Location of Repository

Decision making in child protection practice

By Nancy Kelly

Abstract

This research explores the decision making processes of individuals and groups engaged in\ud child protection practice within social services departments in the UK. The emphasis of the\ud research was to consider how the application of psychological theories and concepts might\ud allow a descriptive and interpretative evaluation of decision processes in child protection\ud practice. The research sought to elaborate upon much of previous social work literature in that\ud it focused upon the processes of decision making rather than the outcomes for participants.\ud Similarly it sought to elaborate upon literature in decision theory in that it focused upon real\ud world, ongoing and naturalistic decision situations. The theoretical framework used in the\ud research was an integrated model of decision making under conditions of risk proposed by\ud Whyte (1989,1991). This model outlines circumstances under which individuals and groups\ud may take decisions in the directions of risk or caution.\ud \ud \ud The methodological approach was grounded in the principles of qualitative research. Drawing\ud upon Forster (1994) and Yin (1989) documentary analysis was applied to case studies. The\ud research considered documents in relation to two categories of child protection cases. Initially\ud those where children who were already known to child protection practitioners had died,\ud namely, child death inquiry reports. Ongoing cases within a local authority child protection\ud department, where the outcomes and decision making were considered to be positive, were\ud then analysed. The interpretation from the first stage of the research suggested that all the\ud concepts outlined in Whyte's model could have explanatory value and that the deaths of\ud children could be a consequence of the ways in which decisions are framed and which leave\ud children in situations of risk. The second stage involved the analysis of documents in relation\ud to eight ongoing cases within a local authority. The number of group meetings held in the eight\ud cases was 38 and in 71% of these the operation of the certainty effect in the direction of risk\ud was evident. In the remaining 39% there was evidence that the certainty effect operated in the\ud direction of caution. Within the documents there was some evidence of group polarisation and\ud groupthink. Resources were committed and escalated consistently in order to ensure the\ud effectiveness of initial plans of action despite evidence that these were unsuccessful in terms of\ud the overall well being of the children.\ud \ud \ud The decisions were shown to be bounded by the 'objective' principles of the Children Act 1989\ud and Working Together (1991). However themes that emerged from the analysis of the cases\ud suggest that there is a 'subjective' influence on decision processes. Evident within the analysis\ud was a shared fundamental belief in keeping children with their mothers. Both these objective\ud and subjective influences suggest that almost inevitably decision making in child protection\ud practice will be driven in directions that result in courses of action that involve potential and\ud actual risks for children. The findings emphasise how an explicit recognition of the\ud multifaceted nature of decision making can assist in more reflective practice. The ways in\ud which national and local policy impacts upon decision processes, at the level of the individual\ud and groups, need to be monitored in order that the needs of children in situations that involve\ud risk remain paramount

Topics: HQ, BF
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.hud.ac.uk:4845

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. 56,
  2. (1970). 7he Battered Baby,
  3. (1995). A
  4. (1997). A bipolar model of groupthink: An expansion of Janis's concept.
  5. (1985). A Child in Trust: Report of the Panel of Inquiry Investigating the Circumstances Surrounding the Death ofJasmine Beckfiord. London, London Borough of Brent London Borough of Greenwich
  6. (1990). A matter of record, documentary sources in social research. London, Polity press.
  7. (1996). A motivational investigation of group effectiveness using social cognitive theory. Joumal ofApplied Psychology.
  8. (1968). A Psychoatric study of parents who abuse infants and small children. In
  9. (1998). A Qualitative Study of Social Work Assessment in Cases of Alleged Child Abuse.
  10. (1995). A Range Frequency Explanation of Shifting Reference Points in Risky Decision Making. Organisational Behaviour and Humand Decision Making.
  11. (1990). A Review of Research on Groupthink.
  12. (1992). A template approach to text analysis: developing and using codcbooks. In
  13. (1998). Alive and well after 25 years: A review of groupthink research. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  14. (1989). An Introduction to the Children Act
  15. (1976). An investigation of the relations among probability estimates.
  16. (1996). Antecedents of groupthink: A quantitative study.
  17. (1996). Avoidable and unavoidable mistakes in child protection work.
  18. (1994). Back to the future: Social psychological research on groups.
  19. (1986). Becoming CriticaL
  20. (1999). Beliefs in child care: -Social work consensus and lack of consensus on issues of parenting and decision making.
  21. (1993). Beyond Blame, Child abuse tragedies revisited.
  22. (1993). Beyond Fiasco: A Reappraisal of the Groupthink Phenomenon and a New Model of Group Decision Processes.
  23. (1995). Care Consultancy Service
  24. (1980). Caringfor Seperated Children: Plans, Procedures and Priorities. A Report by a Working Party Established by the National Children's Bureau.
  25. (1989). Case study Research- Design and Methods.
  26. (1980). Child Abuse Central Register Systems,
  27. (1980). Child Abuse: Aspects of Interprofessional Cooperation.
  28. (1986). Child Abuse: risks and resources.
  29. (1985). Child abusive parents: an empirical review and analysis.
  30. (1997). Child Protection and Family Support, Current Debates and Future Prospects. In Parton,
  31. (1996). Child Protection Decision Making. Child Abuse Review.
  32. (1997). Child Protection, Risk and the Moral Order. London,
  33. (1991). Child protection: A training and resourcepack for work under the Children Act
  34. (1995). Child Protection: Messagesfrom Research.
  35. (1991). ChildAbuse: A Study of Inquiry Reports 1980-1989.
  36. (1990). Childhood antecedents of antisocial behaviour: parental alcoholism and physical abusiveness.
  37. (1984). Choices, values and frames.
  38. (1982). ClzildAbuse: A Study ofInquiry Reports 1973-1981.
  39. (1999). Common Errors of Reasoning
  40. (1969). Content Analysisfor the Social Sciences and Humanities.
  41. (1982). Contingent decision behaviour.
  42. (1989). Convention on the Rights of the Child. United Nations,
  43. (1992). Coordination and Child Protection: A Review of the Literature.
  44. (1989). Crucial Decisions: Leadership in policymaking and crisis management.
  45. (1991). Decision failures: why they occur and how to prevent them.
  46. (1996). Decision Making in Child Protection.
  47. (1999). Decision Making in Social Work.
  48. (1977). Decision Making: A Psychological analysis of conflict, choice and commitment.
  49. (1994). Decision risk in dynamic two stage contexts: Beyond the status quo.
  50. (1997). Degrees of Involvement: The Interaction of Focus and Commitment in Area Child Protection Committees.
  51. (1991). Department of Health, Department of Education and Science, Welsh Office. Working Together
  52. (1993). Deprivation and Child Abuse: implications for Strategic Planning in Children's Services. Children and Sociejy.
  53. (1989). Designing Qualitative Research.
  54. (1998). Developing consensus about groupthik after all these years. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  55. (1990). Developments to be expected in European social psychology in the 1990's. In
  56. (1970). Discussion effects on racial attitudes.
  57. (1988). Dynamics within and between groups.
  58. (1993). East meets West meets mideast: Further explorations of collectivistic and individualistic work groups.
  59. (1994). Escalation of commitment and the framing effect: An empirical investigation.
  60. (1994). Evaluating Child Protection. Milton Keynes,
  61. (1992). Feminist Research in Social Research.
  62. (1995). Framing of Decisions Under Ambiguity.
  63. (1994). GainALoss Asymmetry in Risky Intertemporal Choice. Organisation Behaviour and Human Performance.
  64. (1993). Going Home, the Return of Children Separated from Their Families.
  65. (1996). Good Practice in Risk Assessment and Risk Management-
  66. (1987). Group decision making and non-native versus information influences: Effects of type of issue and assigned decision rule.
  67. (1998). Group Dynamics in top management teams: Groupthink, vigilance, and alternative models of organisational. failure and success. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  68. (1962). Group influence on individual risk taking.
  69. (1992). Group process, group decision, group action.
  70. (1992). Group Risk Taking: Selected Topics. In
  71. (1982). Groupthink (2nd ed).
  72. (1989). Groupthink reconsidered.
  73. (1980). Groupthink: A critique of Janis'theory. In
  74. (1997). Groupthink: A triple fiasco in social psychology.
  75. (1997). Groupthink: An examination of theoretical issues, implications and future research suggestions.
  76. (1996). Handbook of Qualitative Research for Psychology and Methods in Social Sciences.
  77. (2000). in press. Women and Social Work., Narrative Approaches.
  78. (1984). In thefiel& an introduction tofield research London,
  79. (1995). Influencing Risk Preference in Decision Making: The Effects of Framing and Salience. Organisation Behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  80. (1995). Interagency Cooperation in Child Protection.
  81. (1996). Intergroup relations and group solidarity: Effects of group identification and social beliefs on depersonalised attraction. Joumal ofPersonality and Social Psychology.
  82. (1990). Judgement Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. Cambridge,
  83. (1980). Justice for Children.
  84. (1992). Making a case in child protection.
  85. (1996). Mapping European social psychology: Co-word analysis of the communications at the 10th general meeting of the EAESP.
  86. (1989). Meaning construction and social work practice.
  87. (1996). Men's Resistance to Social Workers.
  88. (1999). Mothering and the Child Protection System. in The Violence Against Children Study Group. Children, Child Abuse and Child Protection- Placing Children Centrally.
  89. (1994). Motivation in Work Teams: A qualitative and quantitative exploration of the construct of collective efficacy.
  90. (1985). Naturalistic Inquiry.
  91. (1998). Neglected Children: issues and dilemmas.
  92. (1993). New Strategies in Social Research. Cambridge,
  93. (1974). Non Accidental Injury to Children,
  94. (2000). Office, Department for Education and Employment
  95. (1995). Operating the Child Protection System.
  96. (1998). Organisational Tonypandy: Lessons from a quarter century of groupthink phenomenon. Organisational behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  97. (1997). Original and Cumulative Prospect Theory: A Discussion of Empirical Differences.
  98. (1995). Parental Perspectives in Cases ofSuspected Child Abuse.
  99. (1995). Paternalism or Partnership? Family involvement in the child protection process. London,
  100. (1997). Perceived threat, cohesion and group problem solving in inter group conflict.
  101. (1995). Personality, situation and positive-negative assymetry in socially desirable responding.
  102. (1998). Placing Children on Child Protection Registers: Risk Indicators and Local Authority Differences.
  103. (1982). Polarising effects of social interaction.
  104. (1990). Practice wisdom: the neglected source of practice research.
  105. (1977). Predicting child abuse: signs of bonding failure in the maternity hospital.
  106. (1993). Predicting the rate of children on the child protection register. Research, Policy and Planning.
  107. (1979). Prospect Theory: an analysis of decisions under risk.
  108. (1998). Prospects for research in group processes and intergroup relations. Group processes and Intergroup Relations,
  109. (1988). Protecting Children: A Guidefor Social Workers undertaking a Comprehensive Assessment.
  110. (1992). Psychodynamic theory within the politics of social work theory.
  111. (1984). Qualitative data analysis, a sourcebook of new methods.
  112. (1995). Qualitative Interviewing - The Heart of Hearing Data.
  113. (1992). Qualitative research and psychological theorising. The Psychologist.
  114. (1963). Range Frequency Compromise in Judgement. Psychological Monographs. 77,92 Whole no.
  115. (1986). Rational Choice and the Framing of Decisions.
  116. (1976). Reaffirmation of social comparison views of choice shifts: Averaging and extremity effects in an autokinetic situation.
  117. (1993). Real World Research.
  118. (1998). Recasting Janis's Groupthink Model: The Key Role of Collective Efficacy in Decision Fiascoes. Organisation Behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  119. (1992). Reference Points, Anchors, Norms and Mixed Feelings. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  120. (1987). Reflection of Transitive and Intransitive Preferences: A Test of Prospect Tbcory. Organisation Behaviour and Human Performance.
  121. (1980). Report into the Death of Claire Haddon.
  122. (1968). Report of the Committee on Local Authority and Allied Personal Social Services, Cmnd 3703.
  123. (1975). Report of the conunittee Inquiry into thefamily ofJohn George Auckland.
  124. (1996). Report of the National Commission ofInquiry into the Prevention of ChildAbuse. Volume two, background papers. London, The Stationary Office.
  125. (1974). Report ofthe committee of Inquiry into the care and supervision in relation to Afaria Cobvell.
  126. (1982). Research and publication trends in experimental social psychology: 1971-1980 -A thematic analysis of the
  127. (1993). Researching Sensitive Topics.
  128. (1994). Risk and Responsibility.
  129. (1996). Risk Assessment in Child Protection Work.
  130. (1990). Risk Assessment: the emporer's new clothes? Child Welfare,
  131. (1987). Risk Cognition. In
  132. (1979). Risk factors associated with child abuse. Child abuse and neglect,
  133. (1992). Risk Management: Basic concepts and general principles. In
  134. (1985). Risk, Moral Value ofActions and Mood.
  135. (1968). Risky and cautious shifts in group decisions: the influence of widely held values.
  136. (1996). Search for an Indicator of Effective Child Protection in a Reanalysis of Child Homicide in the Ma or Western Countries 1973-1992: A Response to Lindsey and j Trocme and Macdonald.
  137. (1988). Secretary of State for Social Services
  138. (1993). Services Inspectorate
  139. (1982). Social combination models, persuasive arguments theory, social comparison theory and choice shift.
  140. (1994). Social Focus on Children.
  141. (1986). Social Psychology (2nd ed).
  142. (1984). Social Services Committee (HC360)
  143. (1996). Social Theory, social change and social work.
  144. (1988). Social Work and the legacy of Freud.
  145. (1986). Social Work as Art.
  146. (1977). Sociological Research methods- an introduction-
  147. (1962). Some methodological problems of field studies.
  148. (1989). Some problems about predicting child abuse and neglect.
  149. (1988). Status Quo Bias in Decision Making.
  150. (1992). Stress, affect and risk taking. In
  151. (1994). Study of Working Together 'Part 8'Reports.
  152. (1985). Tacit Knowledge in social work research and practice.
  153. (1990). Taking Child Abuse Seriously in Taking Child Abuse Seriously, Violence Against Children Study Group. London, Unwin Hyman ltd.
  154. (1973). Testing two classes of theories about group induced shifts in individual choice.
  155. (1994). The Analysis of Company Documentation.
  156. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory.
  157. (1969). The group as a polarizer of attitudes.
  158. (1976). The group polarisation phenomenon.
  159. (1989). The nature of social influence in groupthink: Compliance and Internalisation.
  160. (1982). The Psychology of Preferences. Scientific American.
  161. (1987). The psychology of risk. In
  162. (1993). The Psychology ofJudgement and Decision Making.
  163. (1992). The Report of the Inquiry into the removal of children from Orkney in
  164. (1992). The Risk Construct.
  165. (1998). The tendency toward defective decision making within self managing teams. The relevance of groupthink for the 21 st century. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes.
  166. (1954). Thefoundations of statistics.
  167. (1992). Theory Elaboration: The Heuristics of Case Analysis.
  168. (1978). Thick Description: Toward an Interpretive Theory of Culture. In Gecrtz, C. The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays.
  169. (1970). Three Dilemmas in Action Research. Human Relations.
  170. (1996). Toward a process theory of groupthink.
  171. (1980). Translation of gambles and aspiration level effects in risky choice behaviour.
  172. (1972). Victims of Groupthink.
  173. (1974). Whatever happened to the group in social psychology?
  174. (1995). Which Children are Protected at Case Conferences?
  175. (1985). Whose child? The report of the panel appointed to Inquire into the death of Tyra Henry.
  176. (1996). Why some Conferences are Difficult: a Study of the Professionals' Experience of Some Initial Child Protection Conferences. Children and Society.
  177. (1999). Working in Partnership in Child Protection: The Conflicts.
  178. (1998). Working Together to Protect Children on the Child Protection Register: Myth or Reality.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.