Location of Repository

'Viva nihilism!' On militancy and machismo in (anti-)globalisation protest

By Sian Sullivan

Abstract

This paper is a further reflection on the incidence of violence in (anti-)globalisation protest (also see CSGR Working Papers 123/03 and 133/04). Previously I have argued that biopolitical militancy in protest emerges as a legitimate, predictable and human anger at the multiplicitous biopolitical violences that maintain and distribute a modern status quo of alienation and structural inequality. Questions remain, however, regarding the possibilities for violent protest to open up and dismantle the violating categories, assumptions and practices targeted by protestors. Drawing on the violences that occurred during protests against the EU summit in Thessaloniki, June 2003, in this piece I consider some relationships between a contemporary nihilist orientation to protest in some quarters and two superficially contradictory lines of thought associated with the modern era. These are, 1. assertions of what it means to be ‘a revolutionary’ as captured in the ‘catechism’ of the 19th century Russian nihilist Sergei Nechayev, and 2. the 18th century liberal discourse by Adam Smith on the traits accompanying desirable bourgeois masculinity. Both of these discourses elevate a masculinity which is bounded, restrained, unconcerned with the openness and softness of relationship, and built on the disciplined repression of physical needs and desires. This is a conservative ‘hardcore habitus’ that is reproduced rather than shattered in the militancy and machismo accompanying some orientations to protest in contemporary (anti-)globalisation movements. Such orientations participate in a logic of more violence: in the increasingly transnational policing practices that both creates and responds to militant protest, and in support for a romantic, self-sacrificing (but also self-serving) machismo in both violent protest and policing. Drawing on feminist theorists from de Beauvoir to Irigaray, I thus wonder at the potential for violent protest to engender radical departures from contemporary circumstances experienced as violating by many. At the same time, given the structural violence producing these violating circumstances, I conclude that violence, in protest as elsewhere, is likely to intensify rather than diminish in the foreseeable future

Topics: JZ, HV
Publisher: University of Warwick. Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation
Year: 2005
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1962

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (2004). (forthcoming) ‘Beheading, hostage taking and “the new terrorism”: the transformation of tactics and the globalisation of violence’, pp.**
  2. (2003). (forthcoming) ‘The evidence of images: from responsibility to force’, pp.**
  3. (2000). A Language Older Than Words,
  4. (2003). A report from Thessaloniki’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 16
  5. (1988). A Thousand Plateaus. doi
  6. (1998). Acts of Resistance: Against the Tyranny of the Market, translated by R.
  7. (2000). Anarchism and the politics of ressentiment’,
  8. (2000). anarchists go on rampage in San Francisco’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 19
  9. (2003). Anarchists go on Rampage in San Francisco’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 7
  10. (2003). Anthropology and the anarchists: culture, power, and practice in militant anticapitalist protests’,
  11. (2003). Anti-capitalist protesters torch Greek shops’,
  12. (2004). Anti-capitalist resistance in Genoa: a personal reflection’,
  13. (2004). Available HTTP: (accessed 10
  14. (2003). Available HTTP: (accessed 16 doi
  15. (2003). Available HTTP: (accessed 17
  16. (2003). Available HTTP: (accessed 21 doi
  17. (2004). Available HTTP: (accessed 29
  18. (2003). Available HTTP: (accessed 6
  19. (1995). Background briefing: non-lethal weapons’,
  20. (2003). BARBARIANS: the disordered insurgence’, Online. Available HTTP:
  21. (2000). Black Bloc
  22. (2003). Black Blocs for Dummies’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 7
  23. (2002). Call for justice for political prisoners in
  24. (1869). Catechism of a revolutionary,
  25. (2000). City’s WTO policing tab now nearing $9 million’,
  26. (2003). Declaration’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 14
  27. (2001). Directed energy weapons promise “low cost per kill”’, National Defense Magazine, Sept.: 1-4, Online, Available HTTP:
  28. (1977). Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the prison, translated by A. doi
  29. (1996). Eastern Body, Western Mind: Psychology and the Chakra System as a Path to the Self.
  30. (2004). Economic man – superstar: identities, hegemonies and economic theory, paper presented at the Conference of the International Association for Feminist Economists,
  31. (2003). Europe Aims to Strike a Grand Bargain’, The Guardian, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 7
  32. (2003). Evaluation of the G8-Evian mobilization… and a debate to be had on violence’,
  33. (2003). Free movement of peoples within the European Union’, Online. Available HTTP:
  34. (2002). Genoa Red Zone: ‘Whatever Force Necessary’ (video),
  35. (2004). Globalisation debates: bringing in microencounters’, doi
  36. (2002). Gramsci, counter-hegemony and the globalisation critical movement’,
  37. (2003). Greek Social Forum (2003) ‘Homepage’, Online. Available HTTP:
  38. (2004). Historical nihilism: the Russian revolutionaries’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 10
  39. (2003). Homepage’, Online. Available HTTP:
  40. (2003). IMC-Italy (2003a) ‘Prove Video Dell'innocenza di Simon Chapman’, Online. Available HTTP:
  41. (2003). IMC-Italy (2003b) Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 7
  42. (2002). Industrial Society and its Future: By ‘FC’ aka ‘The Unabomber Manifesto’,
  43. (1999). Laser device may provide U.S. military nonlethal option’, Defense News,
  44. (1993). Left Wing Communism: An Infantile Disorder. doi
  45. (2004). Locating anti-capitalism: spaces of capital, places of resistance’,
  46. (2002). Making the breach: utilization of the Active Denial System
  47. (1984). Marx beyond Marx. doi
  48. (2001). Masculine Domination, doi
  49. (2002). Microwave weapons may be ready for Iraq’, Aviation Week and Space Technology,
  50. Network: Britain and Ireland (2003a) Whose Streets? Our Streets! An Introduction to Anarchy. London: Anarchist Youth Network: Britain and Ireland.
  51. (2003). Network: Britain and Ireland (2003b) ‘Homepage’, Online. Available HTTP:
  52. (2003). Picture of Simon Chapman’, in ‘Thessaloniki: Hungerstrikers’ determination forces their release’, Indymedia UK, Online. Available HTTP:
  53. (1998). Propaganda by Deed, Online. Available HTTP:
  54. (2003). Reflections on alternatives, commons and communities: or, building a new world from the bottom up’, The Commoner,
  55. (2000). Self Mutilation and Art Therapy: Violent Creation,
  56. (2003). Shape shifting: civil society, complexity and social movements’, doi
  57. (2001). Shops shoulder £20m cost but the city escapes’,
  58. (1998). Stonehenge: Making Space, doi
  59. (2003). Tear gas fills Thessaloniki’s riot-torn streets as running battles mark end of EU summit’,
  60. (2003). Tesalónica: galería gráfica de la represión del 21 de Junio’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 16
  61. (2000). The body as a weapon for civil disobedience’, translated by Irlandesa,
  62. (1990). The Logic of Practice, doi
  63. (2002). The new anarchists’,
  64. (1996). The newly born woman, doi
  65. (1997). The other: woman. doi
  66. (2001). The Pentagon’s people zapper’,
  67. (2001). The people zapper’,
  68. (2001). The power of violence in war and peace: post-Cold War lessons from El Salvador’, Ethnography, doi
  69. (1953). The Second Sex, doi
  70. (1991). The Temporary Autonomous Zone, Ontological Anarchy, Poetic Terrorism, Autonomedia Anti-Copyright, Online. Available HTTP:
  71. (2001). The tracks of our tears’,
  72. (2002). The Way of Love, translated by doi
  73. (1998). The Will to Knowledge: The History of Sexuality, Volume 1, translated by **
  74. (2003). Thessaloniki 2003: the Bosses of Europe are coming …’,
  75. (2003). Thessaloniki: hungerstrikers’ determination forces their release’,
  76. (2003). Toni Negri in perspective’,
  77. (2003). Update doi
  78. (2003). Urgent forum solidarity: Geneva activist charged’,
  79. (1969). Violence, peace, and peace research’, doi
  80. (2004). When we were winning, or: developing strategies after the death of neoliberalism’, Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 10
  81. (2001). Who are the white overalls? And why are they slandered by people who call themselves “anarchists”?’ Online. Available HTTP: (accessed 20
  82. (2001). Why Europe needs a constitution’, doi
  83. (1977). Women’s Exile’, translated by C.
  84. (2001). Workers’ Collective doi
  85. (2003). Zapping the enemy’, Air Force Times,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.