Location of Repository

An exploration of the dialectic between theory and method in ethnography

By Sam Hillyard

Abstract

The thesis poses three core questions:\ud 1. What is ethnography?\ud 2. What is the role of theory in ethnography?\ud 3. What (and how) can ethnography contribute to the cumulative development of sociologieal theory?\ud The thesis develops a reflexive awareness of the persuasiveness of the theory-method dialectic in ethnography. It explores the processes through which ethnography generates knowledge through social research and hence the basis upon which ethnography rests its claims about the social world. The thesis conducts a specific case study of one ethnographic 'theory' that was developed through a series of classic ethnographic research monographs. The context of the theory in relation to the historical development of ethnography is evaluated and an area for further theoretical development identified.\ud This area was then tested in new, original fieldwork with the aim to contribute to further theoretical cumulation. The thesis offers two conclusions. The first considers what lessons have been learned through the approach to theorising used by the thesis and if it represents a model for future ethnographic research to follow. The final conclusion of the thesis calls for a greater awareness of the capacity of ethnography to contribute to theory cumulation. It suggests the role of theory has become more implicit than explicit. However, the ethnographic research conducted here has, albeit in one small case study, acknowledged the potential of theory for ethnography. This is vital if ethnography is to offer a sophisticated approach to social research and to contribute to sociological knowledge

Topics: GN
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1241

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1984,2 nd edition) [1977] Sociological research methods: an introduction.
  2. (1992,2 nd edition) Modem Social Theoryfrom Parsons to Habennas.
  3. (1996). 1 don't eat peas anyway! Classroom stories and the social construction of childhood, '
  4. (1966). 19301 Thejack-rollen a delinquent boy's own story. doi
  5. (1982). 19421 The Outsider.
  6. (1987). 19451 Animal Farm. The complete works of
  7. (1988). A Brief History of Time. doi
  8. (1996). A Case ofNeglect?
  9. (1979). A critique of Goffman and Berger's cynical sociology. '
  10. (1967). A Diary in the Strict Sense of the Tenn. doi
  11. (1973). A Glasgow Gang Observed. doi
  12. (1999). A history ofsociological research methods in America, 1920-1960. Cambridge, doi
  13. (1978). All things hright and heautiful? A sociological study of infants' classrooms. doi
  14. (1993). An interview with Erving Goffman, doi
  15. (1894). An Introduction to the Study of Society. doi
  16. (1986). Appraising Goffman, doi
  17. (1998). Are you a girl or are you a teacher? ' The 'Least Adult'
  18. (1922). Argonauts of the
  19. (1961). Asylums. doi
  20. (1984). Autobiographical Accounts and Research Experience, '
  21. (1981). Beachside Comprehensive. A Case-Study of Secondary Schooling. Cambridge, doi
  22. (1984). Beachside Reconsidered: Reflections on a Methodological Apprenticeship, '
  23. (1997). Beyond thefirst degree: graduate education, lifelong leaniing and careers.
  24. (1993). Breaking out again. doi
  25. (1983). Breaking out. doi
  26. (1997). Can school improvement overcome the effects of disadvantage? doi
  27. (1983). Case study research in education: some notes and problems, '
  28. (1984). Case Study Research. doi
  29. (1962). Centuties of Childhood.
  30. (1984). Changing Schools: pupil perspectives on transfer to a comprehensive. Milton Keynes,
  31. (1971). Classroom Knowledge, ' doi
  32. (1973). Classrooms Observed.
  33. (1995). Code Theory and its Positioning: a case study in misrecognition, ' doi
  34. (1928). Coming of age in Samoa. doi
  35. (1966). Communities in Britain: Social Life in Town and Country.
  36. (1939). Critiques ofResearch in the Social Sciences: An Appraisal of Thomas andZnatziecki's 'The Polish Peasant
  37. (1971). Deschooling Society. London, Calder and Boyars. doi
  38. (1994). Disciplinary Identities and Doctoral Work, '
  39. (1995). Divide and School., Gender and class dynamics in comprehensive education. doi
  40. (1981). Doing Feminist Research. doi
  41. (1971). Doing Fieldwork. doi
  42. (1977). Doing Sociological Research. London, Allen and Unwin.
  43. (1990). edition) Sex Roles and the School. doi
  44. (1976). Education and Social Control. doi
  45. (1993). Educational research and evalitation: forpolicy and practice?
  46. (1997). Educational Research Undone: The Postmodern Embrace. Buckingham,
  47. (1979). Endless Pressure. doi
  48. (1992). Erving Goffman and modern sociology. doi
  49. (1980). Ethics and Ethnography, doi
  50. (1983). Ethnography and Conversational Analysis, '
  51. (1999). Ethnography: a way of seeing.
  52. (1972). Evaluation as Illumination: A New Approach to the Study ofInnovatory Programmes.
  53. (1983). Expetiencing Comprehensive Education.
  54. (1982). Expulsion in context: a school as a system in action, '
  55. (1992). Fieldwork in Educational Settings. doi
  56. (1981). Foreword doi
  57. (1974). Frame Anatysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience.
  58. (1982). Freedom and constraints
  59. (1985). From ethnography to theory: a programme and paradigm in the sociology of education, ' doi
  60. (1948). From Max Weber. Edited by doi
  61. (1993). Gender Play: Girls and Boys doi
  62. (1980). Initial Encounters in the Classroom and the Process of Establishment, '
  63. (1995). Intellectuals or technicians? The urgent role of theory in educational studies. doi
  64. (1976). Interaction in the Classroom. doi
  65. (1997). Interpretive Ethizograplty: Ethnographic Practicesfor the 21st Century. Thousand Oaks, doi
  66. (1981). Interviewing women: a contradiction in ten-ns, '
  67. (1993). Intetpreting Qualitative Data.
  68. (1921). Introduction to the Science of Sociology. Chicago,
  69. (1985). Language, Stnicture and Reprodtiction: an introduction to the sociology of Basil Benistein.
  70. (1977). Leanzing to Labour.
  71. (1997). Love's Work. doi
  72. (1996). Making Sense of Qualitative Data: Complementary Research Strategies. doi
  73. (1983). Margaret Mead and Samoa: the making and unmaking of an anthropological inyth. doi
  74. (1995). Medical Talk- and Medical Work. The Liturgy of the Clinic. doi
  75. (1994). Methods, Sex and Madness. doi
  76. (1982). Mirrors, Models and Monitors: Educator Adaptations of the Ethnographic Innovation, '
  77. (1995). nd edition) [19831 Ethnography: Ptinciples in Practice.
  78. (1996). nd edition) 119801 The Professional Stranger: An Infonnal Introduction to Ethnography. San Diego,
  79. (1994). nd edition) Qualitative Data Analysis.
  80. (1998). nd edition) Reading Ethnographic Research.
  81. (1970). nd edition) The Stnicture of Scientific Revolutions.
  82. (1987). nd edition) What is history?
  83. (1994). On Feminist Methodology: A Response, '
  84. (1992). On Feminist Methodology: Mate Reason Versus Female Empowerment, ' doi
  85. (1970). On Methodology, '
  86. (1963). Outsiders: Studies it? the Sociology of Deviance. doi
  87. (1992). Ozat's Wrong With Ethnography?
  88. (1976). P edition) The sociology of education. doi
  89. (1955). Pailty andprestige in English secondary education :a study in educational sociology.
  90. (1979). Perspectives on Education, ' Wakefield, Yorks., Educational Productions,
  91. (1994). Postgraduate education and training in the social sciences: processes andproducts.
  92. (1976). Problems of Sociological fieldwork: a review of the methodology of "Hightown Grammar, "'
  93. (1999). Pupils in Transition: Moving Between Key Stages. doi
  94. (1987). Qualitative Anaýysisfbr Social Scientists. Cambridge, doi
  95. (1993). Qualitative Data Analysis. doi
  96. (1993). Qualitative Research Traditions, ' doi
  97. (1988). Quantity and Quality in Social Research. doi
  98. (1993). Rationality and Science: Can science explain everything? doi
  99. (1987). rd edition) [1972] Folk Devils and Moral Panics. doi
  100. (1989). rd edition) [19781 The research act. - a theoretical introduction to sociological methods. doi
  101. (1999). Realising children's agency in research: partners and participantsT doi
  102. (1996). Realist Social Theory. Cambridge, doi
  103. (1993). Recording and Assessing Achievement.
  104. (1992). Response to MartYn Hammersley's Paper on Feminist Methodology, ' doi
  105. (1999). Review essay, 'Voiced and Unvoiced, ' Sociology 33(l): doi
  106. (1996). School case study.
  107. (1997). School ethnography: an ethnographic study into student experiences of the transitionfrom GCSE to 'A'level in an English Coniprehensive tipper school.
  108. (1981). Schooling for delinquency, '
  109. (1976). Schooling in Capitalist Ametica. doi
  110. (1980). Schoolingfor women's work.
  111. (1995). Schools that Make a Difference: a sociological perspective on effective schooling, ' doi
  112. (1993). Self-doubt and soft data: social and technical trajectories in ethnographic fieldwork, ' doi
  113. (1997). Setting, Social Class and Survival of the Quickest. doi
  114. (1999). Shouting Theatre in a Crowded Fire. 'Educational Effectiveness' as Cultural Performance, ' doi
  115. (1967). Social Relations in a Secondary School. doi
  116. (1993). Social Research: Issues, Methods and Process. doi
  117. (1996). Sociological Readings and Re-readings.
  118. (1999). Sociology, what's it for? Questions about function and commitment, ' paper delivered at the British Sociological Association 'For Sociology' conference,
  119. (1966). Some Sociological Concomitants of Academic Steaming in a Grammar School, ' doi
  120. (1909). Source Bookfor Social Otigins: Ethnographical Matetials, JPS-v hologicalStandpoint, Classified and Annotated Bibliographies forthe ,c Interpretation of Savage Sociqy.
  121. (1967). Studies in Ethnomethodology. doi
  122. (1980). Studying girls at school: the implications of confusion, '
  123. (1982). Styles of Data Analysis: Approaches and Implications, '
  124. (1974). Styles of reporting qualitative field reports, '
  125. (1997). Supervising the PhD. Buckingham,
  126. (1969). Symbolic Interactionisin: perspective and method.
  127. (2000). Taking sides in social research. Essays on partisanship and bias. doi
  128. (1974). Telling the code, ' doi
  129. (1989). Testing Hargreaves' and Lacey's differentiation-polarisation theory in a setted comprehensive, ' doi
  130. (1998). Testing teachers: the effect of school inspectors on ptimary teachers.
  131. (2000). The Anomalous Beasts: Hooligans and the doi
  132. (1995). The Art of Fieldwork. doi
  133. (1984). The Chicago School of Sociology. Institutionalization, Diversiýy, and the Rise of Sociological Research. doi
  134. (1988). The Chicago School. A Liberal Ctitique of Capitalism. doi
  135. (1928). The Child in Ametica.
  136. (1970). The Coming Crisis of Westem Sociology. doi
  137. (1997). The Company She Keeps: An ethnography ofkirls'friendships. Buckingham,
  138. (1998). The corrosion of character thepersonal consequences of work in the neiv capitalism.
  139. (1989). The Dilemma of Qualitative Method.
  140. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory. doi
  141. (1979). The Divided School. doi
  142. (1971). The Dnigtakers: the Social Meaning of Dnig Use.
  143. (1993). The Downing Street Years. doi
  144. (1990). The Ethnographic Imagination. doi
  145. (1999). The ethnographic self . doi
  146. (1997). The Goffman Reader, edited by and with an introductory essay by Charles Lemert and Ann Branaman. doi
  147. (1989). The hidden musicians. Music-making in an English town. Cambridge, doi
  148. (1973). The integration of fieldwork and survey methods, ' doi
  149. (1983). The Interaction Order, ' doi
  150. (1973). The Interpretation of Cultures: selected essays. doi
  151. (1994). The Making of Men. doi
  152. (1979). The Making of Symbolic Interactionisin.
  153. (1983). The Managed Heart. The Commercialization of Hionan Feeling. doi
  154. (1973). The Matz in the Ptincipal's Office: An Ethnography.
  155. (1987). The Micro-Politics of the School. doi
  156. (1984). The Old Girl Network" Reflections on the Fieldwork at St.
  157. (1972). The Phenomenology of the Social World. doi
  158. (1927). The Polish Peasant in Ettrope andAmetica.
  159. (1959). The Presentation of Seýf in Everyday Life.
  160. (1976). The Sisterhood, '
  161. (1967). The social constniction of realiýy.
  162. (1959). The Sociological Imagination. London, doi
  163. (1968). The sociologist as partisan, ' American Sociologist. doi
  164. (1950). The Sociology of Georg Simmel. doi
  165. (1968). The sociology of the school. doi
  166. (1970). The Tearoom Traqe. doi
  167. (1970). The Theory of Organizations. doi
  168. (1973). Theories and theory groups in contemporary Ametican sociology. doi
  169. (1998). Theorising Childhood. doi
  170. (1974). Tolarised cultures in comprehensive schools,
  171. (1922). Tractatus Logico-Plzilosophicus. doi
  172. (1994). Transfionning qualitative data: desctiption, analysis and intetpretation.
  173. (1992). Understanding Ethnographic Texts. Thousand Oaks, doi
  174. (1995). Walking the fireline, ' doi
  175. (1999). What criteria must I meeff Letters,
  176. (1954). What is wrong with social theoryT doi
  177. (1995). Who's Afraid of Positivism? A comment on Shilling and Abraham. ' doi
  178. (1967). Whose side are we onT Social Problems. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.