Location of Repository

Social security and women in Malawi : a legal discourse on solidarity of care

By Ngeyi Ruth Kanyongolo

Abstract

Increasing levels of poverty and social exclusion in Africa, and Malawi in particular, have heightened interest in social security with varying proposals for refonn. Feminist scholarship highlights how women experience social security differently. However, debates on refonn have not fully engaged with how social security can reflect the needs of women in a context of plural and competing legal discourses, nonns and values. This thesis investigates the interplay between nonns and values and the lived realities of women in social security from a feminist and radical legal pluralist perspective. It uses predominantly qualitative data from a case study of women in Zomba, Malawi, based on grounded theory complemented by discourse analysis and appreciative inquiry. This study found that women's specific risks and the disproportionately adverse impact of general risks on women are in the majority of cases marginalised due to struggles for resources and power. Plural social responses at family, community, market and state levels reflect this marginalisation. Dominant legal discourses in these institutions devalue non - material disruptions of life mainly related to care practices. This weakens solidarity and results in social insecurity for the majority of women. The marginalisation is further reinforced by dominant conceptions of umunthu and human rights which obscure the disparities in solidarity and care. At the same time, there is practical resistance to the dominant discourse using idioms of jenda and substantive complementarity being generated within the same or modified regulatory institutions. These practices are creating a gap which IS precipitating the changes aspired by women. The changes include increased access to both material and non-material resources and sharing of care within and between the family, community, market and the state. This reflects solidarity of care. The thesis argues that, social security systems should be underpinned by a legal discourse of solidarity of care in order to improve women's social security

Topics: HV, K1
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1152

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (21004), Re -visioning "the social": towards a citizen Centred Social Policy for the Poor in Poor Countries,
  2. (2002). A Democracy of Chameleons: A Politics of Culture in the New Malawi Claim Mabuku, Malawi Emmanuel, Reynaud, doi
  3. (1993). Accessed on httj): //e prints. soton. ac. uk/ 163 401 Accessed on 9/1/06
  4. (1992). Critical Legal Theory. - The Power of Law,
  5. (2004). Discourse Analysis, in Hardy M and Byrman A (eds) Handbook of Data Analysis, Sage, London
  6. (2007). Economic marginal 1 sati on, Vulnerability Constitutional Law; doi
  7. (1998). Explanations of Social Exclusion: Where does Housing Fit In'. doi
  8. (2004). Formulating an Integrated Social Security Response- Perspectives on Developing Links Between Infon-nal and Formal Social Security in the SADC Region
  9. (1999). Imagining Women's Legal World: Towards a Feminist Theory of Legal Pluralism in Affica;
  10. (1985). Law Custom and Social Order: The Colonial Experience in doi
  11. (1975). Legal Pluralism: An Introduction to Colonial and Neo-colonial Law, doi
  12. (1973). Malawi: History of a Nation Longman, doi
  13. (1999). Qualitative Evaluation doi
  14. (2000). Social Protection, Labour Markets and Poor
  15. (2003). Social Security in Africa: Inherited Burdens, Future Priorities, International Social Security Review Vol. doi
  16. (1993). Social Security in Developing Countries: Basic Trends and Fields of State Intervention; doi
  17. (1999). Social Security Law, General Principles,
  18. (1998). Social Welfare and Social Value, Macmillan Press Ltd, London Human Development Report,
  19. (2006). Taking Law to the People, Gender, Law reforin and Community legal education in Zimbabwe; North - South Legal Perspectives Series No. 3 Weaver Press, Women's Law Centre, University of Zimbabwe Tsoka
  20. (1982). The Public - Private Dichotomy: Theoretical Perspectives in Women in Development:
  21. (2005). Theory and Method
  22. (2001). Women, Gender and Work: What is Equality and How did we get there? doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.