Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

A short note on the problematic concept of excess demand in asset pricing models with mean-variance optimization

By Reiner Franke


Referring to asset pricing models where demand is proportional to excess returns and said to be derived from a mean-variance optimization problem, the note formulates what probably is common knowledge but hardly ever made an explicit subject of discussion. This is an insufficient distinction between the desired holding of the risky asset on the part of the speculative agents, which is the solution to the optimization problem and usually directly presented as excess demand, and the desired change in this holding, which is what should reasonably constitute the excess demand on the market. The note arrives at the conclusion that in models with a market maker the story of the maximization of expected wealth should be dropped

Topics: HB
Publisher: Warwick Business School, Financial Econometrics Research Centre
Year: 2008
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. A Behavioral Model for Participation Games with Negative Feedback, doi
  2. A Heterogenous Agents Model Usable for the Analysis of Currency Transaction Taxes,
  3. A New Measure of Herding and Empirical Evidence, doi
  4. A Panel-Based Investigation into the Relationship Between Stock Prices and Dividends,
  5. A Prototype Model of Speculative Dynamics With Position-Based Trading, doi
  6. (2005). A robust rational route to randomness in a simple asset pricing model”, doi
  7. A Short Note on the Problematic Concept of Excess Demand in Asset Pricing Models with Mean-Variance Optimization,
  8. (2006). A Simple Asymmetric Herding Model to Distinguish Between Stock and Foreign Exchange Markets,
  9. A weak bifucation theory for discrete time stochastic dynamical systems, doi
  10. Aggregation and Memory of Models of Changing Volatility, doi
  11. An Analysis of Performance Measures Using Copulae, doi
  12. An Analysis of the Performance of European Foreign Exchange Forecasters, doi
  13. An Elementary Account of Amari's Expected Geometry, doi
  14. An Introduction to Differential Geometry in Econometrics, doi
  15. Ana-Maria Fuertes and Maria-Teresa Perez, Numerical Issues in Threshold Autoregressive Modelling of Time Series, doi
  16. Application of Statistical Physics doi
  17. Ashoka Mody and Mark Taylor, A Cross-Country Financial Accelorator: Evidence from North America and Europe, doi
  18. Calculating the Miss-specification in Beta from Using a Proxy for the Market Portfolio, doi
  19. Cars Hommes and Florian Wagener, More hedging instruments may destabilize markets, doi
  20. Cars Hommes, Joep Sonnemans and Jan Tuinstra, Price Stability and Volatility in Markets with Positive and Negative Expectations Feedback: An Experimental Investigation, doi
  21. Co-Volatility and Correlation Clustering: A Multivariate Correlated ARCH Framework,
  22. Collective Opinion Formation in a Business Climate Survey,
  23. (2001). Combining Heterogeneous Classifiers for Stock Selection, doi
  24. Copula Based Monte Carlo Integration in Financial Problems,
  25. Currency Spillovers and Tri-Polarity: a Simultaneous Model doi
  26. Decoupling and Convergence to Independence with Applications to Functional Limit Theorems,
  27. Deriving the APT when the Number of Factors is Unknown, WP00-03 5. George A. Christodoulakis and Steve Satchell, Evolving Systems of Financial Returns: AutoRegressive Conditional Beta,
  28. (2004). Devraj Basu and Alexander Stremme, Portfolio Efficiency and Discount Factor Bounds with Conditioning Information: A Unified Approach, doi
  29. Dynamic instability in a phenomenological model of correlated assets, doi
  30. Effect of degree correlations on the loop structure of scale-free networks, doi
  31. Effects of degree correlations on the loop structure of scale free networks, doi
  32. Emergence of large cliques in random scale-free networks, doi
  33. Empirical Exchange Rate Models and Currency Risk: Some Evidence from Density Forecasts, doi
  34. (2005). Empirical Validation of Stochastic Models of Interacting Agents: A “Maximally Skewed” Noise Trader Model?, doi
  35. Employee Stock Options: Much More Valuable Than You Thought, WP05-09 10. Gordon Gemmill, Soosung Hwang and Mark Salmon, Performance Measurement with Loss Aversion, doi
  36. Equilibrium Return and Agents' Survival in a Multiperiod Asset Market: Analytic Support of a Simulation Model, doi
  37. Equivalence and bifurcations of finite order stochastic processes, doi
  38. Estimating and Testing Sochastic Volatility Models using Realized Measures, doi
  39. Estimation of a Microfounded Herding Model On German Survey Expectations, doi
  40. (1999). Evaluating the Performance of Nearest Neighbour Algorithms when Forecasting US Industry Returns,
  41. Event-related GARCH: the impact of stock dividends in Turkey, doi
  42. Federal Funds Rate Prediction, doi
  43. Finite Sample Inference for Extreme Value Distributions,
  44. Firms' Investment under Financial Constraints: A Euro Area Investigation, doi
  45. Forecasting Inflation with a Non-linear Output Gap Model,
  46. Forecasting T-Bill Yields: Accuracy versus Profitability,
  47. Forecasting Volatility using LINEX Loss Functions, doi
  48. From Market Micro-structure to Macro Fundamentals: is there Predictability in the Dollar-Deutsche Mark Exchange Rate?,
  49. Gaussian inference on Certain Long-Range Dependent Volatility Models, doi
  50. Generating Composite Volatility Forecasts with Random Factor Betas, doi
  51. Gordon Gemmill and Soosung Hwang, Performance Measurement with Loss Aversion, doi
  52. Hopscotch Methods for Two State Financial Models, doi
  53. How do UK-Based Foreign Exchange Dealers Think Their Market Operates?, doi
  54. Ilias Tsiakas, Is Seasonal Heteroscedasticity Real? An International Perspective,
  55. Ilias Tsiakas, Periodic Stochastic Volatility and Fat Tails, doi
  56. Implied Volatility Forecasting: A Compaison of Different Procedures Including Fractionally Integrated Models with Applications to UK Equity Options,
  57. Improved Testing for the Efficiency of Asset Pricing Theories in Linear Factor Models,
  58. Incentive Contracts and Hedge Fund Management, doi
  59. (2008). Incorporating positions into asset pricing models with order-based strategies”, Working Paper, doi
  60. Informational differences and learning in an asset market with boundedly rational agents, doi
  61. Investigating Dynamic Dependence Using Copulae, doi
  62. Jens Carsten Jackwerth and Stylianos Perrakis, doi
  63. (2002). Lucio Sarno and Giorgio Valente, Exchange Rates and Fundamentals: Evidence on the Economic Value of Predictability, doi
  64. Lucio Sarno and Jouko Vilmunen, Caution and Activism? Monetary Policy Strategies in an Open Economy, doi
  65. Market Risk and the Concept of Fundamental Volatility: Measuring Volatility Across Asset and Derivative Markets and Testing for the Impact of Derivatives Markets on Financial Markets, doi
  66. Minority games with finite score memory, doi
  67. Modeling and Forecasting Stock Returns: Exploiting the Futures Market, Regime Shifts and International Spillovers, doi
  68. Modelling Asymmetric Exchange Rate Dependence, doi
  69. Modelling Emerging Market Risk Premia Using Higher Moments, doi
  70. Multi-asset minority games, doi
  71. Multiple Priors and No-Transaction Region,
  72. Multivariate Extremes at Work for Portfolio Risk Measurement,
  73. Non-Additive Anonymous Games, doi
  74. On Empirical Risk Measurement with Asymmetric Returns Data,
  75. On the Evolution of Credibility and Flexible Exchange Rate Target Zones,
  76. On the flexibility of complex systems,
  77. On Uncertainty, Market Timing and the Predictability of Tick by Tick Exchange Rates, doi
  78. Optimal Investment and Asymmetric Risk for a Large Portfolio: A Large Deviations Approach, doi
  79. Optimal Long Term Investment in a Jump Diffusion Setting: A Large Deviation Approach, doi
  80. Option Hedging with Stochastic Volatility, doi
  81. Phase coexistence in a forecasting game, doi
  82. Predictive Density Accuracy Tests, doi
  83. Price and Wealth Dynamics in a Speculative Market with Generic Procedurally Rational Traders,
  84. Pricing Multivariate Currency Options with Copulas, WP06-21 5. Thomas Lux and Taisei Kaizoji, Forecasting Volatility and Volume in the Tokyo Stock Market: Long Memory, Fractality and Regime Switching, doi
  85. Properties of Bias Corrected Realized Variance Under Alternative Sampling Schemes, doi
  86. Properties of Cross-sectional Volatility, doi
  87. Properties of Realized Variance for a Pure Jump Process: Calendar Time Sampling versus Business Time Sampling,
  88. Rational Forecasts or Social Opinion Dynamics? Identification of Interaction Effects in a Business Climate Survey, doi
  89. Rationality Testing under Asymmetric Loss, doi
  90. Reinterpreting the Real Exchange Rate - Yield Diffential Nexus, WP02-10 4. Gordon Gemmill and Dylan Thomas , Noise Training, Costly Arbitrage and Asset Prices: evidence from closed-end funds,
  91. Rethinking the Forward Premium Puzzle in a Nonlinear Framework,
  92. Risk bubbles and market instability, doi
  93. Robust Decision Theory and the Lucas Critique, doi
  94. (2007). Semi-parametric estimation of joint large movements of risky assets, doi
  95. Sharp Style Analysis in the MSCI Sector Portfolios: A Monte Caro Integration Approach, doi
  96. Simple Tests for Models of Dependence Between Multiple Financial Time Series, with Applications to U.S. Equity Returns and Exchange Rates, doi
  97. Smoothing, Nonsynchronous Appraisal and CrossSectional Aggreagation in Real Estate Price Indices, doi
  98. (1998). Soosung Hwang and Stephen Satchell, Using Bayesian Variable Selection Methods to Choose Style Factors in Global Stock Return Models, doi
  99. Statistical mechanics of socio-economic systems with heterogeneous agents, doi
  100. Stochastic Behavioral Asset Pricing Models and the Stylized Facts, doi
  101. Technical Analysis and Central Bank Intervention, doi
  102. Testing and Modelling Market Microstructure Effects with an Application to the Dow Jones Industrial Average, doi
  103. Testing for One-Factor Models versus Stochastic Volatility Models, doi
  104. Testing Merton's Model for Credit Spreads on Zero-Coupon Bonds, doi
  105. The Asset Allocation Decision in a Loss Aversion World, doi
  106. The Derivation of New Model of Equity Duration,
  107. The Effects of Systematic Sampling and Temporal Aggregation on Discrete Time Long Memory Processes and their Finite Sample Properties, doi
  108. The Efficient Market Hypothesis through the Eyes of an Artificial Technical Analyst: An Application of a New Chartist Methodology to High-Frequency Stock Market Data,
  109. The Felsdtein-Horioka Puzzle is Not as Bad as You Think, doi
  110. The Markov-Switching Multifractal Model of Asset Returns: GMM Estimation and Linear Forecasting of Volatility, doi
  111. Time-Variation of Higher Moments in a Financial Market with Heterogeneous Agents: An Analytical Approach, doi
  112. Towards a Solution to the Puzzles in Exchange Rate Economics: Where Do We Stand?, doi
  113. Tracking Error: Ex-Ante versus Ex-Post Measures, doi
  114. Transaction Taxes, Traders’ Behavior and Exchange Rate Risks,
  115. True and Apparent Scaling: The Proximity of the Markov- Switching Multifractal Model to Long-Range Dependence, doi
  116. Uncertainty Aversion in a Heterogeneous Agent Model of Foreign Exchange Rate Formation, doi
  117. Using Copulas to Construct Bivariate Foreign Exchange Distributions with an Application to the Sterling Exchange Rate Index (Revised), doi
  118. (2000). Vado Durrleman, Ashkan Nikeghbali, Gael Riboulet and Thierry Roncalli, Copulas: an Open Field for Risk Management, doi
  119. Valuing Information Using Utility Functions, doi
  120. Valuing Path Dependent Options in the Variance-Gamma Model by Monte Carlo with a Gamma Bridge,
  121. Who Do Currency Transaction Taxes Harm More: Short-Term Speculators or Long-Term Investors?,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.