Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Foucault and Arendt: the tensions and integrity of critical thinking

By Chungmin Kang

Abstract

In this work, I present an interpretation of two thinkers, Foucault and Arendt. I place these thinkers within a tradition of critical theory running from Kant to Nietzsche. The opposition between modernism and postmodernism, between its philosophical sources, Kant and Nietzsche, has been widely overstated, for example, in the polemical stance taken by Habermas in The Philosophical Discourse ofModenfity (1987). 1 am concerned to show that this way of mapping does Foucault and Arendt an injustice. Foucault and Arendt accept Nietzsche's critique of reason and Western thought and attack Kant's official philosophy, an analytical philosophy of truth. Yet they also appropriate Kant's reflection on the Enlightenment and revolution (Foucault) and his aesthetic judgment (Arendt). More importantly, Foucault and Arendt embrace postmodern sensibility not as an absolute given but as an attitude that must be - at the risk of inviting Nietzschean scorn - constantly checked and examined. For them, critique is based as much on a serious and sustained interrogation of historical experience as it is on a deconstruction of metaphysical philosophy. Recognizing the problems of attaching labels to Foucault's work and that of Arendt, I focus on the tensions and complexity of their work. There are tensions in Foucault's thought between totalizing/detotalizing impulses, discursive/extra-discursive theorization, macro/micro perspectives, and domination/resistance relations as well as between ethical-political commitments and archaeological detachment. There are also tensions in Arendt's thought between creative rupture and exercise in retrieval, between agonism and consensus as well as between existential engagement and philosophical withdrawal. Critical thought, which is experiment as well as problematization, must constantly live within a field of tension. In this light, I argue that these tensions provide the elements for the uniqueness and coherence of their work and that viewing these tensions as a source of flagrant contradiction fundamentally distorts their intentions

Topics: B1
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1190

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1988a) 'The Ethic of Care for the Self as a Practice of Freedom',
  2. (I 972a; orig. 1969) The Archaeology ofKnowledge,
  3. 1) Selectionsfivin the Prison Notebooks, London: LaNvrcncc and
  4. (1995). A Kant Dictionary, doi
  5. (2003). A Portrait ofthe Artist as a Young Alan,
  6. (1989). Acting and Thinking: The Political Thought of Hannah Arendt, doi
  7. (1980). Afterword' doi
  8. (1970). An Answer to the Question: What is EnlightenmentT,
  9. (1984). and 1987) Theory of Communicative Action, vols. I and 2, doi
  10. (1993). Arcndt's account of Action and Authority',
  11. (1987). Arendt and Heidegger: The Episodic Intertwining of Life and Work, doi
  12. (1992). Arendt, Camus, andModern Rebellion,
  13. (1989). Art ofJudgment,
  14. (2000). Basic Mritings of Nietzsche, doi
  15. (1956). Being and Nothingness, doi
  16. (1962). Being and Time,
  17. (1974). Between Existentialism andAfarxism,
  18. (1968). Between Past and Future,
  19. (1984). Beyond Objectivism and Relativism, Philadelpl-da: doi
  20. (2002). Change the World Without Taking Power, doi
  21. (1990). Communists Like Us,
  22. (1976). Considerations on ffestern Marxism, London: Ncw Left Books. Arendt H.
  23. (1992). Correspondence 1926-1969,
  24. (1972). Crises of the Republic,
  25. (1994). Critique and Power, Cambridge: ne
  26. (1952). Critique ofJudgment,
  27. (1987). Critique, Norm, and Utopia, doi
  28. (1989). Cross-Purposes: The Liberal Communitarian. Debate", doi
  29. (1996). Democracy and Difference, doi
  30. (1984). Democracy and the Rule ofLaw,
  31. (1996). Democracy, power, and the Political', doi
  32. (1972). Dialectic ofEnlightenment,
  33. (1984). Dialectic ofNihilism,
  34. (2000). Editor's Introduction',
  35. (1965). Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil, doi
  36. (1962). Erotism,
  37. (1994). Essays in Understanding, doi
  38. (1948). Existentialism and Humanism, doi
  39. (1994). Explainirig Dark Times; Hannah Arendt's Theory of Theory',
  40. (1969). For Marx, Harmondsworth:
  41. (1983). Foucaull-Alarxism and Critique,
  42. (1986). Foucault and Epistcmology',
  43. (1986). Foucault and the Imagination of Power',
  44. (1988). Foucault as Paffhesiast',
  45. (1986). Foucault on Freedom and Truth', doi
  46. (1984). Foucault, Marxism and History, doi
  47. (1986). Foucault: A Critical Reader, doi
  48. (1986). Foucault's Aesthctic Decisionism', Telos, doi
  49. (1969). Four Essays on Liberty, doi
  50. (1996). Fugitivc Dcmocmcy',
  51. (1990). Gender Trouble, doi
  52. (1991). Govcnunentality,
  53. (1999). Governing the Soul, Sccond Edition,
  54. (1995). Hannah and the Magician', The New Republic,
  55. (1987). Hannah Arcndt on Kant, Truth and Politics',
  56. (1994). Hannah Arendt and the Limits ofphilosophy, doi
  57. (1994). Hannah Arendt and the Redemptive Power of Narrative',
  58. (1981). Hannah Arendt and the Search for a New Political Philosophy, doi
  59. (1997). Hannah Arendt on Judgment: The Unwritten Doctrine of Reason',
  60. (1992). Hannah Arendt: A Reinterpretation of Her Political Thought, Cambridge: doi
  61. (1994). Hannah Arendt: Democracy and the Political', doi
  62. (1976). Hannah Arendt: Hellenic Nostalgia and Industrial Society",
  63. (1983). Hannah Arendt: On the Concept of Power',
  64. (1984). Hannah Arendt: Politics, doi
  65. (1993). Hannah Arendt: Politics, History and Citizenship, doi
  66. (1979). Hannah Arendt: The Recovery of the Public Iforld,
  67. (1982). Hannah Arendt. - For Love of the T[brid,
  68. (1979). Hannah Arendt's Conception of Political Community', doi
  69. (1979). Hannah Arendt's Concepts of Labor
  70. (1985). Hannah Arendt's Critical Appropriation of Heidcggcr's Thought as Political Philosophy',
  71. (2001). Heidegger's Children, doi
  72. (1998). Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life, Stanford: doi
  73. (1991). Identityl Difference: Democratic Negotiations of Political Paradox, Ifliaca:
  74. (1960). Ideology and Utopia, doi
  75. (1999). Illuminations, doi
  76. (1984). IMe Procedural Republic and the Unencumbered Sclf',
  77. (1987). Interpretation andSocial Criticism,
  78. (1982). Interpretative Essay',
  79. (1982). Is there a Futureforkfarxism?,
  80. (1986). Judging - The Actor and the Spectator',
  81. (1992). Judgment and the Moral Foundations of Politics
  82. (1985). Just Gaming, Mnncapolis:
  83. (1994). Justicc: On Relating Public and Pxivate',
  84. (1993). Kant on Enlightenment and Revolution', doi
  85. (1982). Lectures on Kant's Political Philosophy, doi
  86. (1987). Legislators and Interpreters, doi
  87. (1998). Lessons in Paganism',
  88. (1982). Liberalism and the Limits ofJustice,
  89. (1987). Logics ofDisintegration,
  90. (1978). Martin Heidegger at eighW',
  91. (1994). Mchel Foucault: The Edfics of an Intcllcctual',
  92. (1996). Miat is Enlightenment?,
  93. (1994). Michcl Foucault: A "Young Conscrvativc"? ',
  94. (1985). Michel Foucault The Freedom of Philosophy,
  95. (1988). Michel Foucault: Politics, doi
  96. (1989). Michel Foucault's archaeoloSy of scientific reason, Cambridge: doi
  97. (1988). Michel Foucault's Ecstatic Thinking', doi
  98. (1992). Models of Public Space'
  99. (1979). Modern French Philosophy, Cambridge:
  100. (1973). Negative Dialectics, doi
  101. (1983). Nietzsche and Philosophy, doi
  102. (1977). Nt (1977b) 'Prcfacc',
  103. (1979). On Hannah Arcndt', in Hill, U (cd. ) 11annah Arendt: The Recovery of the Public World,
  104. (1989). On Liberty and Other RMings, Cambridge:
  105. (1963). On Revolution,
  106. (1983). On the Genealogy of Ethics', doi
  107. (1989). On the GenealoSy ofAforals, IH,
  108. (1970). On Violence,
  109. (1992). orig.
  110. (1975). orig. 1843-4) 'A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right. Introduction', in Early ffritings, doi
  111. (1975). orig. 1845) 'Concenfing Feuerbach', in Early Tfritings,
  112. (1970). orig. 1859) A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, doi
  113. (1975). orig. 1963) The Birth ofthe Clinic,
  114. (1994). orig. 1966) The Order of Things,
  115. (1979). Other InqWsitions', Ideology and Consciousness,
  116. (1977). Outline ofa Theory ofPractice, Cambridge:
  117. (1990). Philosophy and Politics', doi
  118. (1999). PofilicsĂ˝ Philosophy, Terror, Princcton: Princoon Univusity Prcss.
  119. (1983). Political Judgment,
  120. (1974). Political Thought ofHannah Arendt, doi
  121. (1993). Political TVritings,
  122. (1992). Postmodernisin and Public Sphere',
  123. (1998). Practical Reason,
  124. (1985). Prophets ofExtremity, Bcrkely and Los Angeles:
  125. (1997). Rahel Varnhagen: The Life of a Jewess, doi
  126. (1979). Reading Capital Politically, doi
  127. (1998). Reflective Authenticity. Rethinking the Project of Modernity, doi
  128. (1994). Representations ofthe Intellectual,
  129. (1992). Rethinking the Public Sphere', doi
  130. (1962). Review of Hannah Arendt, Between Past and Future', doi
  131. (1990). Schopenhauer as Educator',
  132. (1972). Scicnce as a Vocation', in From Max TPber,
  133. (1994). SociologyofHodernity. -
  134. (1979). Stiuggle against Discipline',
  135. (1984). Strong Democracy, doi
  136. (1986). Taking Aim at the Heart of the Present',
  137. (1981). Teachers, Writers, Celebrities: The Intellectuals of Modern France, doi
  138. (1988). Technologies of the Sclf, in
  139. (1979). The Abyss of Freedom - and Hannah Arendt',
  140. (1965). The Concept of Irony with Constant Reference to Socrates, doi
  141. (1970). The Contest of Faculties',
  142. (1978). The Contradiction of Hannah Arendt's Political Thought', doi
  143. (1972). The Discourse on Language', doi
  144. (1995). The Ethos ofPluralization, London:
  145. (1987). The Faith of Hannah Arendt',
  146. (1991). The Foucault Effect': Studies in Governmentality, Cl-dcago: The Univcrsity of CWcago Prcss.
  147. (1984). The Foucault Reader, doi
  148. (1958). The Human Condition,
  149. (1967). The If 711 to Power, Ncw York: Random Housc.
  150. (2005). The Intellectual, doi
  151. (1978). The Jew as Pariah,
  152. (1990). The Logic ofPractice,
  153. (1963). The Making ofthe English If brking Class,
  154. (1980). The Master Thinkers, doi
  155. (1989). The New Conservatism,
  156. (1979). The Nouvelle Philosophie and Foucault', doi
  157. (1993). The Passion ofMichel Foucault,
  158. (1979). The Pathos of Novelty: Hannah Arendt's Image of Freedom in the Modern World',
  159. (1987). The Philosophical Discourse ofAfodernitY,
  160. (1986). The political Existentialism of Hannah Arendt', in Permanent Exiles,
  161. (1994). The Political Philosophy ofHannah Arendt,
  162. (1988). The Political Technology of Individuals',
  163. (1990). The Politics of Being: The Political Thought ofAfartin Heidegger, Ncw York: doi
  164. (1986). The Politics of Mchcl Foucault',
  165. (1976). The Portable Nietzsche, doi
  166. (1984). The Poshnodern Condition, Manchestcr:
  167. (2003). The Prince, London: Penguin Books.
  168. (1986). The Principle ofHope,
  169. (1994). The Profession and Vocation of Politics',
  170. (1976). The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, London: Gcorgc Allcn
  171. (2001). The Reckless Min& Intellectuals in Politics,
  172. (2003). The Reluctant Modernism of Hannah Arendt, Sccond Edition, doi
  173. (1989). The Role of Intellectuals in the Modem World', doi
  174. (1993). The Sociology of Intellectuals', doi
  175. (1983). The Subject and Power', doi
  176. (1973). Theory and Practice, doi
  177. (1984). Thinking and Moral Considerations',
  178. (1975). Truth andAfethod,
  179. (1989). Unruly Practices, doi
  180. (1996). What is CritiqueT,
  181. (1986). What is MaturityT,
  182. (2000). Within Four Walls',
  183. (1978). Writing and Difference, doi
  184. (1983). Xfichel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics, Second Edition, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.