Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

A sensitivity analysis of the prediction of the nitrogen fertilizer requirement of cauliflower crops using the HRI WELL_N computer model

By C. (Clive) Rahn, A. (Andrew) Mead, A. Philip (Arthur Philip) Draycott, Robert Lillywhite and T. Salo


HRI WELL_N is an easy to use computer model, which has been used by farmers and growers since 1994 to predict crop nitrogen (N) requirements for a wide range of agricultural and horticultural crops.\ud \ud A sensitivity analysis was carried out to investigate the model predictions of the N fertilizer requirement of cauliflower crops, and, at that rate, the yield achieved, yield response to the fertilizer applied, N uptake, NO3-N leaching below 30 and 90 cm and mineral N at harvest. The sensitivity to four input factors – soil mineral N before planting, mineralization rate of soil organic matter, expected yield and duration of growth – was assessed. Values of these were chosen to cover ranges between 40% and 160% of values typical for field crops of cauliflowers grown in East Anglia. The assessments were made for three soils – sand, sandy loam and silt – and three rainfall scenarios – an average year and years with 144% or 56% of average rainfall during the growing season. The sensitivity of each output variable to each of the input factors (and interactions between them) was assessed using a unique ‘sequential' analysis of variance approach developed as part of this research project.\ud \ud The most significant factors affecting N fertilizer requirement across all soil types/rainfall amounts were soil mineral N before planting and expected yield. N requirement increased with increasing yield expectation, and decreased with increasing amounts of soil mineral N before planting. The responses to soil mineral N were much greater when higher yields were expected. Retention of N in the rooting zone was predicted to be poor on light soils in the wettest conditions suggesting that to maximize N use, plants needed to grow rapidly and have reasonable yield potential.\ud \ud Assessment of the potential impacts of errors in the values of the input factors indicated that poor estimation of, in particular, yield expectation and soil mineral N before planting could lead to either yield loss or an increased level of potentially leachable soil mineral N at harvest.\ud \ud The research demonstrates the benefits of using computer simulation models to quantify the main factors for which information is needed in order to provide robust N fertilizer recommendations

Topics: SB
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Year: 2001
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1979). A comparison of three methods for selecting values of input variables in the analysis of output from a computer code. doi
  2. (1987). A dynamic model to predict yield and optimum nitrogen fertiliser application rate for potatoes. Paper read before the Fertiliser
  3. (1988). Current recommendations for nitrogen fertilisation within the EEC in relation to nitrate leaching.
  4. Freeman &C o . doi
  5. (1993). Measurement of soil mineral nitrogen to predict the response of winter wheat to fertiliser nitrogen after application of organic manures or afterploughed – out grass.Journal ofAgricultural Science, doi
  6. (1993). N requirements of cabbage crops grown in contrasting soils. I: Field trials.
  7. (1994). N requirements of cabbage crops grown on contrasting soils in southern Norway. II. Model predictions.
  8. Prediction of nitrogen fertiliser requirement with HRI WELLN Computer Model.
  9. (1995). Rational nitrogen fertilization in intensive cropping systems. doi
  10. (1997). Recommendation systems for nitrogen – A review. Paper read before the Fertiliser
  11. (1981). Simulation model of the behaviour of N in soil.
  12. (1986). The deficiency of the ‘economic optimum’ application for evaluating models which predict crop yield response to nitrogen fertiliser. doi
  13. (2000). The effects of starter fertilizers on the growth and nitrogen use efficiency of onion and lettuce. doi
  14. (1996). The fate of nitrogen from brassica crop residues in intensive cropping rotations. In Nitrogen Supply and Nitrogen Fixation of Crops for Cool and Wet Climates.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.