Location of Repository

Augmenting Competence: an investigation of\ud criteria which may enhance Podiatry Education

By Christopher Stuart Davies


In 2001, the Quality Assurance Agency (QAA), in consultation with the professional body for Podiatry in the U. K., the Society of Chiropodists and Podiatrists (SoCAP), issued a list of benchmark statements that could be\ud expected of new graduate podiatrists. This provided a list of threshold competences expected of students prior to achieving independent practitioner status. These statements are essentially outcomes based judgements based on\ud the students' performance. Evidence within the literature searches suggests that the achievement of competences alone is not enough on which to base such quality judgements and it would follow that the measurement of the quality of podiatry education is therefore incomplete.\ud This study sought to identify a complementary set of statements to supplement the QAA benchmark statement in the education of podiatrists. The pathway leaders of the schools of podiatry from the U. K., Australia, South Africa and\ud New Zealand were asked to cooperate in the formation of a set of criteria that they felt could be considered as being appropriate. This included the subject areas taken from the literature originating in medical education, namely the staff, the resources, the students themselves and the pathway as a whole, each\ud considered as key considerations. The outcome of these discussions served to form a more inclusive set of criteria that may be included to complete the quality circle of standards of podiatry education and hopefully these will be debated further at a later stage for consideration in tandem with the existing competence statements.\ud The study employed an action research methodology and the data was collected in cycles from the participants. Initially a request was made to the\ud professional body for details of any existing guidelines regarding such statements. This was followed using questionnaires, then semi-structured interviews involving the pathway leaders. A list of 32 criteria was distilled\ud from the two rounds of data collection. These were subjected to Likert scale attitude measures, to create the final list of 28 criteria that were agreed by all participants to influence the education of podiatrists. These criteria were sent to the professional body for further debate, to make them aware of a potential weakness in the measurement of the quality of education for podiatrists. It is hoped that further discussions will include all or some of these findings to supplement the existing benchmark initiatives. It\ud may or may not be considered to be appropriate at a later stage to widen the debate to include other groups such as the NHS managers (as employers) and the students (as consumers).\ud The initial feedback from the Director Of Education of SoCAP, the professional body in the UK was positive, in that the potential value of such data was recognised. The response interpreted that the data satisfied the need\ud for the collection of qualitative information, which could be used to balance and support the quantitative data, on which the QAA and professional body had determined the outcome- based benchmark statements

Topics: QP, L1
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.hud.ac.uk:7765

Suggested articles



  1. (1990). 1) completed an exercise to determine an agreed set of clinical
  2. 1) Mandatory Updating: a lifetime commitment. Nursing Times.
  3. (2002). 1) Social Identity: Social Representations and Identity Culture. doi
  4. (2001). A Handbookfor Action Research in Health
  5. (1970). A History of Chiropodial Education.
  6. (1993). A Teachers Guide to Classroom Research.
  7. (1981). A Teachers' Guide to Action Research. doi
  8. (1997). Action Research and the early years. doi
  9. (1996). Action Research- A Handbook for Practitioners. doi
  10. (2000). Action Research: a culturally acceptable path to professional learning for University teachers. doi
  11. (1997). Action Research: Comparison with the concepts of 'The Reflective Practitioner' and 'Quality Assurance' in I. Hughes (Ed) Action Research Electronic Reader,
  12. (1985). Action Science. San Francisco. doi
  13. (1983). Adult and Continuing Education: Theory and Practice. doi
  14. (1989). Adult Education as theory, practice and research: the captive triangle. doi
  15. (1999). Agenda for Change - Modernising the NHSpqy system -jointframework of principles and agreed statement on the wayforward.
  16. (2000). An Action Research Approach to Curriculum Development.
  17. (1993). An Evaluation of Courses of Education and Training which led to State Registration as a Chiropodist.
  18. (1996). An Introduction to Qualitative Interviews. Thousand Oaks, doi
  19. (2003). An Introduction to Quality Assurance in Health Care. doi
  20. (1992). Analysing Mandatory Continuing Education. Nursing Standard.
  21. (1963). Behavioural study of obedience.
  22. (2000). Beyond Competence: the challengefor educational management.
  23. (1996). Beyond Competence. The National Council for Vocational Qualifications Framework and the challenge to Higher Education in the new millennium.
  24. (1988). Beyond Competence. The National Councilfor Vocational Qualifications Framework and the challenge to Higher Education in the new millennium.
  25. (1997). Breaking through barriers.
  26. (2001). Can the computer provide the 'third dimension' in Podiatry Education? Presentation at the Association of Leaming Technologies Conference.
  27. (2001). cfm (accessed 04.07.03) College of Education. Florida Atlantic University http: //fau. edu/divdept/coe/sfcel/define. htm (accessed 12 th
  28. (1995). Changing Nursing and Nursing Change: a dialectical analysis of an action research project. doi
  29. (1994). Competence based management education and the needs of the learning organisation. Education and Training. doi
  30. (1994). Competence, Education and NVQs. - dissenting perspectives.
  31. (2001). Computerised se4flpeer support, learning and assessment of final year under graduates. Presentation at the Association of Learning Technologies Conference.
  32. (1965). Conditions of Knowledge.
  33. (1992). Continuing Education: the answer to education's needs in
  34. (1992). Creating A Good Social Order Through Action Research. doi
  35. (1999). Designing Courses for Further Education.
  36. (1992). Developing Professional Education.
  37. (1987). Educating the reflective practitioner. doi
  38. (1978). Education as Socio-practical field : The theory-practice question reformulated. doi
  39. (1979). Ethical dilemmas in Social Science Research. doi
  40. Ethical Issues in Behavioural Research. doi
  41. Experiences of reflective teaching. active learning in higher education. doi
  42. (1984). Experiential Learning - experience as the source of learning and development. doi
  43. (2000). htm (accessed 7 th
  44. (1990). Identifying the competences required by a state registered chiropodist: A DACUM Workshop.
  45. (1992). Improving Student Learning Project.
  46. (1990). in: - Pears Cyclopaedia.
  47. (2001). Joining the dots: Reconceptualising educational development.. active learning in higher education. 2: 1; 200 1. pp 64-Dagnall, doi
  48. (2000). Joint Quality Assurance Committee for Chiropody / Podiatry.
  49. (2001). Knowledge and Employability. Podiatry Now.
  50. (1993). Kurt Lewin and the Origins of Action Research. doi
  51. (1980). Learning for change: developing the teaching role of the ward sister. doi
  52. (1989). Learning ftom Experience: Principles and Practice In Action Research. Lewes. Falmer Press Zuber-Skerritt,
  53. (1995). Medical Education and Medical Reform. doi
  54. (1997). Medical Education in the United States and Canada.
  55. (1985). Medical Education; A comparative study. doi
  56. (2000). Meeting the Challenge. doi
  57. (2000). Mentoring, Preceptorship and Clinical Supervision. A guide to professional roles in clinical practice. 2e. doi
  58. (1997). National Vocational Qualification, Scottish Vocational Qualifications and Competence Based Education and Training: from de Ville to Beaumont. doi
  59. (1992). Newton Surviving Your Dissertation.
  60. (1988). Observation as a method of learning: a useful experience or a waste of time? doi
  61. (1998). On Becoming an Innovative Teacher. doi
  62. (1991). Outcomes; NVQs and the emerging model of education and training. doi
  63. (2000). Personal Communic ion
  64. (1999). Personal e-mail communication.
  65. (1991). pp 277-280 Fish and Purr
  66. (1999). Press Release :-I Oth September 1999. Fitness for Practice. UKCC Education Commission to review Nursing and Midwifery education. London. UKCC. Placements in Focus. Guidance for education in practice for health care professions.
  67. (1984). Professional Education.
  68. (1984). Professionalism: Occupation or Ideology? in S. Goodlad Education for Professionals.
  69. (1992). Quality Assurance in Podiatry. doi
  70. (1997). Questionnaire Design and Analysis.
  71. (2002). Real World Research. 2. e.
  72. (1990). Research and Evaluation. Police Federation.
  73. (1999). Shared Learning and Clinical Teamwork: new directions in educationfor multiprofessional practice.
  74. (1986). Speaking ofEthnography. doi
  75. (1997). Strategies for efficient and effective teaching in ambulatory care settings. doi
  76. (2003). Streamlining quality assurance in healthcare education.
  77. (1995). Students Facing Boundaries.
  78. (1992). Sustaining and Rewarding Clinical Teaching. doi
  79. (1998). Teaching and Learning in Practice Placements in
  80. (1993). Teaching as Learning: an action research approach. doi
  81. (1996). Teaching Students in Clinical Settings. Therapy doi
  82. (1996). Teaching Students in Clinical Settings. Therapy in Practice 37.
  83. (1999). Teachingfor Quality Learning at University -What the student does.
  84. (1993). The acceptable face of competence Management, Education and Develqpment. doi
  85. (1990). The Action Research reader. doi
  86. (2001). The critical incident method.
  87. (1989). the Development of Adult Continuing Education. (UDACE)
  88. (1996). The development of degree education in Podiatry in the U.
  89. (1979). The Ethnographic Interview. doi
  90. (1997). The Genesis ofAction Research hqp.
  91. The Learning Context within the Workplace: as perceived by apprentices and their workplace trainers. doi
  92. (1999). The making of middle managers: a study in the relationship between groupformation and learning in management training programmes. in P. James Rewriting narratives of self-reflexion from an Action Research study.
  93. (2000). The management NVQ: a critique of the myth of relevance. doi
  94. (1992). The Manual ofLearning Styles.
  95. (1982). The Meaning of Educational Change in C. Robson. Real World Research.
  96. (2000). The New Meaning ofEducational Change.
  97. (1983). the Physicians perfonnance. Evaluation and the Health Professions. doi
  98. (1969). The Practical Theorist: The life and works ofKurt Lewin.
  99. (1984). The principles and Practice of nurse 11 94 Finniston,
  100. (1993). The Process of Learning.
  101. (1998). The role of nurse educators in the development of reflective practitioners: a selective case study of the Australian doi
  102. (1998). The University ofLearning. Beyond quality and competence in Higher Education. doi
  103. (1987). Towards an epistemological basis for experiential learning in nurse education. doi
  104. (1997). Towards More Effective Open and Distance Learning. doi
  105. Treatise in Corns, Bunions, Disease of nails and the general management offeet. doi
  106. (2000). Turning the Contradictions of Competence: competency-based training and beyond. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.