Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

A case study evaluation of implementation of a care pathway to support normal birth in one English birth centre: anticipated benefits and unintended consequences

By Debra Bick, Jo Rycroft-Malone and Maria Fontenla


Background: The policy drive for the UK National Health Service (NHS) has focused on the need for high quality services informed by evidence of best practice. The introduction of care pathways and protocols to standardise care and support implementation of evidence into practice has taken place across the NHS with limited evaluation of their impact. A multi-site case study evaluation was undertaken to assess the impact of use of care pathways and protocols on clinicians, service users and service delivery. One of the five sites was a midwifery-led Birth Centre, where an adapted version of the All Wales Clinical Pathway for Normal Birth had been implemented. \ud Methods: The overarching framework was realistic evaluation. A case study design enabled the capture of data on use of the pathway in the clinical setting, use of multiple methods of data collection and opportunity to study and understand the experiences of clinicians and service users whose care was informed by the pathway. Women attending the Birth Centre were recruited at their 36 week antenatal visit. Episodes of care during labour were observed, following which the woman and the midwife who cared for her were interviewed about use of the pathway. Interviews were also held with other key stakeholders from the study site. Qualitative data were content analysed. \ud Results: Observations were undertaken of four women during labour. Eighteen interviews were conducted with clinicians and women, including the women whose care was observed and the midwives who cared for them, senior midwifery managers and obstetricians. The implementation of the pathway resulted in a number of anticipated benefits, including increased midwifery confidence in skills to support normal birth and promotion of team working. There were also unintended consequences, including concerns about a lack of documentation of labour care and negative impact on working relationships with obstetric and other midwifery colleagues. Women were unaware their care was informed by a care pathway. \ud Conclusion: Care pathways are complex interventions which generate a number of consequences for practice. Those considering introduction of pathways need to ensure all relevant stakeholders are engaged with this and develop robust evaluation strategies to accompany implementation

Topics: RG
Publisher: BioMed Central Ltd.
Year: 2009
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2002). A critical ethnographic approach to facilitating cultural shift in midwifery. Midwifery doi
  2. (2004). All-Wales clinical pathway for normal labour: a way to reducing unnecessary interventions?
  3. An RCT of protocol-based midwifery-led care 2003. Health Technology Assessment Report No doi
  4. (1993). Applications of case study research. Thousand Oaks,
  5. (2006). Caesarean section on request: a comparison of obstetricians’ attitudes in eight European countries. doi
  6. (1994). Case study research. Designs and methods. 2nd Edition. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage
  7. (2003). Change through consensus and commitment: All Wales clinical pathway for normal labour. The Practising Midwife
  8. (1998). Data management and analysis methods.
  9. (2002). Effects of redesigned community postnatal care on women’s health 4 months after birth: a cluster randomised controlled trial, The Lancet doi
  10. (2007). for Health and Clinical Excellence. Intrapartum care: care of healthy women and their babies during childbirth. doi
  11. (2000). Health. The NHS Plan. A Plan for Investment. A Plan for Reform. doi
  12. (2007). Health/Partnerships for Children, Families, Maternity. Maternity Matters: choice, access and continuity of care in a safe service
  13. (2007). Identifying determinants of protocol adoption by midwives: a comprehensive approach. Health Education Research. doi
  14. (2002). Investigation into 10 maternal deaths at, or following delivery at Northwick Park Hospital, North West London Hospitals NHS Trust,
  15. (2000). Judging the use of clinical protocols by fellow professionals. doi
  16. (2006). Labouring to better effect: studies of services for women in early labour (The OPAL study). Final Report to the NHS Service Delivery and Organisation of Care Programme
  17. (2000). Legitimation of Nurses’ Knowledge Though Policies and Protocols in Clinical Practice doi
  18. (1980). Participant Observation, doi
  19. (2008). Protocol Based Care Evaluation Project. Final report for the National Co-ordinating Centre for NHS Service Delivery and Organisation doi
  20. (2008). Protocol based care: Impact on roles and service delivery. doi
  21. (2004). Protocol-based care: The research agenda. Nursing Standard doi
  22. (2009). Protocol–based care: the standardization of decision making? doi
  23. (2008). Re-mapping client journeys and professional identities: A review of the literature on clinical pathways. doi
  24. (1997). Realistic evaluation, doi
  25. (2009). Reality check for checklists. The Lancet. doi
  26. (2005). Rules and guidelines in clinical practice: a qualitative study in operating theatres of doctors’ and nurses’ views. Quality & Safety in health Care doi
  27. (2008). Safer Births: Everybody’s Business. An Independent Enquiry into the Safety of Maternity Services in
  28. (2008). Saving Mothers' Lives (formerly Why Mothers die): reviewing maternal deaths to make motherhood safer 2003-2005. Midwifery doi
  29. Standardising care using integrated care pathways: if they seem like a solution, did we ask the right questions? doi
  30. (2008). Submission to the Health Committee Inquiry into Patient Safety: The current effectiveness of the NHS Litigation Authority in ensuring patient safety
  31. (2007). The All Wales Clinical Pathway for Normal Labour: What are the Experiences of Midwives, Doctors, Managers and Mothers? Final Project Report.
  32. (2005). The rhetoric of informed choice: perspectives from midwives on intrapartum fetal heart rate monitoring. Health Expectations. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.