Location of Repository

Procedural embodiment and magic in linear equations

By Rosana Nogueira de Lima and David Tall


How do students think about algebra? Here we consider a theoretical framework which builds from natural human functioning in terms of embodiment – perceiving the world, acting on it and reflecting on the effect of the actions – to shift to the use of symbolism to solve linear equations. In the main, the students involved in this study do not encapsulate algebraic expressions from process to object, they do not solve ‘evaluation equations’ such as by ‘undoing’ the operations on the left, they do not find such equations easier to solve than , and they do not use general principles of ‘do the same thing to both sides.’ Instead they build their own ways of working based on the embodied actions they perform on the symbols, mentally picking them up and moving them around, with the added ‘magic’ of rules such as ‘change sides, change signs.’ We consider the need for a theoretical framework that includes both embodiment and process-object encapsulation of symbolism and the need for communication of theoretical insights to address the practical problems of teachers and students. \u

Topics: QA, L1
Publisher: Springer Netherlands
Year: 2008
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:479

Suggested articles



  1. 2004b, Thinking through three worlds of mathematics,
  2. (1990). Algebra Mal-Rules and Cognitive Accounts of Error, doi
  3. (1984). An attempt to understand students' understanding of basic algebra, doi
  4. (1981). Concepts associated with the equality symbol, doi
  5. (1994). Duality, Ambiguity and Flexibility: A Proceptual View of Simple Arithmetic, doi
  6. (2002). Embodied action, effect, and symbol in mathematical growth.
  7. (2002). Equação do primeiro grau: métodos de resolução e análise de erros no ensino médio. Master’s Dissertation. São Paulo:
  8. (2004). Explicating a Mechanism for Conceptual Learning: Elaborating the Construct of Reflective Abstraction. doi
  9. O.: 2004a, The three worlds of mathematics, doi
  10. (1997). Persistent errors in indices: a cognitive perspective.
  11. (1991). Reflective abstraction in advanced mathematical thinking. In doi
  12. (1998). Secretaria de Educação Fundamental: doi
  13. (1998). Simplifying algebraic expressions: teacher awareness and teaching approaches,
  14. (2000). Solving equations and inequations: operational invariants and methods constructed by students.
  15. (1989). Solving equations, the transition from arithmetic to algebra,
  16. (2002). The balance model: hindrance or support for the solving of linear equations with one unknown,
  17. (2006). The concept of equations: What have students met before?
  18. (2001). The long-term cognitive development of symbolic algebra,
  19. (2003). The Relationship between Physical Embodiment and Mathematical Symbolism: The Concept of Vector.
  20. (1997). Theory of Didactical Situations in Mathematics. doi
  21. (2000). Where Mathematics Comes From. doi
  22. (1987). Women, Fire and Dangerous Things, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.