Location of Repository

Corruption, taxation, and loan conditionality: a contribution to the macroeconomics of reform and transition with reference to Russia

By Dorothy Engmann


The primary objective of this thesis is to contribute to the debate on the reasons behind Russia's poor economic performance in its first decade after the fall of communism, by examining the role of IMF economic programs in the reform process.In particular, we are interested in the failure of neo-classical models of the market economy, upon which economic reform programs were based, to predict the outcomes in Russia. The purpose of the work is to offer a number of theoretical models which incorporate certain characteristics, such as political and economic motivations of both the IMF and Russian government, large-scale public sector corruption, a substantial underground economy, and a weak tax base, and which are capable predicting the resulting failings in the IMF-Russia economic reform program.\ud In chapter 2, we present a theory of conditionality in which the recipient, aware that the lender faces political and economic motivations in the conditional development lending process, undertakes a game with the lender in which the recipient attempts to undertake the least amount of compliance that guarantees it future loans. There is an exogenous conflict between economics and politics within the lending agency that determines its degree of tolerance for policy (non-) compliance. We then analyse how the donor, in an attempt to regulate its internal conflict, may adopt "rules of thumb" in the lending process which pre-define the actions it will take in response to the lender's level of compliance. The recipient's strategy depends on the payoffs it obtains from the actions available to the lender under each "rule of thumb". We examine how the IMF-Russia relationship from 1992-2002 has elements of the games we model.\ud In chapter 3, we model corruption a proportional tax on labour income in a three-sector economy with a corrupt bureaucracy, a legitimate private sector, and a shadow economy, and examine how tighter fiscal policies may result in a rise in corruption. The rise in corruption negatively affects legitimate private sector employment and output. We suggest that the Russian economy has a similar three sector structure and analyse the impact of reduced spending and increased taxation on corruption and employment.\ud In chapter 4, we modify Alesina and Tabellini's (1987) model of time inconsistency to allow for a weak tax base and then apply it to post-communist Russia. In particular we examine two non-consecutive time periods in which, for different reasons, public debt could not be used to finance the government's budget deficit: 1992-94 and post August 17 1998. We suggest that Russia did in fact move from one sub-optimal position to another, and we raise questions about the optimality of Russia's current monetary policies.\ud In chapter 5, we examine the optimality of monetary policy in the presence of bureaucratic corruption. We model corruption as a proportional tax on firm revenue and a positive function of the official tax rate. The higher the official tax, the higher the corruption tax levied by public bureaucrats in order to supplement their decreasing official net wage, and the lower is output. We find that under both discretion and commitment, inflation is higher, and output and taxation are lower, than when there is no corruption

Topics: HC, DK
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2324

Suggested articles



  1. (1998). (Dec 11,1997) "The IMF is a Power unto Itself',
  2. (1993). 0 993), "The Budget Deficit in Transition: A Cautionarv Note",
  3. 1992-95, The Social Market Foundation.
  4. 4,1999, p. 2, translated by The Curi-el7t Digest Of t17C POSt-SOVICt Pf-CSS.
  5. (1992). 46A Bargaining Model of Partisan Appointments to the Central Bank",
  6. (1998). 4ddress b- vVichel Caindessits at the U.
  7. (1986). A Companson of br-ibery ai-id bidding in thin markets",
  8. (1986). A Note on Competitive Bnbery Games",
  9. (1983). A Note on Money and the Consumer in Eastern Europe",
  10. (1983). A Positive Theory of Monetary Policy in a Natural-Rate Model",
  11. (1992). A Theory of Conditionality",
  12. (1995). Aid and Power: The [Forld Batik and Policy-Based Lending, Vols I and 2.
  13. (1987). Alcasuring hidden personal the USSR",
  14. (1990). An econometric method of estimating the "hidden economy", United Kingdom (1960-1984): estimates and tests"I
  15. (1985). An Equilibrium Queuing Model of Bribery", fournal ol'Political Economy,
  16. (1987). Asymmetric Infon-nation in Competitive Briber-,,
  17. (2000). Barter in the Russian Economy: Classifications and Implications (Evidence from Case Study Analyscs),
  18. (1998). Behind the Smiles: The Cold War is Ovcr, The Friction is Not", Congressional Research Service,
  19. (1986). Black economy i. n India, Tata McGraw-Hill, reported in
  20. (1983). Bureaucracy and the shadow economy: a macroapproach",
  21. (1999). Camdessus pleads that we at least do something. but Nlaslyukov refuses to surrender", Noviye Izvestia,
  22. (1994). Can the Shadow Economy be Reduced thrOU'U'll MajorTax Reforms' *I An Empirical 11IN-cstigation for Austria", Supplement to NNW Finwice., "
  23. (1999). Capitalism Russian-Style,
  24. (1997). Central Bank Independence and public debt policy",
  25. Closing Remarks at Plenary Session of the IMF/World BankAlinual Meetings,
  26. (1977). Coloured Markets in the Soviet Union",
  27. (1997). Conditional ity When Donor and Recipient Preferences Vary",
  28. (1995). Conditional ity: Past, Present, and Future",
  29. (1987). Conditionality as Bargaining Process. - Structural-A djustment Lending,
  30. (1998). Consolidation of market institutions in Russia: political interests and 'demand' for property rights", The Politics ql'Econonlic Rýlornl,
  31. (1988). Controlling Con-uption,
  32. (1990). Corruption and Allocation Efficiency",
  33. (1997). Corruption and Development: A Review of Issues",
  34. (1979). Corruption and Development",
  35. (1998). Corruption and Development", Fintince (110 Developinel7l,
  36. (1997). Corruption and Developtnent,
  37. (1999). Corruption and Government: Causcs, Consequences and Reforms,
  38. (1995). Corruption and Growth",
  39. (1998). Corruption Around the World: Causes, Consequences, Scopc, and .
  40. (1992). Corruption as a forin of insurance",
  41. (1987). Corruption as a Gamble",
  42. (1998). Corruption, Public Finances and the Unofficial Economy". Worhl Bunk Discus.
  43. (1996). Corruption, Supervision, and the Structure of Hierarchies",
  44. (1978). Corruption: A Study in Political Econoin-v,
  45. (1993). Corruption",
  46. (1998). Countnes'Repayrnent Performance Vis-A-Vis the IMF: An Empirical Analysis",
  47. (1968). Crime and punishment: an economic approach",
  48. (1996). Do Government Wage Cuts Close Bud,, Yet Deficits? Costs of Corruption",
  49. (1999). Dodgillo the Grabbing Hand: The Determinants of Unofficial Activity in 69 countries", World Band Discussion Paper.
  50. (1990). Eastem Europe's Economies: What is to be done9" The Ecollonlist,
  51. (1999). Economic Trends
  52. (1978). Experience with Programs of Balalicc of Payments Adjustment: Stand-By Arranocmcrits
  53. (1980). Fiscal Content of Financial Pro-(" rams Supported by Stand-By Arrangements in the Upper Credit Tranches, 1969-78",
  54. (1998). for Reconstruction and Development,
  55. (1997). Game Theory Introduction andApplications,
  56. (1995). Game Theoty,
  57. (1984). Go vemment and Shadovv Economy in the Soviet Union",
  58. (1999). Hidden Economy of an Unknown Quantity? Comparative '9-95. 'o -kill, P )e -
  59. (1990). How Corruption May Corrupt",
  60. (1999). IMF Conditionality as a Screening Dc% ice",
  61. (1997). IMF Crackdown on Corruption in Projccts", In(hun EvIvess,
  62. (1995). IMF Programmes in Developing Countries: Des(gn and hilpact,
  63. (1998). IMF Welcomes Russian Government's Statement on Fiscal Measures; Management to Recommend Completion of Revlc%k' Under Russia's EFF Program", News Brief No.
  64. (1999). IMF', ý Caindessus ReOcit's Status ol'Russ'an Proarain,
  65. (2000). Improving Governance and Fl. ghting Comption in the Baltic and CIS Countries: The Role of the IMF",
  66. (1972). Income tax evasion: a theoretical analysis",
  67. (1974). Inconic tax cvasion: a theoretIcal analvsl, ý",
  68. Informal Economic .4 ctivity, Harvester Wheatsheaf.
  69. (1996). Integrating the Unofficial Economy Into the Dynamics of Post-Socialist Economies",
  70. (1998). International Cooperation Against Corruption", Finance S, Dcvclopment,
  71. (1995). Introduction", in
  72. (1997). Labour Market Adjustment: The Russian Wa\
  73. (1985). Little Mo and the moon lighters: another look at the black economy",
  74. (1996). Macroeconomic Stab i lisation in Russia.
  75. (1982). Measunng the Hidden Economy: Though This Be Madness, There is Method in It",
  76. (1980). Measuring the Hidden Economy: A Rc% 1cw of FvIdcnce and Methodologies",
  77. (1987). Middlemen in Third-World Corruption". WorhlPohfics,
  78. (1984). Monetary Politics- The Fc(leral Rcsen-c atul thc Politics Monetary Polici,,
  79. (1983). National Income and the Black Economy",
  80. (1999). objectives met despite IMF: Putin,
  81. (1976). Occupazione e capacitaproduttive. - La realt4i italicinti,
  82. (1984). On the simple niacroeconornics oftax evasion: an claboration of tile Peacock-Shaw approach",
  83. (1978). On the Time Consistency of Optimal Policy in a
  84. (1992). Optimal Commitment in Monetary Policy: Credibility versus Flexibility",
  85. (1995). Optimal Contracts for Central Bankers",
  86. (1987). Optimal income taxation and the untaxed sector",
  87. (1967). Optimum bribing for queue position",
  88. (1996). Pnncipals, Agents and the Limitations of IMA Conditional ity",
  89. (1998). Political blockages to economic reform. some theory and an application to Mrs. Thatcher (1979-83)", The Politics ofEconoinic Reform,
  90. (2000). Political Economy in Macroeconomic., ý,
  91. (1989). Politics and Graft: Recruitment, Appointment, and Promotions to Public Office in India",
  92. (1994). Postscript to Jeffrey Sachs"
  93. Putin the Great Unknown",
  94. (1999). Quantifying the Black Economy: 'Measurement withoLit Theory' yet again? ",
  95. (1999). Reforming the International Financial System",
  96. (1998). Regulatory Discrvtlon and the Unofficial Economy",
  97. (1987). Rules and Discretion with NoncoordInated Monetary and Fiscal Policies",
  98. (1977). Rules Rather Than Discretion- Tile Inconsistency of Optimal Plans",
  99. (1998). Russia and the IMF: Meeting the Challenges of an Frnerging, Market and Transition Economy",
  100. (1994). Russia in need: To help Russia, the West must change its approach",
  101. (1999). Russia: Long Climb Out of a Black Hole.
  102. (1999). Russia: The
  103. several articles.
  104. (2000). Shadow Economies Around the \ýrorld: Size, Causes and Consequences",
  105. (2000). Shadow Economies Around the World: Size, Causes and Consequences"
  106. (1981). Stabilization Programs in Developing Countncsý A Formal Framework,
  107. (1998). Stellt das Anwachsen der Schwarzarbeit eine wirtschaftspolitische Herausforderung dar? Einige Gedanken aus volkswirtschaftlicher Sicht",
  108. (1986). Tax Aversion and the Laffer curvc",
  109. (1988). Tax cvasion and tax collectioils- an aggregate demand-aogrecyate supply analysis".
  110. (1982). Tax Evasion and Tax Revenue Loss",
  111. (1977). The "Second Economy" of the USSR",
  112. (1980). The Consumer Second Economy: Size and Effects",
  113. (1958). The demand for currency relative to the total money supply",
  114. (1991). The Economics of Corruption: A Survey,
  115. (1997). The Economics ofPost-Communist Transition,
  116. (1990). The Econoni-v qf the USSR: Sununatý- antl Recommendations, World Bank,
  117. (1998). The Econoniics of Taxation: Ninciples, Policy, an(I Pi-acticc,
  118. (1985). The effects of irregular markets on macroeconomic policy: some estimates for Belgium",
  119. (1996). The Efficiency Implications of Corruption",
  120. (2001). The Emergence of Non-Monetary Means of Payment in the Russian Economy",
  121. (1978). The Fund's Conditional Assistance and the Problems of Adjustment: 1973-75",
  122. (1999). the Government of the RussianFederation wid theCC17tral Bank Russia on Economic Policies,
  123. (1981). The Hidden Economy in Norway", in V. Tanzi
  124. (1980). The hidden economy- the labour market and tax evasion",
  125. (1995). The Historical Development of the Principle of Sur-ý,, eillance",
  126. (1999). The IMF as the United States' Ultimate weapon", Izvestia, %larch 4,1999, p. 7, translated by
  127. (1989). The International Monetary Fund and the Developilig, Countries: A Critical Evaluation",
  128. (1990). The Macroeconomic Effects of Fund- Supported Ad-j ustment Programs",
  129. (1985). The Market for Public Office: Why the Indian State is not better at Development", World Development,
  130. (1989). The meaning and measurement of the Lindequourid ccoivmý ",
  131. (1985). The Political Economy of Governmental Corruption: The Logic of Underground Government",
  132. (1984). The Questfor Economic Stabilization: The IMF aml the Third World, St Martins,
  133. (1969). The regulation of queue size by levying tolls",
  134. (1994). The road to ruin: Whether Russia or the West is mainly to blame, the brave attempts at reform under Bons Yeltsin have come to a halt. The worst maý be yet to come",
  135. (1997). The shadow econornies of Western Europe",
  136. (1998). The Social Market Foundation,
  137. (1977). The subterranean economy",
  138. (1982). The System of Administrative and Political Corruptlon: Canal Irrigation in South India",
  139. (1996). The Transition at Mid- Decade".
  140. (1983). The underground economy in the United Statcs. annual estinlatcs,
  141. (1997). The World Bank and Conditionality",
  142. (1989). Tolicý' illusion. macroeconomic instabilm, and the unrecorded economy",
  143. (1999). translated by The Current Digest of the Post-Soviet
  144. (1992). Trembling Russia: Under what circumstances should wcstcmald be halted? ", 15
  145. (1982). Underdevelopment and the Economics of Corruption: A Game Theory Approach", World Dei, clopment,
  146. (2000). Vladimir Putin, Russia's post- cold- warrior",
  147. (1999). West Closes its Wallet",
  148. (1990). Why does the Fed smooth interest rates? "
  149. (1999). Why Michel Camdessus is Intractable", Rossiiskaý, a ga/Cul.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.