Location of Repository

Portfolio risk measurement: the estimation of the covariance of stock returns

By Lan Liu


A covariance matrix of asset returns plays an important role in modern portfolio analysis and risk management. Despite the recent interests in improving the estimation of a return covariance matrix, there remain many areas for further investigation. This thesis studies several issues related to obtaining a better estimation of the covariance matrix for the returns of a reasonably large number of stocks for portfolio risk management. \ud The thesis consists of five essays. The first essay, Chapter 3, provides a comprehensive analysis of both old and new covariance estimation methods and the standard comparison criteria. We use empirical data to compare their performances. We also examine the standard comparisons and find they provide limited information regarding the abilities of the covariance estimators in predicting portfolio variances. It therefore suggests that we need more powerful comparison criteria to assess covariance estimators.\ud The second and third essays, Chapter 4 and 5, are concerned with the alternative appraisal methods of return covariance estimators for portfolio risk management purposes. Chapter 4 introduces a portfolio distance measure based on eigen decomposition (eigen-distance) to compare two covariance estimators in terms of the most different portfolio variances they predict. The eigen-distance measures the ratio of the two extreme variance predictions under one covariance estimator for the portfolios that are constructed to have the same variances under the other covariance estimator. We show that the eigen-distance can be used to assess a risk measurement system as a whole, where any kind of the portfolios may need to be considered. Our simulation results show that it is a powerful measure to distinguish two covariance estimators even in small samples.\ud Chapter 5 proposes a0 measure to distinguish two similar estimated covariance matrices from the observed covariance matrix. 0 is constructed based on the essential difference of the two similar covariance matrices: the two extreme portfolios that are predicted to have the most different variances under these two matrices. We show that 0 is very useful in evaluating refinements to covariance estimators, particularly a modest refinement, where the refined covariance matrix is close to the original matrix.\ud The last two essays, Chapter 6 and 7, are concerned with improving the best covariance estimators within the literature. Chapter 6 explores alternative Bayesian shrinkage methods that directly shrink the eigenvalues (and in one case the principal eigenvector) of the sample covariance matrix. We use simulations to compare the performance of these shrinkage estimators with the two best existing estimators, namely, the Ledoit and Wolf (2003a) estimator and the Jagannathan and Ma (2003) estimator using both RMSE and eigen-distance criteria. We find that our shrinkage estimators consistently out-perform the Ledoit and Wolf estimator. They also out-perform the Jagannathan and Ma estimator except in one case where they are not much worse off either.\ud Finally, Chapter 7 extends the analysis of Chapter 6, which is under an unchanging multivariate normal world, to consider implications of both fat-tails and time variation. We use a multivariate normal inverse Gaussian (MNIG) distribution to model the log returns of stock prices. This family of distributions has proven to fit the heavy tails observed in financial time series extremely well. For the time varying situation, we use a tractable mean reverting Ornstein- Uhlenbeck (OU) process to develop a new model to measure an interesting and economically motivated time varying structure where the risks remain unchanged but stocks migrate among different risk categories during their life circles. We find that our shrinkage methods are also useful in both situations and become even more important in the time varying case

Topics: HG, HA
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1154

Suggested articles



  1. A capital asset pricing model with time varying covariances. doi
  2. A multi dynamic factor model for stock returns. doi
  3. A note on using cross-section information in beyeslaii estimation of security betas. doi
  4. A quasi-monte carlo algorithm for the normal inverse gaussian distribution and valuation of financial derivatives. doi
  5. A random matrix approach to cross- correlation in financial data. epritil condmat 0108023,2001.
  6. A shrinkage approach to large-scale covariance matrix estimation and implications for functional genomics. doi
  7. A simplified model for portfolio analysis. doi
  8. A test for the number of factors in an approximate factor model. doi
  9. (1991). A user's guide to principal component. Wiley - Interscience, doi
  10. A well- conditioned estimator for large-dimensional covariance matrices. doi
  11. An analysis of covariance risk and pricing anomalies. doi
  12. An empirical evaluation of alternative portfoliosection models. doi
  13. Application of random matrix theory to study cross- correlations of stock prices. doi
  14. Are betas best? doi
  15. Assessing the risk in sample minimum risk portfolios. NBER working paper No. doi
  16. Beta and their regression tendencies. doi
  17. Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds. doi
  18. (1987). Developments in eigenvalue estimation. doi
  19. (1972). Distributions Zn statistics: Continuous multivariate distributions. doi
  20. Empirical bayes estimation of the multivariate normal covariance matrix. doi
  21. Estimated correlation matrices and portfolio optimization. PhysZca A: Statistical mechanics and its applications, doi
  22. Estimating the correlation structure of international share prices. doi
  23. (2005). Estimating the covariance matrix for portfolio optimization. Working paper, doi
  24. Estimating the dependence structure of share prices - implications for portfolio selection. doi
  25. Estimation of a covariance matrix under stein's loss. doi
  26. Estimation of a covariance matrix using the reference prior. doi
  27. (1975). Estimation of a covariance matrix. Rietz Lecture.,
  28. (1961). Estimation with quadratic loss. doi
  29. Extra-market components of covariance in security returns. doi
  30. Flexible multivariate garch modelling with an application to international stock markets. doi
  31. Forecasting the correlation structure of share prices: a test of new models. doi
  32. (1996). Forecasting the covariance structure of UK stock returns: test of a new model.
  33. Have individual stocks become more volatile? an empirical exploration of idiosyncratic risk. doi
  34. Honey i shrunk the sample covariance matrix. doi
  35. Hyperbolic distributions in finance. doi
  36. Improved estimation of the covariance matrix of stock returns with an application to portfolio selection. doi
  37. Interest rate sensitivity in the common stocks of financial intermediaries: a methodological note. doi
  38. lmproved estimates of correlation coefficients and their impact on the optimum portfolios. doi
  39. (1968). Metric spaces. doi
  40. Modeling asymmetric comovements of asset returns. doi
  41. (2007). Modern portfolio theory and investment analysZs. Wiley, 7th edition,
  42. Multivariate simultaneous generolized arch. doi
  43. Noisy covariance matrices and portfolio optimization ii. Phystca A: Statzstical mechanics and its applications, doi
  44. Non-gaussian ornstein-uhlenbeck based models and some of their uses in financial economics. doi
  45. Normal inverse gaussian distributions and stochastic volatility modelling. doi
  46. (2002). On portfolio selection: improved covariance matrix estimation for swedish asset returns. Working paper,
  47. On the assessment of risk. doi
  48. On the short-term stationarity of beta coefficients. doi
  49. (2005). Optimal versus naive diversification: How inefficient is the I/n portfolio strategy? Review of Financial Studies, doi
  50. Portfolio selection. doi
  51. (1971). Principles of Econometrics. doi
  52. Random matrix theory and financial correlations. doi
  53. Risk reduction in large portfolios: why imposing the wrong constrains helps. doi
  54. (1996). RiskMetrics - technical document. Morgan Guaranty Rust Company of
  55. Sensitivity analysis for mean-variance portfolio problems. doi
  56. Shrinkage estimators for covariance matrices. doi
  57. The 'efficient index' and prediction of portfolio variance. doi
  58. The adjustment of beta forecasts. doi
  59. The conditional capm and the cross-section of expected returns. doi
  60. The m2-compeition: a real time judgementally based forecasting study. doi
  61. The m3-compeition: results, conclusions and implications. doi
  62. The markowitz optimization enigma: Is 'optimized' optimal? doi
  63. (2004). The multivariate normal inverse gaussian. distributionl em-estimation and analysis of synthetic aperture sonar data. Working paper,
  64. The normal inverse gaussian levy process: simulation and approximation. doi
  65. The scree test for the number of factors. doi
  66. The three types of factor models: a comparison of their explanatory power. doi
  67. The variation of economic risk premium. doi
  68. The variational form of certain bayes estimators. doi
  69. ýhlrket and industry factors in stock price behavior.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.