadian generic pharmaceuticals.
  8. Variable definitions variable name description -----------------------------------------------------lap log average brand price dag

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.