Location of Repository

The problems of offenders with mental disorders: A plurality of perspectives within a single mental health care organisation

By Jacqueline Davies, Bob Heyman, Paul Godin, M. Shaw and L. Reynolds


Managers, doctors, nurses, occupational therapists, social workers, psychologists, unqualified staff and service users were interviewed for a qualitative study of risk management and rehabilitation in an inner city medium secure forensic mental health care unit. Different professional orientations to service user problems were identified. Doctors focused primarily on the diagnosis of mental disorder, which they managed mainly through pharmaceutical interventions. Psychologists were principally concerned with personal factors, for example service user insight into their biographical history. Occupational therapists concentrated mainly on daily living skills, and social workers on post-discharge living arrangements. Some front line nurses, held accountable for security lapses, adopted a criminogenic approach. Service users were more likely than professionals to understand their needs in terms of their wider life circumstances. These differences are explored qualitatively in relation to four models of crossdisciplinary relationships: monoprofessional self-organisation combined with restricted communication; hermeneutic reaching out to other perspectives; the establishment of interdisciplinary sub-systems; and transdisciplinary merger. Relationships between professions working in this unit, as portrayed in qualitative interviews, corresponded mainly to the first model of monoprofessional self-organisation. Reasons for restricted crossdisciplinary understanding, particularly the wide power/status differences between the medical and other professions, and between staff and patients, are discussed

Topics: RC0321, HD61, RA
Publisher: Elsevier
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.hud.ac.uk:6401

Suggested articles



  1. (2003). A Sociological Theory of Communication: The SelfOrganization of the Knowledge-based Society.
  2. (1961). Asylums: Essays on the social situation of mental patients and other inmates. doi
  3. (1975). Better services for the mentally ill. Cmnd 6233.
  4. (1996). Covert participant observation in a secure forensic unit. doi
  5. (2004). Forensic mental health services as a health risk escalator: A case study of ideals and practice. In B. Heyman (Ed.) Special edition on Risk and Mental Health. doi
  6. (2000). Issues in implementing and evaluating a managed care home health care system for HIV/AIDS. doi
  7. (1986). Management of radiation hazards in hospitals: Professional rationalities in a single institution. doi
  8. (1989). Medical expansionism: Some implications for psychiatric nursing practice. doi
  9. (2004). Mental health problems, psychotropic drug technologies and risk. doi
  10. (1995). Offenders, deviants or patients? doi
  11. (2000). Out of the mouths of forensic nurses: a 'pathology of the monstrous' revisited. Mental Health Care and Learning Disabilities,
  12. (2002). Power and control: Forensic community mental health nurses’ perceptions of team-working, legal sanctions and compliance. doi
  13. (2005). Practitioners welcome review's aim to define mental health nurses' role.
  14. (2005). Professionals' perceptions of interprofessional working in community mental health teams. doi
  15. (2000). Psychiatric diagnosis under conditions of uncertainty: personality disorder, science and professional legitimacy. doi
  16. (1964). Psychiatric Ideologies and Institution. doi
  17. (2002). Research priorities in forensic mental health. doi
  18. (2004). Risk and liminality in mental health social work. doi
  19. (2002). Risk and Technological Culture: Towards a Sociology of Virulence. doi
  20. (2002). Risk escalators and the rehabilitation of offenders with learning disabilities. doi
  21. (2005). Roles of psychiatrists and other professionals in mental healthcare: Results of a formal group judgement method among mental health professionals. doi
  22. (1993). Social Being, 2nd Ed.
  23. (1998). Structure and meaning in multidisciplinary teamwork. doi
  24. (2005). Team types, perceived efficiency and team climate in Swedish cross-professional teamwork. doi
  25. (2002). The nursing role in out-patient child and adolescent mental health services. doi
  26. (1988). The system of professions: An essay on the division of expert labor. doi
  27. (1984). The Theory of Communicative Action, Volume One: Reason and the Rationalisation of Society.
  28. (2001). What am I doing here? Safety, certainty and expertise in a secure unit. The Association for Family Therapy and Systemic Practice, doi
  29. (2001). Working with a multidisciplinary team in secure psychiatric environments.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.