Location of Repository

Measuring Performance in the Hospitality Industry:\ud An evaluation of the Balanced Scorecard approach in the UK’s Licensed Retail Sector

By Aidan M James


The research investigates the role of performance measurement within the hospitality industry and in particular, the UK’s licensed retail sector. The research aimed to: 1) Analyse what is meant by performance management and to establish its application and use in various types of business; 2) Explain the balanced scorecard approach to performance measurement and to assess its theoretical and business value; 3) Establish the methods of performance measurement utilised by licensed retailers and to evaluate the effectiveness of these methods; 4) Apply the balanced scorecard method in selected collaborating organisations and to compare its usefulness to more traditional methods of performance measurement; and 5) Make recommendations and evaluate how a balanced scorecard approach might improve performance management in the licensed house sector. \ud \ud \ud The research highlighted a shortage of hospitality-related research with the industry predominantly using financial performance measures. The balanced scorecard was therefore put forward as a solution as it measures both the financial and non-financial performance of an organisation. \ud \ud \ud The financial and non-financial performance measures used by financial analysts and pub companies were identified through questionnaire surveys and semi-structured interviews, the results of which demonstrate the licensed retail sector’s reliance on financial performance measures. Case studies were developed on a number of Managed and Leased/Tenanted pub companies (PubCo’s) which also demonstrated this reliance, although the Managed PubCo’s are beginning to embrace non-financial measures and two of the Managed PubCo’s had adopted the balanced scorecard approach. \ud \ud \ud The fast pace of consolidation which is evident within the UK’s licensed retail sector had impacted upon the research as three of the PubCo’s featured in the case studies had been acquired by competitors during the study. The PubCo’s sampled for the questionnaires also changed during the data collection process, mainly due to consolidation.\ud \ud \ud It was recommended that further research would be necessary to develop a balanced scorecard for the UK’s licensed retail sector. It was also suggested that further empirical research could be conducted within those PubCo’s identified as using the balanced scorecard, to determine the extent to which the balanced scorecard assists them in managing and improving both their financial and non-financial performance.\ud \ud \ud The author suggests that The Centre for Licensed Retailing at Nottingham Trent University might provide the resources to continue with the research with a need also to develop standardised definitions of the financial performance measures used by PubCo’s. This development would enable performance data to be compared across the sector whilst also removing the opportunities for data manipulation by PubCo’s which was identified during the research

Topics: HD28, Q1
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.hud.ac.uk:9058

Suggested articles



  1. (editor) [1996] Introduction to hospitality operations,
  2. [1984a] The evolution of management accounting, The Accounting Review,
  3. [1984b] Yesterday’s accounting undermines production,
  4. [1995/1996] De nye og de gamle ikkefinansielle nogletal,
  5. [1995a] Bass buys into pub brand war,
  6. [1996a] The balanced scorecard: Translating strategy into action,
  7. [1996b] Using the balanced scorecard as a strategic management system,
  8. [1996c] Linking the balanced scorecard to strategy,
  9. [1997a] Firms take the tenancy route,
  10. [1997b] Greenalls at the business bazaar,
  11. [1997c] Strategy showdown debate ends in draw,
  12. [1998a] Wizard casts spell on pub acquisition,
  13. [1998b] Lessees cautious after IPC sell-off, The Publican Newspaper, 23/02/1998, p.5. Burtonwood Brewery plc. [2002] Burtonwood Brewery plc: Annual report & accounts 2002, Burtonwood: Burtonwood Brewery plc.
  14. [2000a] Return of the tenant,
  15. [2000b] Growth of the retail brands set to end,
  16. [2001a] Leading change with the balanced scorecard,
  17. [2001b] The strategy-focused organization: How balanced markets,
  18. [2003b] New risks as private equity investors raise the bar in the contest for pubs, Financial Times,
  19. [2004b] Best of the brands,
  20. [2004c] Wizard in fund deal,
  21. [2004d] City Briefs,
  22. [2004e] City Briefs,
  23. [2006a] Performance measurement in the value chain: manufacturing V tourism,
  24. [2006a] Pub companies switch more units to leases,
  25. [2006a] Restaurants take AIM,
  26. [2006b] Goodbye to the small guy?
  27. (1955). [2006b] Independent pub numbers set to dip,
  28. [2006b] Performance measurement in tourism: A value chain model,
  29. (1990). [2006e] TGI Friday’s & Yo Sushi cook up deals,
  30. [2006f] Café Rouge float in doubt as possible buyers appear, The Times,
  31. [2006g] Coffee chain brews plan to percolate into China, The Times,
  32. [2007a] Whitbread plans to take budget hotel chain to Asia, The Times,
  33. [2007b] Big hitters line up for the chance to take on David Lloyd, The Times,
  34. [2007c] Tchenguiz may link with bidder eyeing David Lloyd, The Times,
  35. [2007d] Whitbread may up returns after revaluing assets, The Times,
  36. [2007e] Premier Travel Inn has no intention of yielding market lead, The Times,
  37. [2007f] Whitbread develops £150m taste for hot Indian market, The Times,
  38. [2007g] Next Generation expected to rebrand as David Lloyd Leisure after £925m deal, The Times,
  39. [2008a] About Beefeater, http://www.beefeater.co.uk/about/, Date accessed 23/04/2009.
  40. [2008b] Welcome to Taybarns – The ultimate eatery, http://taybarns.com/index.html, Date accessed 23/04/2009.
  41. (2004). A balancing act,
  42. (2002). A balancing act, Perform: Performance measurement in action,
  43. (2004). A critique of benchmarking & performance measurement,
  44. (2000). A framework for auditing and enhancing performance measurement systems,
  45. (1995). A helping hand,
  46. (1986). A primer on Critical Success Factors published in – The Rise of Managerial Computing: The best of the Center for Information Systems Research.
  47. (1981). A primer on Critical Success Factors, Working paper No.1220-81 at the Centre for Information Systems Research, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Alfred P. Sloan School of Management,
  48. (1998). A study of TQM implementation in Thailand,
  49. (1996). A survey and taxonomy of strategy-related performance measures for manufacturing,
  50. (2001). A week of running water & liquid assets,
  51. (1987). Accounting & management: a field study perspective,
  52. (2006). Admiral in good cheer as it buys pubs in £318m Enterprise deal, The Daily Telegraph,
  53. (1999). After the precipice: Sector update UK Publican. [2004a] Top of the ops,
  54. (2005). an empirical analysis of lead benchmarking and performance measurement,
  55. (1992). Basic marketing (3rd edition),
  56. (1996). Becoming a master manager: A contemporary framework,
  57. (2008). Benchmarking the benchmarking models,
  58. (1998). Benchmarking: Destination attractiveness & small hospitality business performance,
  59. (1994). Big boys join food war, Pub Food Business,
  60. (2000). BNFL admits struggle to hit targets,
  61. (1997). Brakspear plans £30m floatation,
  62. (2002). Brakspear to stop brewing beer,
  63. (2000). Branding in the UK public house sector,
  64. (1999). Bruce leads Honeypots,
  65. (2002). Building performance measurement systems with the balanced scorecard approach,
  66. (2003). Burtonwood Brewery plc: Annual report & accounts 2003, Burtonwood: Burtonwood Brewery plc.
  67. (2001). Business accounting for hospitality & tourism,
  68. (1984). case study”
  69. (2000). Change management: A guide to effective implementation (2nd edition),
  70. (1979). Chief executives define their own data needs,
  71. (1985). Control in business organisations, MA:
  72. (1999). Corporate strategy for hospitality (2nd edition),
  73. (1998). Cost and effect: Using integrated cost systems to drive profitability and performance,
  74. (1996). Costing techniques to support corporate strategy:
  75. (2002). Delivering excellence in health & social care,
  76. (1990). Designing performance measurement systems for just in time operations,
  77. (1997). Designing performance measures: A structured approach,
  78. (1998). Differentiating the British public house,
  79. (1979). Divisional performance measurement: Beyond an exclusive profit test,
  80. (1990). Do financial and non-financial measures have to agree?
  81. (1995). Evaluating a hotel GM’s performance: a case study in benchmarking,
  82. (1988). Exploring corporate strategy, Hemel Hempstead:
  83. (2008). Exploring corporate strategy: Text & cases,
  84. (2001). Features best suited to the BSC,
  85. (1996). Financial accounting: An introduction,
  86. (1993). Financial management for the hospitality industry, East Lansing – USA:
  87. (1999). Good company: The story of Scottish &
  88. (2006). Goodbye W&DB, hello Marston’s,
  89. (2003). Great believers in balance,
  90. (1996). Greene King to shed jobs,
  91. (1999). Guide to franchising
  92. (2001). Guide to money matters for hospitality managers,
  93. (1991). Handbook of research design and social measurement (5th edition),
  94. (2000). having trouble with your strategy? Then map it,
  95. (1997). Hospitality accounting (Fifth Edition),
  96. (1992). Hotels & motels: A guide to market analysis, investment analysis and valuations, Chicago: American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers.
  97. (2006). How to profit from the balanced scorecard,
  98. (2000). How to yield value – the Janus perspective,
  99. (1993). Implementing the Balanced Scorecard at FMC Corporation: An interview with
  100. (1998). Improving business performance: Are you measuring up?
  101. (2000). Improving the performance of hospitality firms,
  102. (1993). In search of quality improvement:
  103. (1992). Integrated performance measurement: Management accounting to support the new manufacturing realities,
  104. (1999). Is there life in the lease?,
  105. (2007). Jonathan Neame: REITs, pubcos & the tortoise & the hare,
  106. (1994). Knowledge goes to Hollywood,
  107. (2005). Lean solutions,
  108. (1997). Linking the balanced scorecard to strategy,
  109. (1998). Management control systems,
  110. (1964). Managerial breakthrough,
  111. (2003). Managing & measuring social enterprises,
  112. (1983). Managing organisational performance, Jossey Bass Incorporation.
  113. (1983). Measuring manufacturing performance: A new challenge for managerial accounting research,
  114. (1994). Measuring performance for business results,
  115. (1987). Measuring performance in an advanced manufacturing environment,
  116. (2007). Measuring the benefits of bespoke training: The balanced scorecard approach,
  117. (2006). Mid-market dining matures,
  118. (1992). Morland escapes Greene King coop, The Times,
  119. (2003). Motives, diffusion & utilisation of the balanced scorecard
  120. (1995). Moving into the pub trade,
  121. (1996). New directions for the licensed trade: A structural analysis,
  122. (2004). No nasty shocks, says Holbeck’s chief,
  123. (2003). On the profession of management: A Harvard Business Review book,
  124. (2001). Onward & upward,
  125. (1996). Opposite ends of the scale,
  126. (1999). Performance management: A framework for management control systems research,
  127. (2000). Performance measurement at Nordic companies,
  128. (2007). Performance measurement definitions,
  129. (2000). Performance measurement in the UK hotel
  130. (2005). Performance measurement system design,
  131. (1995). Performance measurement system design: A literature review & research agenda,
  132. (2000). Performance measurement system design: Developing & testing a process-based approach,
  133. (2003). Performance measurement tools: The Balanced Scorecard and the EFQM Excellence Model,
  134. (1991). Performance measurement: Implementing strategy, Management Accounting,
  135. (1998). Perspectives on performance measurement conflicts in service businesses,
  136. (1989). Pub grub,
  137. (2004). Punch Taverns tops up empire with 1,000 pubs,
  138. (1993). Putting the balanced scorecard to work,
  139. (1992). Questionnaire design, interviewing & attitude measurement,
  140. (1995). Ready for anything,
  141. (1993). Real World Research – A Resource for Social Scientists & Practioner Researchers,
  142. (2002). Real world research (2nd edition), United Kingdom:
  143. (1994). Research design: Qualitative & quantitative approaches,
  144. (2003). Rethinking performance measurement: Beyond the balanced scorecard,
  145. (2004). Robert Kaplan, The Times,
  146. (1993). S&N swoop on Chef &
  147. (2007). Smoking ban the catalyst as pub market diversifies,
  148. (1998). Supporting the Balanced Scorecard,
  149. (1971). Survey methods in social investigation,
  150. (2004). Thank you for taking the time to fill out the questionnaire. I would be very grateful if you could return the completed questionnaire for Monday
  151. (1992). The balanced scorecard – Measures that drive performance,
  152. (2002). The balanced scorecard assumptions & drivers of business growth,
  153. (1999). The balanced scorecard: A necessary good
  154. (2001). The balanced scorecard: An integrative approach to performance evaluation,
  155. (1999). The beer dilemma: High beer prices & little profit,
  156. (1990). The brewing industry: A guide to historical records,
  157. (1994). The British brewing industry 1830 –1980, Cambridge:
  158. (1996). The British pub: An industry in transition,
  159. (2004). The challenges of performance measurement,
  160. (1995). The changing face of the British pub,
  161. (1990). The core competence of the corporation,
  162. (1994). The dynamics of the international brewing industry since 1800,
  163. (1994). The future is in ‘superpubs’,
  164. (1997). The golden rules: Implementing the balanced business scorecard,
  165. (1992). The greatest brewery in the world: A history of Bass,
  166. (1991). The handbook of performance management,
  167. (1998). The implementation stages of activity-based costing & the impact of contextual & organisational factors,
  168. (1994). The mergers & acquisitions handbook,
  169. (1999). The performance measurement revolution: Why now & what next?
  170. (2001). The performance prism in practice,
  171. (2001). The performance prism perspective,
  172. (2002). The performance prism: The scorecard for measuring & managing stakeholder relationships, London: Financial Times/Prentice
  173. (2001). The use of management accounting systems in hotels: an exploratory study,
  174. (2003). Time to invest, now the froth has blown off the beer trade,
  175. (1993). Total quality management process: A systematic approach,
  176. (1993). Total quality management: Text, cases & readings, Felray Beach – Florida:
  177. (1994). TQM’s challenge to management theory & practice,
  178. (2000). Using SPSS for Windows
  179. (2000). Whitbread focuses on leisure,
  180. (2006). Whitbread quits race for Esporta, The Times,
  181. (2007). Whitbread sticks to business,
  182. (1997). why does business need a balanced scorecard?
  183. (1995). Why tenancies are here to stay,
  184. (1997). Winning ways with a balanced scorecard,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.